1 / 15

(You “mumpsed out” yet?)

MUMPS:. (You “mumpsed out” yet?). A pre cautionary tale. Gaynor Watson-Creed, MSc, MD, CCFP, FRCP(C) Medical Officer of Health, Capital District Health Authority (Halifax). And lo, an outbreak was borne…. There once was a student with cheek lumps Who knew not what to do with these bumps.

ranit
Download Presentation

(You “mumpsed out” yet?)

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. MUMPS: (You “mumpsed out” yet?) A precautionary tale Gaynor Watson-Creed, MSc, MD, CCFP, FRCP(C) Medical Officer of Health, Capital District Health Authority (Halifax)

  2. And lo, an outbreak was borne… There once was a student with cheek lumps Who knew not what to do with these bumps. So to Halifax s/he fled To go bar-hopping instead And so gave his/her hosts the great gift of the mumps.

  3. About Halifax (CDHA) • 4 amalgamated municipalities (HRM) + East Hants • 5 post secondary institutions + Nova Scotia Community College (4 campuses) • 420 family docs – private offices, not hospital based • 2 large tertiary-care hospitals (11 campuses; 10000 employed at CDHA; 3000 at IWK) • Department of National Defense – 8700 personnel, 120 hcws • Coast Guard • Population: approx 400 000

  4. About Nova Scotia • Population – 913 000 • Proportion of persons aged 20-24 – 56 000 • Proportion of persons aged 15-19 – 62 000 • 5 additional universities + Nova Scotia Community College (9 campuses) • DND, Coast Guard

  5. Where we’ve been… PHAC; November 9, 2007

  6. Descriptive Epidemiology – November 30 , 2007

  7. Complications

  8. Our definition of the precautionary principle: In the absence of certainty as to what to do, we will use our best knowledge and understanding of what MIGHT work to control this outbreak. PRIMARY ASSUMPTION: that risk of mumps and of outbreak required doing something

  9. APPLYING PRECAUTION during mumps: twice unlucky… • Early in the outbreak • aggressive case finding • aggressive contact tracing • aggressive case management • aggressive contact management • Purpose • to find as many cases as possible (stop spread) • to find as many contacts as possible (stop spread) • 2. Mid outbreak • aggressive management of health care workers • Purpose • to prevent hcws from bringing mumps into the institutions

  10. Finding and achieving “New Normal” Public Health Services Other Health Care Responses “NEW NORMAL” Activity Levels (Operational) “Denouement” Baseline operations Time

  11. Outcomes: Cases continued to accumulate Cases became “mumpsed out” – non compliance Contacts difficult to find Massive document management challenges PHS staff overtaken by OH and IC response Exhausted staff – and new programs and other PH challenges on the horizon!

  12. Our ethical dilemnas became these… • What is the appropriate response to an outbreak in the face of other public health burdens? When is doing nothing ok? • What was the harm to the public from our precautionary approach to mumps? • What was the harm to our organization(s) from our precautionary approach to mumps?

  13. (con’t)… • Can you know in advance of applying the principle that the burden of applying the precautionary approach might outweigh the benefit (e.g. during an evolving outbreak)? • Can you “take it back”? …We did, but not without issues…

  14. Thank you. Questions? “Thank goodness we have the opportunity to learn these things through mumps and not_____________.”

More Related