190 likes | 297 Views
Heat Transfer from Protuberances and Simulated Ice Accretion Roughness Elements. Scholars Day 04/20/2009 Steven Mart Mentor: Dr. Stephen T. McClain. Outline. Aircraft Icing & Henry et al. Small Test Piece New Mylar Application Technique Results & Conclusions Large Test Plate
E N D
Heat Transfer from Protuberances and Simulated Ice Accretion Roughness Elements Scholars Day 04/20/2009 Steven Mart Mentor: Dr. Stephen T. McClain
Outline • Aircraft Icing & Henry et al. • Small Test Piece • New Mylar Application Technique • Results & Conclusions • Large Test Plate • Construction • Results • Apparent Enhancement of Elements • Flow Characteristics • Conclusions & Improvements • Future Research
The Icing Problem • Aircraft icing is a serious flight safety concern and is not completely understood • Initial heat transfer influences how ice formations grow on aircraft surfaces • By analyzing the local heat transfer coefficient we can better understand how ice develops • Continuation of research by Henry et al. • Used gold deposited Mylar film to study the local heat transfer
Gold Deposited Mylar Film • Thin, uniform coating of gold over Mylar • Applied by vacuum sputter deposition • Highly susceptible to degradation and contamination (scratches, oils, etc.) • Used to apply a constant heat flux boundary condition
New Application Method • Need to mount metallic roughness elements to gold Mylar • Traditional application orients film gold-side up • Mounting high thermal conductivity elements creates local hot spots • Negates the constant heat flux boundary • Needed a way to mount elements without disrupting the boundary condition
New Application Method (cont’d.) • Developed new gold-side down orientation • Elements attached to non-conductive side • Maintains constant flux boundary condition • Requires consideration of additional heat transfer modes • Mylar conduction • Plexiglas conduction
Test Piece Profiles • 3.9% variation within central region of plate • Encouraging due to small size of Mylar used
Small Test Piece Conclusions • New mounting procedure verified as a viable mounting solution • Constant flux boundary condition still maintained • Allows for the mounting of roughness elements • Transitioned into creation and testing of full scale test plate
9.53 mm Steel Roughness Element 5.0 mm Plastic Roughness Element 9.53 mm Plastic Roughness Element Test Plate Construction
Testing & Data Acquisition IR Camera Test Plate IR Temperature Gun
Test Plate Results • Investigated apparent enhancement (AE) of elements • Indicates how much heat transfer has increased due to the presence of protuberances vs. unperturbed regions • Not a true enhancement measurement but still useful • Compared to data of Henry et al. • Also analyzed flow characteristics
AE for Large Plastic Element AE for Large Steel Element AE for Small Plastic Element • Material properties and size influence AE • Increasing enhancement for increasing velocity • Vortices • Flow Separation
AE vs. Reynolds Number 1 mps 5 mps 10 mps 20 mps
Flow Characteristics Large Steel Element Large Plastic Element • Flow from bottom to top, increasing left to right • Flow separation and reattachment • Again, influence of material and size Small Plastic Element
Flow Characteristics (cont’d.) Large Plastic Element • Greater and more uniform temperature profile for steel due to its conductive properties • Effects of separation vortices visible at high speeds • Elongation of profiles also visible Large Steel Element Small Plastic Element
Conclusions & Recommendations • Apparent enhancement results in general agreement with those of Henry et al. • Need to compare data to flat plate correlations • New higher amperage power supply needed • Eliminate power issues • Needed for higher velocity tests • Automation of voltage, current and pressure measurements
Future Studies • Tests at higher flow velocities • Influence of turbulent flow on AE • Accelerating/Decelerating Flow • Large roughness element distribution (400+) • Plastic Element Distribution • Steel Element Distribution
Acknowledgements • Dr. Stephen McClain • Dr. Kenneth Van Treuren • Dr. Ian Gravagne • Mr. Ashley Orr • Gilbert Narvaez III • John Miller [1] Henry, R. C., Hansman, R. J., Breuer, K. S., “Heat Transfer Variation on Protuberances and Surface Roughness Elements”, Journal of Thermophysics and Heat Transfer, Vol. 9, No. 1, March 1995.
Thank You Questions?