1 / 9

B ig Question #1

B ig Question #1. How can cops, who can be exemplary heroes, beat people and be prepared to lie about it? Short answer : The police worldview, based in authority and danger, affects the values of cops, which can sometimes lead to misconduct. The longer answer. Several factors are involved:

savea
Download Presentation

B ig Question #1

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Big Question #1 How can cops, who can be exemplary heroes, beat people and be prepared to lie about it? Short answer: The police worldview, based in authority and danger, affects the values of cops, which can sometimes lead to misconduct.

  2. The longer answer Several factors are involved: • The police culture (danger & authority) • Paradoxes of coercive force • Suspiciousness (cynicism/mistrust) • Police view of citizens (3-fold typology) • Police view of the underclass • Siege mentality • The Dirty Harry Syndrome • Code of silence

  3. Paradoxes of Coercive Power Paradox of face: The nastier one’s reputation, the less nasty one has to be But: Police who rely on coercive force to make the world a less threatening place make it more dangerous for themselves and other cops. Why? Coercive force is limiting and cannot overcome all challenges police confront.

  4. Suspiciousness Cops are trained to be suspicious, and to make distinctions about what behaviors are normal and abnormal, within a particular context • “Symbolic assailants” Outcome: Such thinking isolates police from the public, since most encounters have no potential for danger

  5. The Asshole Cops divide citizens into 3 groups • Suspicious persons • Know nothings • Assholes

  6. Last 3 • Underclass: criminal is a bad guy perpetrating violence on a deserving poor • Dirty Harry syndrome: using bad means to achieve good ends • Siege mentality: rewards for hardnosed policing and “us vs. them” mentality • Code of silence

  7. Big Question #2 How does the paramilitary organization of police work contribute to unnecessary violence? • Implies a war model where police fight an “enemy” hiding amongst the citizenry • A “war on crime” mentality implies that this war can be won, which is highly doubtful • The war on crime model aggrandizes the “tough guy” mentality • The war mentality relegates line officers to the role of the grunt in the trenches.

  8. Consequences of Military Organization • Elaborate rulebooks are developed to create an elaborate façade of “by-the-book” policing • Officers must often run afoul of the rules to do their jobs, and thus officers come to devalue all rules and find shortcuts around them. • Since all officer violate rules, accountability is difficult for those who rise in rank and also for those who would speak up against serious misconduct.

More Related