190 likes | 421 Views
Letting the Gini out of the Bottle: Making Sense of the Evidence on Income Inequality, Social Cohesion, and Health. Ichiro Kawachi. Average After-Tax Income Gains, 1979-97. Congressional Budget Office, 2001. So What?. Economic residential segregation Crime and rising prison population
E N D
Letting the Gini out of the Bottle:Making Sense of the Evidence on Income Inequality, Social Cohesion, and Health Ichiro Kawachi
Average After-Tax Income Gains, 1979-97 Congressional Budget Office, 2001
So What? • Economic residential segregation • Crime and rising prison population • Drag on economic growth • Increased social tensions • Worse health status?
State-Level Income Inequality and Mortality (Kennedy, Kawachi 1996)
Hypotheses about Income and Health(Wagstaff and van Doorslaer, 2000)
NHIS-NDI follow-up, 1987-1995546,888 persons - 19,379 deaths RR total mortality Lochner, Kawachi et al. 2001
RR of Total Mortality for Near-Poor Women Aged 18-74 State Gini RR total mortality Lochner, Kawachi et al. 2001
State Income Inequality, Individual Income, and Maternal Depressive Symptoms Percent with Depressive Symptoms Gini Individual Income Quintiles Kahn, Kawachi et al. 2000
Under what conditions does income inequality matter? • State > MSA, Counties > Census tracts • USA > non-USA
Income Inequality and Mortality Rates in USA and Canada (Ross et al. 2000)
Current Debates • Confounding • Time lags • Mechanisms
Confounding • Race (as individual attribute) • Percent race (at state level)
Odds Ratio of Fair/Poor Health by State Income Inequality Odds Ratio State Gini Blakely, Kawachi et al. 2000
Mechanisms • Psychosocial • Social spending • Social cohesion
Social Cohesion • Civic engagement • Voluntarism • Norms of reciprocity • Trust
Pathways to Health at the State Level Income Inequality _ _ Social Cohesion Political Participation + + _ Racial heterogeneity + + _ Health