E N D
1. BIAN2013The Neandertals: whence and whither?
2. From Homo heidelbergensis? From about 700-400 ka, Homo heidelbergensis was the species occupying Europe*
*and Africa
By about 120 ka, Homo neanderthalensis was in occupation
What happened in between?
3. The fossil sequence in Europe
4. The Neandertal features to look for Suprainiac fossa
Increased occipital convexity
Occipitomastoid crest
Reduced mastoid
“En bombe” braincase
Laterally deepened ophryonic groove
Evenly circular supraorbital tori
Large round orbits
Deeply depressed glabella
Nasal protrusion
Protruding midface
Enlarged maxillary sinus / no canine fossa
Malars slope to maxilla
Taurodontism
Retromolar space
Truncated jaw angle
Mental foramen further back, under M1
Subvertical mandibular symphysis
5. Steinheim, Germany
6. Swanscombe, England
7. Atapuerca – Sima de los Huesos (Cave of Bones)
8. SH5Some primitive features, but mainly derived Neandertal features of face
9. SH4more derived occipital features than SH5
10. Conclusions to Stages 11-9
11. Stages 7-5: very Neandertal
12. Saccopastore, Italy
13. CT scans of Saccopastore showing sinuses
14. Krapina
15. Conclusion on Stages 7-5 Most of the Neadertal features are present
The main difference: cranial capacity is less enlarged
Mean Early – 1289.1cc
Mean Late - 1482.5cc
16. How to classify the intermediates? As Homo heidelbergensis
As Homo neanderthalensis
As (one or more) species on their own:
Homo steinheimensis
Homo ehringsdorfensis
Split them according to which they are closest to phenetically
17. The composite species concept A species commences at the base of a stem along which a new character state becomes fixed
- after Kornet, 1991
So the intermediates are Homo neanderthalensis
Leaving Homo heidelbergensis as the basal species without any derived (Neanderthal, or sapient) character states
18. How far east does Homo neanderthalensis extend?
19. Maba, Guangxi, China
20. - and, on the way to China:
21. An eastward spread?
22. So maybe Neandertals briefly extended as far as east as southern China
23. And what became of them? About 40 ka, Homo sapiens began to spread into Europe (see next week)
Did Neandertals disappear because of competition (or warfare?)
Or did they interbreed?
24. Late Neandertals
25. Neandertals survived latest in southern Spain -
26. - And in Croatia
27. BUT -
29. What other fossils have been tested? Serre et al. made mtDNA primers from Feldhofer, Mesmeskaiya and Vindija 75
They tested four Neandertals: Vindija 77, Vindija 80, Engis 2 and La Chapelle-aux-Saints.
All of them amplified using the Neandertal primers
They tested five European early moderns: Mladec 25c and 2, Cro-Magnon, Abri Pataud and La Madeleine.
None of them amplified using the Neandertal primers