760 likes | 785 Views
This article discusses the design and capabilities of earPod, a menu selection system for mobile devices that is designed to be used without visual feedback. It explores the challenges of eyes-free menu selection and presents solutions such as reactive audio feedback and marking menus. The article also highlights the benefits of an auditory-based menu system and describes the design and walkthrough of earPod.
E N D
earPod:Eyes-free Menu Selection with Touch Input and Reactive Audio Feedback Shengdong Zhao Pierre Dragicevic Mark Chignell Ravin Balakrishnan Patrick Baudisch
Menu Selection on Mobile Devices Often Requires Visual Feedback
Eyes-free capable Marking Menus
Eyes-free capable Marking Menus (Expert Use)
Eyes-free capable Marking Menus (Expert Use)
True eyes-free • TouchPlayer (Pirhonen et al, 2002)
True eyes-free • TouchPlayer (Pirhonen et al, 2002) • Head gesture-based auditory pie menu (Brewster et al, 2003)
earPod 13
earPod 14
Interactive Voice Response System Slow Painful “Touchtone Hell” (Yin and Zhai, 2006) 25
Visual vs. auditory menu Visual Linear Menu 26
Visual vs. auditory menu IVR System Visual Linear Menu 27
Problems of IVR system • Speech is serial and slow (Slowiaczek and Nusbaum 1985)
System Visual Outputs time Mouse Input User Problems of IVR system • Synchronous vs. asynchronous communication Synchronous
System System Visual Outputs Audio Audio time time Press Key Press Key Waiting Waiting Mouse Input User User Problems of IVR system • Synchronous vs. asynchronous communication Asynchronous Synchronous
Problems of IVR system • Transition to expert use Skill level Novice (Voice menu: recognition) Skill development
Problems of IVR system • Transition to expert use Expert (direct code access: recall) Skill level Novice (Voice menu: recognition) Skill development
Problems of IVR system • Transition to expert use Expert (direct code access: recall) Skill level Novice (Voice menu: recognition) Skill development
earPod’s approach • Problem: speech is serial and slow
earPod’s approach • Problem: speech is serial and slow • By-pass audio
earPod’s approach • Problem: speech is serial and slow • By-pass audio • Use interruptible audio feedback
earPod’s approach • Problem: speech is serial and slow • By-pass audio • Use interruptible audio feedback • Use non-speech audio
earPod’s approach • Problem: asynchronous communication
Audio Outputs time Touchpad Input User earPod’s approach • Problem: asynchronous communication • Synchronous communication (reactive audio feedback)
earPod’s approach • Problem: steep novice to expert transition
Smooth transition • Learning menu structure
Smooth transition • Learning menu structure • Learning expert gesture Target Item
Smooth transition • Learning menu structure • Learning expert gesture Target Item Novice
Smooth transition • Learning menu structure • Learning expert gesture Target Item Novice Novice/Expert
Smooth transition • Learning menu structure • Learning expert gesture Target Item Novice Novice/Expert Expert
Expert (direct tapping: recall) Skill level Novice (glide browsing: recognition) 46 Skill development
Support Single-hand Usage (Karlson et al, 2007) 47
earPod Design Summary • Touch Input 50