1 / 13

From academic profession to higher education workforce: academic careers in the UK

From academic profession to higher education workforce: academic careers in the UK. Based on a forthcoming article by John Brennan, Monica Franco and Rajani Naidoo. CAP project. Changing nature of the Academic Profession

rainer
Download Presentation

From academic profession to higher education workforce: academic careers in the UK

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. From academic profession to higher education workforce: academic careers in the UK Based on a forthcoming article by John Brennan, Monica Franco and RajaniNaidoo

  2. CAP project • Changing nature of the Academic Profession • Initiated early 2000 as a follow up to the 1992 Carnegie Study on the Academic Profession • Totally bottom up driven project, no central funding, academic collaboration • One common questionnaire, limited national variations • Initially 18 countries, subsequently evolved to 25+ countries • On-line survey launched in participating countries 2007-08 • Respondents for practical reasons limited to ‘regular’ university academic staff; casual/sessional staff excluded • Reasonable response rates that allow for generalisations • Book series “The Changing Academy” with Springer Publishers

  3. Some distinctive UK features • Traditional autonomy and authority at institutional levels • State and professorial levels of authority weaker than in many places • A high degree of ‘vertical’ institutional differentiation • No binary distinctions • Traditions of academic freedom

  4. Changing contexts • Erosion of institutional autonomy • Mixture of market and state regulatory mechanisms • ‘Competitive state’ replacing ‘welfare state’ • ‘Elite’ within ‘mass’ supported by rankings • Key roles and powers for administrators • ‘Trust’ and ‘responsibility’ replaced by evaluation and accountability • Students as ‘consumers’ (not ‘junior members’) • Competition replacing collaboration • University as ‘business’ replacing university as ‘university’

  5. Academic loyalties of UK academics % indicating that the following are ‘important’ or ‘very important’ to them • Academic discipline/field - 81.5% • Department/school - 55.6% • Institution - 38.4%

  6. Academic ‘boundary crossing’ % who would emphasise the following as characteristics (“much” or “very much”)of their current research: Basic/theoretical - 56.2 Applied/practical - 65.9 Single disciplinary - 40 Multidisciplinary - 63.4

  7. Changing work conditions • % experiencing improvement - 20.1 • % experiencing deterioration - 67.6 • % job as source of considerable personal strain - 58.4 • % high or very high job satisfaction - 47.5

  8. UK academics considering changing their jobs % considering % taking action Management job in present institution 25.5 12 Academic job elsewhere in UK 53 27.9 Academic job abroad 34.8 11.4 Work outside HE 40.2 7.2 No changes considered 23.5

  9. UK academics’ views on their institutions % agreeing or strongly agreeing that…… • Strong emphasis on ‘mission’ - 61.9 • Good communications between management and academics - 22.9 • Top-down management - 71.7 • Collegial decision-making - 20.6 • Strong performance emphasis - 68.1 • Cumbersome administration - 76.7

  10. UK academics’ views on their profession % agreeing or strongly agreeing that….. • Poor time to begin an academic career 50.7 • Would not now become an academic 22.5 • Job is considerable source of strain 58.4

  11. Some comparative perspectives(based on CAP project data) ‘Unusual’ features of UK being…… • High sense of deteriorating working conditions, especially among older, established academics • Substantial differences in ‘satisfaction’ levels between older and younger academics with latter more satisfied • The relatively high number of teaching hours

  12. Some more comparative perspectives(based on CAP project data) • UK academics ‘most likely’ to have considered changing jobs • Overall job satisfaction lowest in UK • Greatest perceived decline in working conditions • Most ‘top down’ style of management • Worst communication between academics and management • Lowest perceived competence of top level administrators and least informed about institutional developments • Highest proportion saying ‘wouldn’t choose to be an academic again’ • UK academics ‘lowest’ in loyalty to institution

  13. Some questions…… • Defining an ‘academic’ • Defining ‘profession’ • Institutional, subject and generational differences • Collaborative v competitive relationships • Changing career routes • Changing boundaries and ‘new professions’

More Related