1 / 29

A Philosopher Against the Grain: The Actuality of Georg Lukács

A Philosopher Against the Grain: The Actuality of Georg Lukács. Paul RJ Falger, PhD Master Student Faculty of Arts & Social Sciences Maastricht University, the Netherlands. Georg Lukacs (1885-1971). Georg Lukács (1885-1971).

ralph
Download Presentation

A Philosopher Against the Grain: The Actuality of Georg Lukács

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. A Philosopher Against the Grain:The Actuality of Georg Lukács Paul RJ Falger, PhD Master Student Faculty of Arts & Social Sciences Maastricht University, the Netherlands GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  2. Georg Lukacs (1885-1971) GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  3. Georg Lukács (1885-1971) • Hungarian philosopher, published History and Class Consciousness *(1923), the most influential 20th century Western Marxist text • Was NOT involved with “Star Wars” episodes. • *original title: Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein. GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  4. Georg Lukács (1885-1971) • Crucial philosophical texts 1st half, 20th century: • ‘Tractatus Logico–philosophicus’(Wittgenstein, 1922) • ‘Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein’(Lukács, 1923) • ‘Sein und Zeit’(Heidegger, 1927) • ‘Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein’: little known & studied (English transl., 1971), politically most important. GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  5. Actuality of Georg Lukács • Precursor, ‘Existentialism’: Heidegger & Sartre (Goldmann, 1977) • Founding father, ‘Critical Theory’ of Frankfurter Schule: Adorno, Horkheimer, Fromm & Marcuse (Jay, 1973; Bronner, 2011) • Grandfather, radical 1967-8 student uprisings: W. Germany, France, the Netherlands, US et al. (Dannemann, 2009) • Unintended instigator, Hungarian Uprising, October 1956, Minister of Education, Nagy administration (Kadarkay, 1991). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  6. Actuality of Georg Lukács • Urgently Needed: Critical theory building for analyzing, understanding & changing Totalität of present ‘neo-liberal market’ capitalist thinking • Urgently Needed: Philosophy & philosopher as radical political actor: Badiou, Todorov, Žižek et al. GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  7. Actuality of Georg Lukács • January 1st 2012, the Hungarian Government officially closed Lukács Archivum (Budapest) because of “…lack of need for further scientific study of Lukács (and his [Leftist-Messianic-Utopian] ideas)” (e-mail December 23, 2011). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  8. Georg Lukács (1885-1971) • “…Is a new reading of Lukács possible? Perhaps a more pertinent question would be: • Is a new reading of Lukács necessary?”(Bewes & Hall, 2011; Thompson, 2011). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  9. Georg Lukács (1885-1971) • “…Jewish by birth, raised in a Catholic country, and turned Protestant, Lukács incarnated alienation in its deepest and broadest sense” • “…Archetype of the rebellious son”; …His father is the key to his tragedy”(Kadarkay, 1991). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  10. Georg Lukács (1885-1971) • Rejected his haut bourgeois upbringing: father bank president, mother from wealthiest Jewish family in Central Europe • Sought & lived cultural & political alternatives • ‘From Romanticism to Bolshevism’ (Löwy, 1979). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  11. Georg Lukács (1885-1971) • Before Marxism, Lukács already was influential European literary & art critic* in mostly a-political literary ‘circles’(Weber Circle: Heidelberg – Lukács Circle: Budapest) • Becoming Marxist: defeat Austrian-Hungarian monarchy in World War I, Lenin, Russian Revolution 1917, revolutionary ‘events’ Germany & Hungary 1918-23 (‘Soviet councils’). • * Soul and Form (1911), Theory of the Novel (1915-20). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  12. Historyand Class Consciousness • Written 1919-1922 • Published (German), 1923 • Repudiated, after severe CP criticism, 1924 • Re-printed, with New Introduction (1967), 1970 GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  13. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein • Essays, reflecting Lukács’ development as radical Western Marxist thinker (1919–1922) • Rethinking Kantian-Hegelian roots of Marxism • Defining alternative concept Verdinglichung (Reification) vs. Entfremdung (Alienation) (Marx) • Opposing Engels’ interpretation of Marxism. GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  14. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein • Theoretical: What is Orthodox Marxism (1919); Class Consciousness (1920); ReificationandProletarianConsciousness (1922) • Political: LegalityandIllegality (1920); Towards a Methodology of the Problem of Organization(1922). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  15. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein • Major philosophical & political themes (Löwy, 1979): • “…A revolutionary humanism defined from standpoint of the proletariat”: • Critique of Verdinglichung • Critique of inhuman effects capitalism • Guideline for human emancipation through socialist revolution. GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  16. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein • “…A philosopher and critic: but not much of a writer. […] He wrote Hungarian badly. […] Essentially a German thinker and writer”(J Lukacs, 1988) • “…Lukács expressed himself in Hegelian terminology impenetrable to anyone lacking postgraduate competence in philosophy”(Service, 2007). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  17. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein • Footnote to Marx’s 11th thesis on Feuerbach: “…Die Philosophen haben die Welt nur verschieden interpretiert ; es kommt darauf an, sie zu verändern” (Marx, 1845-6). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  18. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein Philosophical discourse & understanding: • Kant: ‘Idealism’: Subject-Object dualism • Hegel: ‘Idealism’: Subject-Object identity Conservative dialectics & ‘History’(bourgeoisie) • Marx: ‘Materialism’: Revolutionary dialectics & ‘History’(proletariat). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  19. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein Practical-political discourse & understanding: • 4) Proletariat negates Verdinglichung by revolutionary action, creating new Totalität (cycle thesis-antithesis-synthesis) • 5) Communist Party (CP) leads proletariat into action • 6) Critique of Lenin’s view of role of CP. GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  20. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein Verdinglichung: (from ‘commodity fetishism’, Marx): • Psychic structure of man in capitalist society • Interhuman relations determined by production relationships (exchange values) • Qualitative human values transformed into quantitative ones • Perception & understanding of Totalität increasingly lost (alienation). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  21. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein Totalität: • The total societal process made up of all relations between social classes & nature • Dynamic entity, continuously in the process of structuration & destructuration through interactions of social classes • No psychological perspective outside Totalität • All elements dialectically referring to each other. GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  22. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein • Geschichte: man’s inseparable state from his (subjective) meaning and his surrounding (objective) world (as in Hegelian ‘History’) • Klassenbewuβtsein:consciousness of possibility & necessity fully understanding (dialectical process of) Totalität, thereby changing Totalität. GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  23. Historyand Class Consciousness:ItsDefence • Written, 1925-6, not published, thought lost • Discovered late 1980’s • Published, 1996 (German), 2000 (English) GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  24. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein • Lukács ‘encouraged’ to repudiate his masterpiece in 1924 • CP pressure: deviating from Marx – Engels orthodoxy & criticizing Leninist CP line • Increasing influence authoritarian Stalinism • Wrote defence Chvostismus und Dialektik * in 1925-6; lost manuscript, first published 1996! • * A Defence of H and CC: Tailism and the Dialectic (2000). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  25. Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein • In 1932, early, unknown works by Marx were published (Economic & Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844) • Corroborated Lukacs’ ideas of Verdinglichung and the Hegelian roots of Marxism • Embarassment of CP doctrine; no rehabilitation, silent career as philosopher in Moscow. GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  26. Life-Span Evaluation • Lukacs’ lived rebellious life (1919 & 1956 uprisings), courageous in developing humanistic, Utopian Marxism, going ‘against the grain’ of orthodox CP doctrine, while staying loyal to & fighting for personal beliefs and ‘the right cause for mankind’. GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  27. On the Barricades • Georg Lukács, ‘Volkscommissar’ for Education, Budapest Soviet Council, 1919, lecturing ‘the proletariat’ GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  28. Selected References • G Lukács: Geschichte und Klassenbewuβtsein (1923). • G Lukács: Chvostismus und Dialektik [1925-6] (1996); A Defence of History and Class Consciousness: Tailism and the Dialectic (2000). • T Bewes & T Hall: Georg Lukács - The Fundamental Dissonance of Existence (2011). • SE Bronner: Critical Theory: A Very Short Introduction (2011). • R Dannemann: Georg Lukács: Eine Einführung (n.d.). • R Dannemann: Lukács und 1968 (2009). • L Goldmann: Lukács and Heidegger - Towards a New Philosophy (1977). • M Jay: The Dialectical Imagination - A History of the Frankfurt School and the Institute of Social Research 1923-1950 (1973). • A Kadarkay: Georg Lukács: Life, Thought, and Politics (1991). • M Löwy: Georg Lukács - From Romanticism to Bolshevism (1979). • M Thompson: Georg Lukács Reconsidered (2011). GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

  29. Kösönum sepen, Thank You! • Any Questions Anyone? GLS Symposium 2012, USC, June 23-24

More Related