1 / 65

Irish Drivers of Recession

Irish Drivers of Recession. (And the EU funding). Rejection of Lisbon treaty  crisis in relations with EU Aug 2008 Budget deficit about 6% GDP 2009 Unemployment to raise sharply… Reducing spending €440m and 2008 and €1bn 2009 Political Years of government largesse have come to an end…

sadie
Download Presentation

Irish Drivers of Recession

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Irish Drivers of Recession (And the EU funding)

  2. Rejection of Lisbon treaty  crisis in relations with EU • Aug 2008 • Budget deficit about 6% GDP 2009 • Unemployment to raise sharply… • Reducing spending €440m and 2008 and €1bn 2009 • Political • Years of government largesse have come to an end… • Tax and spend trade-offs • Needing a second referendum on the treaty or potential issues…

  3. Falling tax receipts • Curbing spending growth… • Official forecast dropped 6% GDP • 2008 general budget deficit will breach the 3% GDP ceiling for Euro Area countries under the Stability and Growth Pact • Working against the government will be the charge that it is the author of much of its own fiscal misfortune, not least as a result of large pre-election spending increases.

  4. ECB raised financing rate in Aug 4% to 4.25% • Ireland’s property market went up faster than anywhere else – inflated by growth in income, employment and population… • But there was also concurrent massive increase in supply of housing – 5 times more than in the 1990s…

  5. FT Article • Bad start to the year • Waterford Wedgwood – into receivership • Dell from Limerick to Poland • Anglo-Irish Bank third-largest lender • Struggling with rising unemployment and spiralling budget deficit • Iceland cf Ireland  1 letter and 6 months

  6. 1980s • National debt quadrupled • Economic reforms provided a platform for growth • 82 – diagnosis, 87 – action (ESRI) • During 1980s, 1/5 unemployed, 10% emigrated, top tax rate 70%

  7. Celtic Tiger • 2006 - Higher income per capita than any of the EU apart from Luxembourg • EU funding support • Low corporate taxes • Increase in population of working age • Key target for US foreign investment into EU • Every 5th job created was in Ireland

  8. 1990s - Export growth and convergence • Recently – Construction investment and low interest rates • Property market growth • Housing boom lead to increased tax receipts • Property taxes increased from 6.9% 1998 to 15.7% 2006 • Government spending increased • Consumers became indebted €36,500 twice Eurozone average

  9. Recession • 88000 completions in 2006 to 30000 2008 • Interpreted the boom as permanent • First Eurozone economy in recession in September • Government guaranteed the €440bn liabilities of financial institutions • Budget brought forward • Protests at cuts

  10. €5.5bn recapitalisation • including €1.5bn for Anglo-Irish • Government popularity falling • Ireland is considered a credit risk • Debt outlook downgraded from Stable to negative • Suggestions of calling in the IMF

  11. What went wrong • “Consumed by consumerism” • Deficit 9.5% GDP including €2bn savings might reach 11 to 12% by 2013 • Increased borrowing to finance the deficit will mean debt-to-GDP will jump from 24.7% in 2007 to 80%! • Short-term resolution – cuts in public pay bill • Opposition pay will not support pay cuts apart from in those earning more than €100k • Cuts are likely to lead to strikes

  12. Ireland’s competitive advantage is at risk • 32% loss of cost competitiveness between 2000-08 due to wage inflation compared to trading partners and Euro appreciation • Ireland has an underlying competitiveness problem • Economic contraction can be mitigated by currency devaluation, but that is not possible for Ireland with the Euro

  13. Low inflation will mean there is a need for wages to fall in nominal and absolute terms • Political issues – Ministers 10% pay cut, private companies ending bonuses, influencing unions

  14. Banks • Banks inadequately capitalised and dependent on wholesale funding • … but not overly exposed to subprime • High risk lending at home • Lending to residential developers with unsold houses • Institutions Allied Irish Banks, B of I and Anglo Irish were forecasting lower bad debts than analysts • Recapitalised to €5.5bn - €2bn to AIB and BoI and €1.5bn to Anglo Irish • But they underplaying risk? • Between 2005-2008 112 properties repossessed but unemployment is expected to rise to 12% by 2009, so will lead to more home repossessions and higher write-offs

  15. EU Reform Treaty • EU Lisbon treaty may be more appealing to voters in crisis • Voters rejected Lisbon in June • Opposition remains strong • Argued that it will reduce Ireland’s influence • Undermine social ethos and military neutrality • EU membership could be at risk after a 2nd no vote – end up like Iceland?

  16. IMF - briefing • “Ireland faces a difficult economic situation and will need to take steps to manage the financial sector and fiscal risks” • …But Ireland won’t need IMF financing

  17. Celtic Tiger • May 2007  people were sending delegations and students to compare Ireland to other countries • EU enlargement in 2004  Ireland held EU presidency  what could new Eastern European states learn from Irish model?

  18. How do they do it? • Inappropriate policies in the past leading to 1980s issues • A “partnership process” of government, employers, unions and farmers addressed sustainability in the 1980s • Prior to growth of 90s, Ireland suffered from high unemployment, high emigration and loss of skills

  19. Government policy • Support from the EU • Importance of young, well-educated, English speaking population • FDI, esp from US helped….

  20. Tax policies • Corporation tax – 12.5% low • Income tax rates have been cut

  21. Current issues • GDP 7.5% contraction in fourth quarter 2008 • Annual GDP growth rate -2.3% - worst since 1983 • Collapse of housing boom • Open economy whose major trading partner – the UK has devalued its currency savagely and cut VAT • Rise in cross-border shopping to N. Ireland • Relatively large size of banking sector and the need to recapitalise it

  22. Industry • Machinery and equipment • Computers • Chemicals • Pharmaceuticals • Animals

  23. Imports/Exports 2007 (CIA Factbook) • Export partners • UK 18.7% • US 17.9% • Belgium 14.5% • Germany 7.4% • France 5.8% • Import Partners • UK 38.3% • US 11.3% • Germany 9.7% • Netherlands 5% • France 4.2%

  24. Financials • GDP - $285bn (2008) • Stock of FDI - home $216bn (2008) • Stock of FDI – abroad $149.1bn

  25. Economy of Ireland • 1922-1990 poverty and emigration • 1990s Celtic Tiger  last two decades Irish government aiming to curb inflation, ease tax burden, reduce gov. spending as % of GDP, increase labour force skills and promote foreign investment • Join Euro in 1999 • Global slowdown 2001  due to high tech exports • Growth of 6% 2001-2

  26. Infrastructure • 1993, road transport coordinated by National Roads Authority • Rail network is run by a semi-state body • Efficiency of train network is poor  rolling stock acquired and since 2004 beginning to expand capacity • Well served by relatively cheap air transport • Several ports • Deregulated Telecommunications market – 32% share from licensed operators • 2007 – DSL available to 88% of homes and business • Broadband 15.4% penetration 2007 • 2008 – Every household to be capable of 100mb broadband by 2012

  27. Energy • Overreliance on fluctuations on access to fossil fuels  98% fossil fules • Sustainable Energy Act 2002 • Energy Production by source • Oil 55.8% • Natural gas 24.3% • Coal 12.9% • Peat 3.8% • Renewables 2.2%

  28. Monetary System • Euro • CB and FSA of I is an agent for ECB • Low interest rates of ECB have helped sustain growth • Inflation of housing from IRE£9k (€11430) in 1973 to €220k in 2004 • Big four credit institutions • AIB, BoI, Ulster and National Irish

  29. Sectors • Primary • 5%GDP and 8% employment • Agriculture - €7.15bn agri-food and drink • EU Common Agricultural Policy is expected to lead to a decline • Overfishing on coastline • Secondary • 46% GDP and 29% labour force • Initially dominated by textile companies • Now largely high-tech multinationals, Dell, Intel, Pfizer and IBM • Confectionaries • 25% of Europe’s computers are made in Ireland • Software – World’s largest exporter of software • Increasing competition from Poland and Asian countries • Particularly in low skill areas, e.g. confectionaries • Tertiary • 49% GDP and 64% Irish Employment • Driver of Celtic Tiger • Accountancy, legal, call centres, finance and stock broking, catering and tourism • IFSC created 14000 jobs in 1990s – high value finance and legal sectors

  30. State Ownership • Ownership of most bus and all rail • Ownership of much of power gen and transmission – Electricity Supply Board – considering part privatising ESB • Radio and Television broadcast sector • Monopoly on Light mail • Aer Lingus privatised in 2006

  31. Taxation • 1997-onwards – low taxation encouraging FDI • Opposing EC moves to restrict tax competition • Corporation tax reduced from 32% 1998 to 12.5% 2003 • In the rest of Europe, between 15-60% • 2 tax bands on income levels 20% and 41%, but the tax credits system reduces taxation to between 4-12% and 35% respectively • Much burden comes from 21.5% VAT

  32. Education • Comparatively very good • Maths, science and tech high • State virtual monopoly in higher education

  33. Economic ties • US • $33bn trade between Ireland and US (2003) • $25.7bn exports to US (500% increase since 1997) • US FDI has aided growth since 1980 • Ireland is attractive to US for mfg in the EU • EU • EU = 63.3% of exports and 57.4% imports • Joined EU in 1973

  34. 21% population at risk of relative poverty in 2004 • Poorest members of society entirely dependent on welfare payments • Inequality of income distribution on Gini coefficient was 30.4 • Ireland has high rates of home ownership (80%) • €8.5bn gov. investment in 34,000 social housing units

  35. Minimum Wage • €8.65/hr minimum wage (one of the highest in the world) • Income below €17.6k not taxed

  36. Welfare benefits • Unemployment benefits was 3rd highest in OECD • Jobseeker’s benefit is €197.80/week cf £60.50 UK • Pensions are relatively generous

  37. Recent Developments • Falls in property values • Large reductions in activity and employment • Impact of credit crunch & higher inflation (energy fuel costs)

  38. Financial Crisis 2008 • International credit crunch • Sub prime • Fall off in liquidity • Irish banks reliant on wholesale markets • Bank solvency • Solvency is related to the Irish property bubble • Exposure to property developers with oversupply in the face of a demand drop • Property developers speculatation

  39. Social Partnerships • Between employers, unions and the government offering wage restraint in exchange for tax cuts – providing stability in the business environment

  40. Export diversification • Government provided financial and fiscal support to indigenous and foreign owned businesses

  41. Deregulation of Airlines • Airline deregulation – first step in the Celtic Tiger phenomenon • Allowed the reduction of cost of travel • Highly dependent on aviation for trade and tourism • Previously national airlines controlled aviation at the expense of consumers • New market entrants were excluded and price competition prohibited • Irish economy heavy emigration -1970s and 1980s • Regulatory capture, weak regulatory authority, weak consumer interests and protectionist era dogma blocked market forces

  42. Impact of Irish airline deregulation on transport and wider economy • 1994 – green paper on aviation policy estimated that airline deregulation had generated 60% increase in visitor numbers • Additional tourism earnings of €711m • 25k additional jobs between 1987-93 • Volume of outward business travel increased 50% • Impact of deregulation was to increase competitiveness of Irish economy • Sea fares fell by 40% between 1987-95

  43. Uneuropean Approach to Tax policies

  44. Abi - Points • Tax Cuts • 1998  32% • 2001  20% • 2002  16% • 2003  12.5% • 2004  10% (wanted to but denied) • Income Tax 20%, 41%, €17.6 • Promoting and encouraging investment and growth

  45. Employment • 12.6% construction industry • 9.4% GNP  dependent on construction… • Gov. Revenues  based around construction… • Collapse in housing prices • 2007-2008  9% drop in properties • Demand was dropping, unemployment increasing • Sustainability of the Construction economy… • Declining domestic demand…

  46. Unemployment drove retail sales volume trend down… • 2008 - Q1 – -0.2% • 2008 – Q2 - -4.5% • 2008 – Q3 - -5.7% • Average growth in retail sales Europe • 0.5% down…

  47. Foreign Trade • Exports • 2007 - €200bn • Current account registered deficit • To private company not govenrment

More Related