E N D
Results from RHICBeam Energy Scan-INu Xu(1,2)Outline:1) Introduction2) Selected Results from RHIC BES-I 3)Remarks on Observables in CBM(1) College of Physical Science & Technology, Central China Normal University, China (2) Nuclear Science Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, USA
Polarized p+p Program -proton intrinsic properties STAR Decadal Plan + 2020 -eRHIC (eSTAR) Small-x Physics Program - Low-x properties, initial condition, CGC -Elastic and inelastic processes in pp2pp STAR Physics Focus 1) At 200 GeV at RHIC -Deconfinement* &medium properties, EoS - pQCD in hot and dense medium 2) RHICBeam Energy Scan (BES-I) - QCD phase structure*: phase boundary & critical point - Chiral symmetry restoration* * Holy Grail for the physics of high-energy nuclear collisions
STAR Collaboration STAR Experiment
STAR Detector Configurations • STAR: Large coverage, excellent PID, fast DAQ • - detects nearly all particles produced at RHIC • - multiple fold correlation measurements • - Probes: bulk, penetrating, and bulk-penetrating • STAR: Perfect Mid-y Collider Experiment
Particle Identification at STAR TPC TOF TPC TPC K pd π e, μ TOF Log10(p) Charged hadrons Hyperons & Hyper-nuclei MTD HFT Jets EMC Neutral particles Jets & Correlations High pTmuons Heavy-flavor hadrons Multiple-fold correlations from identified particles!
Beam Energy Scan at RHIC Study QCD Phase Structure - Signals of phase boundary - Signals for critical point Observations: (1) Azimuthally HBT 1st order phase transition (2) Directed flow v1 1st order phase transition (3) Dynamical correlations partonic vs. hadronic dof (4) v2 - NCQ scaling partonic vs. hadronic dof (5) Fluctuations Critical point, correl. length - http://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/starnotes /public/sn0493 - arXiv:1007.2613
Bulk Properties at Freeze-out STAR: S. Das, L. Kumar QM2012 • Kinetic Freeze-out: • Central collisions => lower value of • Tkinand larger collectivity β • Stronger collectivity at higher energy Chemical Freeze-out: (GCE) - Central collisions => higher values of Tch and μB! - The effect is stronger at lower energy.
Di-electrons: √sNNDependence STAR: B.C. Huang, P. Huck, QM2012 Chiral symmetry (restoration?) and direct radiations: LMR enhancement vs. collision energy, mass cut dependence Future Heavy Flavor Tracker and Muon Telescope Detector upgrades: - correlated charm contributions - extract direct radiation information
Anisotropy Parameter v2 coordinate-space-anisotropy momentum-space-anisotropy y py px x Initial/final conditions, EoS, degrees of freedom
Partonic Collectivity at RHIC STAR: preliminary QM09: arXiv 0907.2265 Low pT (≤ 2 GeV/c): hydrodynamic mass ordering High pT (> 2 GeV/c): number of quarks scaling Partonic Collectivity, necessary for QGP! De-confinement in Au+Au collisions at RHIC!
NCQ Scaling in v2 • m ~ mp ~ 1 GeV • ssφnot K+K-φ • h<< p, • In the hadronic case, no number • of quark scaling and the value of • v2ofφ will be small. • * Thermalization is assumed!
Collectivity v2 Measurements STAR: NasimMd, S.S. Shi, QM2012 STAR Preliminary Systematic measurements of collectivities At lower beam energies, the number of quark scaling is broken. Hadronic interactions become dominant, especially for √sNN< 11.5 GeV STAR Preliminary
NCQ Scaling of v2/v3 & J/ψ RAA PHENIX: E. O’Brien, QM2012 √sNN≥ 39 GeV, measured vi (i=2,3) and J/ψ RAA show no energy dependence Partonic interaction and sQGP dominant for collisions at √sNN≥ 39 GeV
L or B Search for Local Parity Violation in High Energy Nuclear Collisions The separation between the same-charge and opposite-charge correlations. - Strong external EM field - De-confinement and Chiral symmetry restoration AAA AA • Parity-even observable, assumptions must be tested • Energy dependence & UU collisions • - S. Voloshin, PRC62, 044901(00). - STAR: PR103, 251601; PRC81, 054908(2009)
Dynamical Correlations vs. √sNN STAR: G. Wang, QM2012 STAR Preliminary SS - OS Below √sNN= 11.5 GeV, the splitting between the same- and opposite-sign charge pairs (SS-OS) disappear If QGP is the source for the observed splitting at high-energy nuclear collisions hadronic interactions become dominant at √sNN ≤ 11.5 GeV
STAR: G. Wang, QM2012 √sNN= 193GeV U+U Collisions U+U Collisions: (1) test CME with small external B-field (2) test v2 at 30% higher density (3) test path-length dependence of RAA tip-tip body-body Comparing to Au+Au collisions, v2 values are higher in U+U At 1% most central collisions, v2 is found to be finite & SS-OS=0!
Higher Moments 1) High moments for conserved quantum numbers: Q, S, B, in high-energy nuclear collisions 2) Sensitive to critical point (ξ correlation length): 3) Direct comparison with Lattice results: Extract susceptibilities and freeze-out temperature. An independent/important test on thermal equilibrium in heavy ion collisions. - A. Bazavov et al. 1208.1220 (NLOTE) - R.V. Gavai and S. Gupta, PLB696, 459(2011) - S. Gupta, et al., Science, 332, 1525(2011) - STAR Experiment:PRL105, 22303(2010) - M. Stephanov: PRL102, 032301(2009) - F. Karsch et al, PLB695, 136(2011) - M.Cheng et al, PRD79, 074505(2009) - Y. Hatta, et al, PRL91, 102003(2003)
Higher Moment: Net-charge STAR: D. McDonald, QM2012 STAR Preliminary Preliminary net-charge results: efficiency, decay, … effects under study Higher statistics data needed below 20 GeV - HRG Model: K. Redlich et al, private communications
Net-proton Higher Moments BES-II RHIC BES-I STAR: X.F. Luo, QM2012 STAR net-proton results: All data show deviations below Poisson beyond statistical and systematic errors in the 0-5% most central collisions for κσ2 and Sσ at all energies. Larger deviation at √sNN ~ 20GeV UrQMD model show monotonic behavior Higher statistics needed for collisions at √sNN< 20 GeV STAR Preliminary
e-cooling at RHIC for BES-II A. Fedotov, W. Fischer, private discussions, 2012. Fermi Lab Pelletron - Requested to install the e-cooling device - BES-II data taking in 2016 - 2017
RHIC Beam Energy Scan-I Higher Moments Directed Flow v1 Elliptic Flow v2 Jet Quenching Strangeness ET/Nch Freeze-out Changes at √sNN< 20 GeV, calls for higher statistics data!
Exploring the QCD Phase Structure TERHIC, SPS, FAIR 2 Tini, TC LHC, RHIC Phase boundary RHIC,FAIR, NICA 3 1 BES-II Map the QCD Phase Structure HI collisions at √sNN ≤ 20 GeV 1 2 3 Hadronic Matter Partonic Matter • RHIC Top Energy • Study QGP Properties • heavy flavor hadrons • di-leptons • Jets 0 250 500 750 1000 μB (MeV)
Summary BES-I Program: - Partonic QGP dominant: √sNN >39 GeV Hadronic interactions become dominant: √sNN ≤11.5 GeV - High statistics data for energy region √sNN ≤ 20 GeV, needs e-cooling at RHIC => BES-II 2) Jets, Heavy Flavor and Di-lepton Programs: PHENXI: sPHENIX, full jets reconstruction, ready by 2018 STAR: HFT+MTD upgrades, ready by summer of 2014 In the coming decade, RHIC provides unique opportunities for exploring matter with QCD degrees of freedom!
Key Observables for CBM TERHIC, SPS, FAIR 2 Tini, TC LHC, RHIC Phase boundary RHIC,FAIR, NICA 3 1 1 2 SIS300+ IS A MUST! (√sNN ~ 4 - 8.5 GeV, μB ~ 0.7 - 0.4 GeV) Region of extremebaryon density! CBM Key Observables 1) Strangeness production: * phases of the matter, EOS, FO 2) Correlation/fluctuation, light nuclei: * critical point, local-phase-space-density 3) Di-leptons: * space-time-evolution of the matter * Chiral symmetry related properties 3 Hadronic Matter Partonic Matter 0 250 500 750 1000 μB (MeV)
Acknowledgements: • STAR Collaboration • Higher Moments: S. Gupta, F. Karsch, V. Koch, X.F. Luo, L. McLerran, B. Mohanty, K. Rajagopal, K. Redlich, M. Stephanov, H.G. Ritter • Freeze-out & Collectivity: P. Braun-Munzinger, S. Das, U. Heinz, M. Kaneta, D. Keane, L. Kumar, F. Liu, B. Mohanty, H.G. Ritter, A. Schumah, S.S. Shi, S. Voloshin, F.Q. Wang, X.P. Zhang • Strangeness: H.Z. Huang, B. Mohanty,E. Shuryak • Di-lepton & Heavy Flavor: P. Braun-Munzinger, X. Dong, V. Koch, Y.P. Liu, R. Rapp, K. Schweda, J. Stroth, Y.F. Zhang, J. Zhao, P.F. Zhuang
Net-proton Higher Moments STAR:L.Z. Chen, QM2012 STAR Preliminary Higher sensitivity expected from higher order moments STAR first net-proton C6/C2 results, wide centrality bins More data needed especially for collisions below 20 GeV - B. Friman, F. Karsch, K. Redlich, V. Skokov, Eur. Phys. J. C71 1694(2011). - STAR: L.Z. Chen, QM2012