1 / 26

INFORMATION & CONSULTATION

INFORMATION & CONSULTATION. Are You Ready ? Tom Flanagan 7 October 2004. Popular Misconceptions. The new Regs require you to create a “ Domestic Works Council ” - NO ! You must put something in place by 6 April 2005 - NO !

Download Presentation

INFORMATION & CONSULTATION

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. INFORMATION & CONSULTATION Are You Ready ? Tom Flanagan 7 October 2004

  2. Popular Misconceptions • The new Regs require you to create a “Domestic Works Council” - NO ! • You must put something in place by 6 April 2005 - NO ! • A Pre-Existing Agreement means that you escape the Regs requirements - NO ! • If you satisfy these Regs, you avoid the risk of penalties under existing laws on TUPE and collective redundancy - Not necessarily !!

  3. Structure of Talk • Choose your approach • Directive: basic principles • Regulations: current state / introduction • Overview • Key practical issues • Practical solutions

  4. Choose your Approach • Don’t care / too busy / irrelevant • Compliant • Gain positive advantage (“High Performance Workplace”) • Evangelical

  5. The Directive - Basic Principles (1) • General framework - up to Member States • Existing law on I&C inadequate • Earlier I&C preferred (Renault / M&S / Vauxhall) • 3 levels: (Article 4): • inform • inform and consult • …with a view to reaching agreement

  6. The Directive - Basic Principles (2) • Exception (Article 5) • Basis of “Pre-Existing Agreement” • Agreement between “management and labour” • Which does not need to follow Article 4 • As long as “respecting the principles laid down in Article 1”

  7. I&C Regs: Current State of Play • In force by 25 March 2005 • UK Government plans 6 April 2005 • 2 Consultation Papers: “High Performance Workplaces” - 2002/2003 • Current Draft Regs / DTI Guidance • DTI seeks views before 22 October 2004 • Possibility of further change ?

  8. I&C Regs: Introduction • April 2005: >150 employees (c.14,000) • March 2007: >100 employees • March 2008: >50 employees (c.38,000 in all) • Employees “in the undertaking”

  9. Overview • “High Performance Workplaces” • Flexibility (allegedly) • Obligation to I&C • Comply with Directive • Empowering Trade Unions ?

  10. Overview : The Structure of the Regs (1) • Voluntary • Negotiated • Statutory

  11. Overview : The Structure of the Regs (2) • Obligation to negotiate an I&C process • if either/or… • employer volunteers • trigger is pulled • Trigger: • 10% of workforce • min. 15% / max 2,500 • Unless: pre-existing agreement • If neither: Standard Provisions (statutory fall-back)

  12. Key Practical Issues • Undertaking • Pre-existing agreement • Sanctions • Overlap with existing law

  13. Undertaking • “a public or private undertaking carrying out an economic activity, whether or not for gain…” (similar to “old” TUPE • DTI: “a separately incorporated legal entity” (why?) • Not “establishment, division or business unit of a Company” • But if TUPE jurisprudence applies, DTI guidance must be doubtful

  14. Significance of Undertaking • Application • Trigger • Pre-existing agreement • Election / appointment of negotiating reps • Election of I&C reps

  15. Pre-Existing Agreements (1) • Valid employee request (10%/2,500 (etc)) • By less than 40% “in the undertaking” • Agreement • in writing • covers all employees “in the undertaking” • approved by the employees • sets out I&C procedures • More than one undertaking’s employees

  16. Pre-Existing Agreements (2) • Content not prescriptive • ACAS guidelines • Different parts of undertaking • As long as, together, cover all employees of the undertaking • Collective agreements

  17. Pre-Existing Agreements (3)Employee Approval • Simple majority in ballot • Majority through signatures • Agreement of those representing majority • Different methods for different agreements

  18. Pre-Existing Agreements (4)Effect • No “Article 13” opt-out • Still have to ballot or negotiate • 40%+ majority = endorsement  negotiate • Pre-existing agreements still exist? (Collective Agreements) • <40% or minority = no endorsement • Therefore, no obligation to negotiate • Pre-existing agreement stands • 3 year moratorium

  19. Pre-Existing Agreements (5)Effect • Does not let you off the hook • Still need a ballot • If survives - 3 year moratorium • If it doesn’t survive - negotiate a new I&C process • Going on to the negotiated procedure

  20. Do You Have a Pre-Existing Agreement ? • Irrelevant unless trigger pulled already • Don’t drive policy based wholly on it • Adapt existing processes • …with half an eye to a PEA • Unlikely that you can satisfy it

  21. Why is it Unlikely ? • Covers all employees in the undertaking • Approval of the workforce

  22. Sanctions • Complaint to CAC (not for PEAs) • Declaration • Penalty notice, from EAT • Max of £75,000 per failure • Paid to DTI

  23. Overlap with Existing Law (1) • Collective Redundancies (s188 TULRCA) • TUPE • “Double” jeopardy • protective award: redundancy - up to 3 months • compensation: TUPE - up to 13 weeks • I&C Regs: up to £75,000 fine

  24. Overlap with Existing Law (2) • Overlapping obligations • redundancy: TU Reps / elected • TUPE: TU Reps / elected • ICON: reps under Regs • Exclude ICON in redundancy / TUPE cases ? • Hidden trap ?

  25. Practical Solutions • Employees in the undertaking • umbrella agreement • sub-committees • Employee approval • existing procedures • reps are truly representative • “employee representative” not defined • Voluntary / PEA: do what you like ? • Collective agreements survive a PEA

  26. Conclusion • “DON’T PANIC • Avoid the trigger • Not necessarily a PEA • Satisfied workforce • Engage trade unions

More Related