1.47k likes | 1.51k Views
20 WAYS TO OVERCOME BARRIERS TO RECOVERY. Prof. Courtenay M. Harding Professor of Psychiatry and Director, Center for Rehabilitation and Recovery The Coalition of Behavioral Health Agencies - NYC. Good Morning!. OVERALL GENERAL INFORMATION FOR TODAY What’s in the folders?
E N D
20 WAYS TO OVERCOME BARRIERS TO RECOVERY Prof. Courtenay M. Harding Professor of Psychiatry and Director, Center for Rehabilitation and Recovery The Coalition of Behavioral Health Agencies - NYC
Good Morning! OVERALL GENERAL INFORMATION FOR TODAY What’s in the folders? How to work with this information Take a break for phone & bathroom Ask questions as we go along Evaluations and Certificates at end
THE PRESENTATION PLAN Review 20 obstacles with strategies to get some answers or how to better understand the complications. Lots of resources!
IF RECOVERY AND SIGNIFICANT IMPROVEMENT ARE POSSIBLE………. THEN WHY ARE SO MANY PARTICIPANTS NOT GETTING BETTER? 2.5 2.5 – – 5 MILLION PEOPLE 5 MILLION PEOPLE LANGUISHING IN US ALONE LANGUISHING IN US ALONE
ACKNOWLEDGMENT & APPRECIATION TO ALL THE CLINICIANS & FAMILIES WHO CARE WHO SPEND TIME PROBLEM SOLVING WHO CHALLENGE THE STATUS QUO WHO SPEND TIME GOING THE EXTRA MILE
HOWEVER……….. If your participant seems to be “stuck” on the path to recovery let’s look at some possible reasons and ways to change the Individual Recovery Plan (IRP)……
Learning to play a detective !
LOOKING FOR THE “PERSON UNDER THE DISORDER” COMPREHENSIVE RE COMPREHENSIVE RE- -EVALUATION NEEDED NEEDED (based on history, careful interview, lab findings & physical exam) BIO BIO- -PSYCHO PSYCHO- -SOCIAL SOCIAL- -SPIRITUAL APPROACH APPROACH SYSTEMATIC & SYSTEMATIC & MULTIDISCIPLINARY MULTIDISCIPLINARY EVALUATION SPIRITUAL
YOU NEED TO LOOK AT A PERSON TWICE…… once with your heart and then with your head…….. FIRST TO SEE THE SIMILARITIES AND ONLY THEN CAN YOU APPRECIATE THE DIFFERENCES
QUESTION #1 HAVE OTHER POSSIBLE CAUSES OF SYMPTOMS AND BEHAVIORS BEEN ELIMINATED?
DIAGNOSIS OF EXCLUSION DIAGNOSIS OF EXCLUSION (especially schizophrenia) (especially schizophrenia) 26 other disorders (medical, neurological, and psychiatric) that masquerade with schizophrenia-like symptoms !
DIAGNOSIS OF DIAGNOSIS OF EXCLUSION EXCLUSION (schizophrenia) (schizophrenia) Autism (esp. Asperger’s Syndrome) Temporal Lobe Epilepsy Tumor Stroke
MORE THINGS TO EXCLUDE Brain Trauma Endocrine & Metabolic Disorders (e.g. acute intermittent porphyria (liver enzyme) Homocystinuria (a disorder of amino acid metabolism)
MORE THINGS TO EXCLUDE Vitamin Deficiency (e.g. B 12) Central Nervous System Infectious Processes (e.g. AIDS, neurosyphilis, or herpes encephalitis) Autoimmune Disorders (systemic lupus erthymatosa) Heavy Metal Toxicity (e.g. Wilson’s Disease – too much copper)
EVEN MORE TO EXCLUDE: Some Drug Induced States (e.g. amphetamines, barbiturate withdrawal, cocaine, digitalis, disulfram) Mood disorders, schizoaffective disorder, Personality disorders, Brief Reactive Psychosis, OCD
Differential Diagnoses for Mood D/O (based on history, careful interview, lab findings & physical exam) Multiple Sclerosis Stroke Hyper & Hypothyroidism Bereavement Dementia Cancer (esp. of Pancreas) Spinal Cord Injury Peptic Ulcer Mononucleosis Huntington’s Disease AIDS End-stage Renal Disease Head Injury Parkinson’s Disease Lupus Hyper & Hypo parathyroidism Hepatitis
SUGGESTED INSTRUMENT Basis-24 “a leading behavioral health assessment” Comprehensive Cuts across diagnostic categories Provides weighted average Overall score plus 6 subscales (sub abuse, symptoms and functioning, relationships, self harm, emotional liability, psychosis, and depression)
SUGGESTED INSTRUMENT SCID –THE STRUCTURED CLINICAL INTERVIEW FOR DSM-IV TR CLINICAL VERSION
HOW TO DO BETTER……… Take the time get Take the time get triangulated information triangulated information Get the lab tests done Get the lab tests done Reassess over time Reassess over time Pay attention to comorbid Pay attention to comorbid d/o d/o
Treat or refer other diagnoses Establish links and a little black book with other medical colleagues across the local community Work with your colleagues in other fields to understand what happened and how to understand your participant who may still appear to them to have a psychiatric disorder Health Homes are coming as networks of partnerships treating person in a holistic way Partners include hospital, primary care docs, mental health and addiction services + + +
OR IF PSYCHIATRIC DIAGOSIS IS RE-ESTABLISHED All diagnosis are cross-sectional working hypotheses Not lifetime labels Not able to predict long-term outcome Write enough evidence to “convict” person of the diagnosis into the case record
REMEMBER TO LOOK FOR & RECORD STRENGTHS Strengths of your participant ( e.g. insight? Manage meds? Manage S/S ? Uses strategies to recognize oncoming prodrôme? Uses coping to reduce anxiety? Computer skills? Has driver’s license? ETC Working with the strengths rather than deficits, problems and disabilities – that is what helps people get better
EBP:WELLNESS MANAGEMENT AND RECOVERY PROGRAM-1 CLINICIAN BENEFITS: A comprehensive step by step approach Ready-to-use materials Skills is using motivational , cognitive behavioral and educational strategies Satisfaction to see outcomes
EBP: WELLNESS MANAGEMENT AND RECOVERY PROGRAM-2 CLINICIANS RECEIVE: guide with practical tips handouts, checklists, planning sheets intro video info brochures fidelity scale outcome measures
EBP: WELLNESS MANAGEMENT AND RECOVERY PROGRAM-3 • reducing • relapses • using meds • effectively • coping with • stress • coping with • problems & symptoms • getting your • needs met in the mh system • Recovery strategies • Practical facts about mi • Stress- Vulnerability & treatment strategies • Building social supports
EBP: ILLNESS (WELLNESS) MANAGEMENT AND RECOVERY PROGRAM-4 RESOURCES: Wellness Self-Management & Plus by Columbia University – Paul Margolies and Tony Salerno http://www,mentalhealth.samhsa.gov/cmhs/co mmunitysupport/toolkit http://www.mentalhealthpractices.org/imr_mlpl . html Liberman RL et al, describing UCLA Models, Innovations & Research, Vol2(2), 1993 P.A. Garrety et al , Schiz Bull, 2000
QUESTION #2 Is there an additional additional neurological neurological impairment? impairment? Is there an
THE DEFICIT THE DEFICIT SYNDRÔME SYNDRÔME +/- S/S of Schizophrenia Come and Go (esp. + symptoms) Attempts to find primary, enduring stable negative symptoms Subtype or Additional D/O Neurological Impairments ( sensory integration, stereognosis, graphesthesia, right-left confusion, the face-hand test, & audiovisual integration)
THE DEFICIT THE DEFICIT SYNDRÔME SYNDRÔME - - 2 2 Poor premorbid social functioning Reduced glucose uptake in the frontal cortex, parietal & thalamic areas on PET scans Increased anhedonia and fewer psychotic events Earlier onset, seems to be unremitting, suffer spontaneous movement d/o, severe cognitive impairments
THE DEFICIT SYNDRÔME - 3 Deficit PARTICIPANTs in comparison to NonDeficit PARTICIPANTs show: Equal positive symptoms (hallucinations, delusions, and formal thought d/o) Less severe dysphoric symptoms (e.g. depressive mood, anxiety, guilt, & hostility) Less severity of suspiciousness Similar duration of illness Brain architecture seems to be more intact in some areas
THE DEFICIT THE DEFICIT SYNDRÔME SYNDRÔME - - 4 4 Need longitudinal information Use SDS or PDS Criteria Exclude: drug effect & demoralization Need 2 of of the following for more than a year: restricted affect, diminished emotional range, poverty of speech, curbing of interests, diminished sense of purpose and social drive
THE DEFICIT THE DEFICIT SYNDRÔME SYNDRÔME - - 5 5 USE SCREENING TOOL: THE Neurological Evaluation Scale (NES) TRY: Atypical Neuroleptics Cognitive Remediation Other Aggressive Rehab
Some Resources: Brian Kirkpatrick et al, 1989, (SDS - The Schedule for the Deficit Syndrome), 1993, 2001 PDS : Proxy for Deficit Syndrome Kirkpatrick 1996 (core deficit + no dysphoria) Robert W. Buchanan et al, 1990, 1993,1994, 1996
QUESTION # 3 QUESTION # 3 DOES THIS PERSON DOES THIS PERSON HAVE OTHER HAVE OTHER MEDICAL PROBLEMS MEDICAL PROBLEMS ABOUT WHICH TO ABOUT WHICH TO WORRY? WORRY?
OVERVIEW OF OVERVIEW OF SITUATION SITUATION 40-60 % with medical co-morbidity Not recognized nor treated Participants get “turfed” back to psychiatry or not referred at all Need primary care, eye & hearing exams, OB etc Need physical by nurse practitioner, a health history questionnaire and basic lab tests
LABORATORY TESTS LABORATORY TESTS TO ORDER TO ORDER BIOCHEM 23 BIOCHEM 23 TOX SCREEN TOX SCREEN COMPLETE COMPLETE BLOOD COUNT BLOOD COUNT URINALYSIS URINALYSIS THYROID THYROID FUNCTION FUNCTION TESTS (T4 & TESTS (T4 & TSH) TSH) B B- -12 FOLATE FOLATE VDRL (for VDRL (for syphilis) syphilis) HIV HIV _______________ _______________ CT or CT or MRI (if MRI (if indicated) indicated) 12
Some Suggested Strategies Collaboration and linkages Have a case manager or other person who knows person well go armed with information and written questions and take notes Rescheduling missed appt.s Get outside prescriptions into record
Medical Algorithm for Detecting Physical Disease in Psychiatric Patients Harold C. Sox, Jr. et al: Hospital and Community Psychiatry, vol.40 (12) 1270-1276
Some Suggested Strategies Offer preventive programs: e.g. Weight Watchers, Jazzercise, other exercise programs, nutrition, cooking and grocery shopping skills, meditation, other relaxation techniques, walking, blood pressure and diabetes monitoring. Health and Wellness Education Classes
PAYING ATTENTION PAYING ATTENTION GETS ……… GETS ……… Finding strengths in self Finding strengths in self care management care management Healthier people Healthier people Reduced mortality rates Reduced mortality rates Avoids confounding Avoids confounding diagnosis diagnosis And contraindicated And contraindicated medications medications
QUESTION #4 QUESTION #4 WHO IS THIS WHO IS THIS PERSON PERSON UNDER A COAT UNDER A COAT OF ILLNESS? OF ILLNESS?
ASSESSMENT OF ADULT DEVELOPMENT PSYCHIATRIC PROBLEMS DISRUPT A LIFE NEED TO GRIEVE FOR LOSS OF TIME AND OPPORTUNITIES THE “REHABILITATION CRISIS” (McCRORY, 1982) ASSESSMENT OF PREMORBID LEVELS OF FUNCTIONING (PEER RELATIONS, SCHOOL PERFORMANCE AND DATING etc)
What to do when people deny they have an illness? Can get better without any insight or admission that they have a diagnosis Usually aware that something is holding them back from getting a life they want If want to recapture their dreams and accept some kind of help from others or Focus on what the person thinks is distressing or getting in the way of dream Listening and engaging – L. Davidson, 2012