1 / 19

Productivity of Rural Credit: A Review of Issues and some Recent Literature

Productivity of Rural Credit: A Review of Issues and some Recent Literature. M S Sriram Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad. Introduction. Policy Assumptions: The most significant policy intervention has to be made in agriculture in rural India

rocco
Download Presentation

Productivity of Rural Credit: A Review of Issues and some Recent Literature

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Productivity of Rural Credit: A Review of Issues and some Recent Literature M S Sriram Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad

  2. Introduction • Policy Assumptions: • The most significant policy intervention has to be made in agriculture in rural India • Credit is important and has a causal relation with productivity – both in agriculture and non farm sectors • Opening up the supply of credit is desirable • Cost of credit is critical and needs to be regulated

  3. Causality is elusive • Credit is a sub component of inputs that go into agriculture • Data on credit is available largely for the formal segment • Diversity across crops, regions and practices makes it difficult to undertake such an exercise on a nationwide basis

  4. Recent Literature • Burgess and Pandey: • Opening of bank branches in unbanked areas [and thus increased supply of formal credit] has helped to reduce poverty. • Impacts on poverty might have come from non-agricultural sector • No evidence of elite capture with bank loans • agricultural loans disbursed across all land holding segments prior to 90s • Microfinance has not been successful in reaching real backward areas

  5. Recent literature • Vaidyanathan: • Increased credit supply [indebtedness] may not lead to increase in agricultural productivity • Private capital formation without concurrent effect on economics of agriculture is worrying • If credit is not appropriately directed, it might lead to deep indebtedness and distress • Focus on public capital formation and infrastructure to address the problem of productivity

  6. Recent literature • Rakesh Mohan: • Growth in formal agricultural credit has slowed down, but should not be a cause for worry • Credit to be seen more as a proportion of Agricultural GDP that as a proportion of overall supply of credit

  7. Is there increase in value of output? Is credit the reason?

  8. Is Agriculture Profitable? • Not very profitable in general • Profitability figures vary widely across states • Income from cultivation Rs.949 per month across the country • States like Jharkhand, Kerala, TN, WB and Rajasthan report greater income from wage than from agriculture • Average interest costs are less than 1% of cost of cultivation, never exceeding 3% in the country Source: NSSO 59th Round

  9. Relative costs of inputs • Inputs that might not have an impact on productivity: • Labour 22%, lease rental 5%, other expenses 15% • Inputs that might impact productivity • Fertilisers 23%, Irrigation 12%, Seeds 16% [Total 51% of input costs] • Can increased credit significantly impact productivity?

  10. Who needs Credit? Cultivators • Census data for India 31.7% - Rural 40% • Primary data from Dungarpur 25% [only BPL] –census 59% • Primary data from Dharmapuri 25% - census 39% • Primary data from W.Godavari 15% - census 12% • Backward regions have more cultivators • Financing subsistence agriculture is actually financing food security. • How are these loans serviced? Is there something else out there?

  11. Agricultural Productivity: Other Issues • Changing technology – deskilling of farmer • Inputs moving out of farmer control • Seeds moving towards research intesity • Research and Extension services moving from public to private space • Pesticides being peddled as extended service of extension • No comprehensive risk mitigation products • Downside risks are unlimited, upside benefits seem to have a ceiling

  12. Rural Credit: Beyond Agriculture • Supply side interventions: IRDP, SGSY, other “self employment” schemesMicrofinance: Supply side as it is design inducedMicrofinance: Does not sufficiently address diverse livelihood opportunities

  13. Strategies for making Rural Credit Productive • Reduce Vulnerability • Understand pressure points [Anirudh Krishna] • RCL of Velugu Project • Maturing of SHGs [Alwer] • Diversification of livelihoods [Dharmapuri]

  14. Strategies for making Rural Credit Productive • Increase opportunities through response to demand side patterns [better targeting] • Understand demand induced product attributes • Understand the space in which each player operates • Provide effective competition in these spaces

  15. Desirable policy [non] interventions • Recognise that there are no easy-quickfix solutions • Initiate exercise to understand the cost of delivering rural financial service products in a scientific manner • possibly examine activity based costing • Remove formal and informal interest rate caps • Allow banks to “exploit” rural areas • they would be better than the current alternatives • Leave operational decisions like settlements, rescheduling and write offs as commercial decisions of the institutions • Continue to remove bottlenecks for microfinance to flourish • Continue to direct branch licencing towards rural areas • Continue to provide targets for rural lending

  16. Thanks mssriram@iimahd.ernet.in www.iimahd.ernet.in/~mssriram

  17. The SEWA Framework

  18. Product Attributes

  19. Purpose-Source Mapping

More Related