E N D
1. Percutaneous Intervention Inventing Breakthroughs and Commercializing Science
2. Catheter use in clinical setting
3. Technology – State of the Art (start 1:04)
4. Catheter Placement: State of the Art
5. Complications Rates
6. Technology – What can go wrong?
7. Technological Innovation: Mechanical Insight
8. Technological Innovation: Medical Application
9. Technological Innovation: Demonstration
10. Competitive Technology – Image Guided Placement
11. Advantages of Technology
12. Top Three Selections Fistula for kidney dialysis
High frequency
High complication rate and cost of complication
Large market
Reliable reimbursement by Medicare for dialysis
The “centesis” procedures (Pericardio, pleural, amnio)
Costly complications
Vascular Access
Large market
High frequency of complications because often performed by novices
13. Fistula
14. Final Recommendation Capital needs: $0.5 - $1 million for additional proof-of-concept data to reach a viable exit event
Current data: 1 porcine model, PoC established
Need small trial in humans: safety and PoC data
Reasons the option to pursue independent company model difficult
Low margins in Dialysis procedures, because Medicare supported
No premium pricing on devices, no room to undercut competition
Customers heavily concentrated in large organizations
Difficult to compete with large players in these channels
Licensing deal
~$5-10M upfront plus single-digit royalty on sales
Implies 1.3-2.5x return on invested capital of $1 million
15. IP Key Facts:
Priority date reserved: Feb 7, 2007
Filed International application Feb 7, 2008
International search report pending
Coverage
Broad claims which encompass vessels, organs, and body cavities
Both product and method claims which describe the steps in operating prototype device
Validity
Inventor does not know of any prior art that invalidates claims
No opinions yet from patent office
Freedom to Operate
Search of Google patents and WIPO database for broad claims in cannulation, percutaneous intervention, catheterization did not reveal any major findings
Possibility of combining our product with other technologies that will need to be licensed
16. INDEX
17. Fistula
18. Fistula Fistula provides access for hemodialysis
Nurse uses needles for cannulation
Needle overshooting ? bleeding and hematoma ? infiltration ? access dysfunction ?hospitalization for catheter placement ? catheter related infection
Overshooting depends on quality of dialysis staff
19. TEAM
20. Problem: Catheter Placement Multiple step process which requires time to carry out successfully
Operator expertise dependent
Small part of entire clinical experience but can lead to complications which extend hospital stay and increase healthcare burden
21. Complications Mechanical
Pneumothroax – collapsed lung, requiring insertion of chest tube
Hemothorax – blood in pleural cavity
Hematoma - collection of blood outside the blood vessels, could require blood transfusion or surgery
Arterial puncture
22. Criteria for Evaluating Clinical Procedures Time it takes for the procedure to be executed
Complication rates involved in procedure
Frequency of procedures
Current standard of care for procedure
Reimbursement landscape
Other relevant factors
23. Summary of Applications Considered
24. Summary of Applications Considered
25. Channel Strategy 63% of all patients treated by one of the four large dialysis organizations
Per year: DaVita (94K patients), Dialysis Clinics Inc. (13K patients), Fresenius (111K patients )
Hospital-based clinics treated 40K patients in 2006, a drop of 6% despite a 1.3% growth in the number of hospital-based units
Independent clinics treated 65K patients in 2006 and saw an 9% increase in unit and patient counts
Small dialysis organizations (20-29 clinics) accounted for 24K patients in 2006
Renal Advantage, Satellite Healthcare, Renal Research Institute, Dialysis Corp. of America, National Renal Institutes, National Renal Alliance and American Renal Associates
26. Market Opportunity Capital needs: $0.5 - $1 million for additional proof-of-concept data
Current data: 1 porcine model, PoC established
Need small trial in humans: safety and PoC data
Premarket notification 510(k), not PMA
Only substantial equivalence needed
Shorter and cheaper development timeline
Injection device market of ~$2B in US and $4B worldwide
Includes renal, coronary, and infusion
US syringes and needles ~ $1B market opportunity
27. Startup? >500K End-stage Renal Disease (ESRD) patients receiving therapy., growing at 4%
$23 billion spend by Medicare p.a., over $33 billion total
Large market opportunity, but large gorilla payor
Low margins in Dialysis procedures, because Medicare supported
No premium pricing on devices, no room to undercut competition
Customers heavily concentrated in large organizations
Difficult to compete with large players in these channels
Product not as valuable alone in a salesforce’s bag
Could gain pricing power by combining with other devices on a sales call
$1 million investment on $3 million pre-money
28. License? Potential Partners:
Distributors and device players: Cardinal Health, Tyco, needle companies
Customers: Davita, Dialysis Clinics Inc. Fresenius
Need easy math for corporate partners: how does this contribute to net income?
Licensing deal:
~$5-10M upfront plus single-digit royalty on sales
Implies 1.3-2.5x return on invested capital of $1 million
29. Interviews Conducted Dr. Tamara Isakova (Nephrologist)
Dr. Diane Sacco (Urologist)
Dr. Steven Wu (Interventional Nephrologist)
Dr. Raul Uppot (Abdominal Interventional Radiologist)
Dr. Benjamin Medoff (Pulmonary Medicine and Intensive Care)
Dr. Kathleen Corey (Gastroenterologist)
Dr. Stephan Wicky (Interventional Radiologist)
Dr. Faisal Merchant (Interventional Cardiologist)
Dr. Thomas Wolf (Neuro-Ophthalmologist)
Dr. Kiran Reddy (Neurologist)
Dr. Ugwuji Maduekwe – TBD
Dr. Mark Conrad - TBD
30. References Avgerinos DV et al. Management of endoscopic retrograde
cholangiopancreatography: related duodenal perforations. Surg Endosc 2008.
Holzmann M et al. Complication rate of right ventricular endomyocardial biopsy
via the femoral approach: a retrospective and prospective study analyzing 3048
diagnostic procedures over an 11-year period. Circulation 2008;118:1722-8
Liang SJ et al. Application of ultrasound-guided pigtail catheter for drainage of
pleural effusions in the ICU. Intensive Care Med 2008.
Klein SV et al. CT directed diagnostic and therapeutic pericardiocentesis: 8-
year experience at a single institution. Emergency Radiology 2005; 11: 353 –
363
McGee DC, Gould MK. Preventing complications of central venous
catheterization. NEJM 2003
31. References Myers RP et al. Utilization rates, complications and costs of percutaneous liver
biopsy: a population-based study including 4275 biopsies. Liver Int 2008
28:705-12.
Skolarikos A et al. Ultrasound-guided percutaneous nephrostomy performed by
urologists: 10 year experience. Urology 2006
Raad II and Bodey GP. Infectious complications of indwelling vascular
Catheters. Clin Infec Dis 1992; 15: 197-210
Weber A et al. Complications of percutaneous transhepatic biliary drainage in
patients with dilated and nondilated intrahepatic bile ducts. Eur J Radiol 2008
Wu Y et al. Ventriculoperitoneal shunt complications in California: 1990 to
2000. Neurosurgery 2007;61:557-62