310 likes | 342 Views
NITROGEN FIXATION IN THE EQUATORIAL PACIFIC: RATES, DIVERSITY, NUTRIENT LIMITATION AND BIOGEOCHEMICAL IMPLICATIONS. EUC-Fe Kilo Moana Cruise 0625 Data Workshop, Seattle. Sophie Bonnet WiSE Postdoctoral Fellow University of Southern California - Los Angeles.
E N D
NITROGEN FIXATION IN THE EQUATORIAL PACIFIC: RATES, DIVERSITY, NUTRIENT LIMITATION AND BIOGEOCHEMICAL IMPLICATIONS EUC-Fe Kilo Moana Cruise 0625 Data Workshop, Seattle Sophie Bonnet WiSE Postdoctoral Fellow University of Southern California - Los Angeles Doug Capone Lab, Department of Biological Sciences 18-19 September 2007
NITROGEN FIXATION: WHY DO WE CARE? N2 Endless source of nitrogen atmosphere ocean N2 + 8H + + 8e- 2 NH3+ H2 NH3 ‘New’ Nitrogen Prokaryotes Sustains ‘new’ primary production Diazotrophs (prokaryotes)
NITROGEN FIXATION: WHY DO WE CARE? ‘New’ Nitrogen Prokaryotes Sustains ‘new’ primary production ≥ NO3- from diapycnal diffusion (Capone et al., 2005) Up to 50% (Karl et al., 1997)
EVOLUTION IN THE PERCEPTION OF N2 FIXATION Large cyanobacteria (> 10µm) - Trichodesmium Explain only 40-59% of nitrogen fixation predited by geochemical methods (N*, stable isotopes) (Mahaffey et al., 2005) Small cyanobacteria (< 10µm) - Crocosphaera Contribution ≥ Trichodesmium(Zehr et al., 2001) Sustain 10% of global NPP (Montoya et al., 2004) Very few data on these organisms (postdoc)
N2 FIXATION IN THE EQUATORIAL PACIFIC N2 fixation suggested in the warm pool: - delta 15N settling particles (Yoshikawa et al., 2005) - total organic nitrogen measurements (Hansell and Feely, 2000) No direct measurements Surface [nitrate] gradient (S. Pal) Surface DFe gradient (L. Ossiander)
PROTOCOLE Labelling technique: 15N2 (Montoya et al. 1996) 15N (atom %) Europa Integracontinuous flow mass spectrometer Incubation in presence of 15N2gas Gentle filtrations (2 size fractions)
PROTOCOLE • Equatorial stations • Vertical profiles (50% - 10% - 1% - 0.1% surface irradiance) • Each depth: • total N2 fixation (2 replicates) • size fractionnation (2 replicates per fraction) • > 10µm • < 10µm
TRACE METAL CLEAN CONDITIONS!!! N2 NITROGENASE N2 + 8H + + 8e- 2 NH3+ H2 NH3 Fe-Mo protein (7 Fe atoms) Diazotrophs: 10-fold higher Fe requirements than than non diazotrophic phytopk Station 25 TMC versus non TMC conditions Culture: Fe limits growth and N2 fixation of Trichodesmium (Rueter 1988; Pearl et al., 1992) Field: Fe limits nitrogen fixation in the North tropical Atlantic (Mills et al., 2004)
TRACE METAL CLEAN CONDITIONS!!! • Trace metal clean sampling AND incubation • Go flo (in the bubble) • Clean tubes (Suprapur HCl) • Clean bottles (Suprapur HCl)
Before….. After…..
RESULTS (Total N2 Fixation - nmol N.l-1.h-1) Mean = 0.71 nmol N.l-1.d-1 Mean = 2.3 nmol N.l-1.d-1
RESULTS (Size fractionnation) = 25% of Total N2 fixation > 10µm Adrian Marchetti
RESULTS (Size fractionnation) = 25% of Total N2 fixation > 10µm Characterisation of the assemblage by molecular tools = 75% of Total N2 fixation < 10µm
RESULTS - Molecular data Collaboration Isabelle Biegala - IRD Marseille (France) 3 size fractions >10µm 3-10µm 0.2-3µm TSA-FISH technique: whole cell specific fluorescent probes hybridization (Biegala et al. 2003, 2005). Abundance of unicellular diazotroph in each size fraction
RESULTS - molecular data Micro- fraction Nano- fraction Pico- fraction Dominance of pico diazotrophs
RESULTS - molecular data Free picodiazotrophs (station 18) Symbiosis with dinoflagelates (stations 10 & 27) Tricho (station 27) Pictures from Isabelle Biegala
RESULTS - molecular data • Summary • 75% of N2 fixation occurs in the small size fraction • molecular data : small size fraction = pico diazotrophs (free or attached) • Cf lagon noumea (Biegala et al., in rev) micro nano pico
BIOGEOCHEMICAL IMPLICATIONS Areal rates: 32 to 268 µmol N.m-2.d-1 HNLC waters Warm pool ‘New’ N provided by N2 fixation = 2% of the vertical transport of nitrate (Carr et al., 1995) ‘New’ N provided by N2 fixation = 70% of the vertical transport of nitrate (Lewis et al. 1986) Contribution of N2 fixation to PP = 20% (up to 70% at station 14) if we consider ‘New’ PP Contribution of N2 fixation to PP = 0.8% PP data from Veronica Lance
Different species / different ecological niches? > 10µm < 10µm
Different species / different ecological niches? • What controls N2 fixation in the ocean? • P = Sañudo-Wilhelmy et al. 2001; Dyhrman et al. 2002; Krauk et al. 2006; Sohm & Capone 2006 • Fe = Rueter 1988; Pearl et al., 1992; Mills et al., 2004 • Temperature = Staal et al., 2003; Breitbarth et al., 2006 • CO2= Hutchins et al., 2007 Different controlling factors for different diazotrophs in the open ocean. Nature of limitation of diazotrophy changes over time and space
Trichodesmium dominates at high DFe levels > 10µm [DFe] DFe data from L. Ossiander
Different species / different ecological niches NITROGENASE Fe-Mo protein (7 Fe atoms) Unicellulars diazotrophs Trichodesmium High cellular Fe quotas = 30 µmol Fe : mol C (Berman-Franck et al., 2001) ? Higher S/V (x4) outcompet Tricho at low Fe? Fe limits N2 fixation in 75% of the global ocean!!!
The role of Fe on unicellular diazotrophs (Post-doc) Crocosphaera watsonii (WH 8501) Bonnet, Unpublished data Cellular quotas = 0.3 µmol Fe : mol C (Berman-Franck et al., 2007) 100 times lower than Tricho’s
Different species / different ecological niches > 10µm > 10µm [DFe] DFe data from L. Ossiander
IS IT NECESSARY TO WORK UNDER TMC CONDITIONS? Why? Fe unintended fertil? (DFe Lia) The 2 distributions are significantly different (p<0.05) Overestimation by a factor of 2 in non TMC conditions !!!!!!
RESULTS FROM Fe FERTILISATIONS Grow out exp: A. Marchetti, V. Lance, D. Varela, S. Bonnet Grow out exp: S. Bonnet • Different combinations of nutrients added: • Fe • P • N • Si • deepwater
Grow out exp No effect of Fe , P and FeP additions on N2 fixation Units: nmol.l-1.d-1
WHY WORKING UNDER TMC CONDITIONS? Why do we observe such differences in TMC versus non TMC? Hypothesis: other metals exert a control on N2 fixation Preliminary results (Bonnet, Capone, Panzeca, Sanudo-Wilhelmy, Webb) The role of cobalt on N2 fixation Crocosphaera watsonii (WH 8501) [Co] [Co]
WHY WORKING UNDER TMC CONDITIONS? Produce large quantities of B12 Crocosphaera watsonii (WH 8501) 2 fmol.cell-1 (Bonnet, Panzeca) Vitamin B12 [Co]
The role of Cobalt B12 synthesis = N expensive process C63H88CoN14O14P • Dual ecological function of diazotrophs in N-depleted environments? • Source of ‘new’ N (sustains ‘new’ PP) • Source of B12 for eukaryotes
SUMMARY • First rates measured in the eq pac: N2 fixation well established • E-W gradient (very high rates close to PNG) • - Minor biogeochemical importance in HNLC waters • - Major importance in the warm pool (up to 70% of PP) • The small size fraction represents 75% of total N2 fixation • Dominance picodiazotrophs - importance of symbiosis • ‘Necessity’ to work under trace metal clean conditions Article in prep. For L&0. Bonnet, S., Biegala, I., Capone, D.G., Ossiander, L., Dutrieux, P., Murray, J. Nitrogen fixation in the Equatorial Pacific Ocean.