60 likes | 213 Views
Node ID based RSVP Hello: A Clarification Statement draft-ali-ccamp-rsvp-node-id-based-hello-00.txt. Zafar Ali, Reshad Rahman and Danny Prairie zali@cisco.com , rrahman@cisco.com , dprairie@cisco.com. HELLO REQUEST (Source Address: A.B.C.D. Destination Address: E.F.G.H).
E N D
Node ID based RSVP Hello: A Clarification Statementdraft-ali-ccamp-rsvp-node-id-based-hello-00.txt Zafar Ali, Reshad Rahman and Danny Prairie zali@cisco.com, rrahman@cisco.com, dprairie@cisco.com
HELLO REQUEST (Source Address: A.B.C.D. Destination Address: E.F.G.H) What’s a Node-id based Hello? • A Hello session such that local and remote node-ids are used in the source and destination fields of the Hello packet, respectively. • Node-ID is “Router-id” as defined in the Router Address TLV for OSPF and Traffic Engineering router ID TLV for ISIS. It usually refers to a loopback address. Node-id = E.F.G.H Node-id = A.B.C.D ... HELLO ACK (Source Address: E.F.G.H Destination Address: A.B.C.D)
RSVP Hellos over Optical Links • Data and control plan are separated. Node-id = A.B.C.D Node-id = E.F.G.H 10.1.2.1 10.1.2.11 10.1.2.2 Router OXC 10.1.2.12 ... 10.1.2.9 10.1.2.19 Control Channel Node-id based Hello Session
Optimization Aspect • When link level failure detection is performed by some means other than RSVP Hellos, the use of node-id based Hellos is also optimal for detection of RSVP-TE signaling adjacency failure. • We RSVP Hellos are used for GR applications only. Node-id = A.B.C.D Node-id = E.F.G.H 10.1.2.1 10.1.3.1 10.1.2.2 10.1.3.2 ... 10.1.3.255 10.1.2.255 One node-id based Hello
Use of node-id based RSVP Hello messages is implied in many cases, e.g., When data and control plan are separated. When TE links are unnumbered. When RSVP Hellos are used for GR procedure. When link level failure detection is performed by some means other than RSVP Hellos, e.g., BFD, use of node-id based Hellos is optimal for RSVP-TE signaling adjacency failure. Inter-AS links. The draft clarifies use of node-id based RSVP Hellos. The ID is informational and backward compatible. Summary:ID is Really a Clarification Statement
Next Steps • Given that, • We had various off-line discussions with many key contributors, including service providers. • All the SP/ contributors we spoke with are interested in this ID. • We agreed to include comments on the mailing list in the next revision. • We would like the WG to adopt this ID as a WG document.