1 / 35

Semiparametric Methods for Colonic Crypt Signaling

This article presents a semiparametric framework for modeling correlations among functions in a colon carcinogenesis experiment. It discusses nonparametric methods, asymptotic summaries, and analysis techniques. The study aims to understand the structure of p27 in the colon when animals are exposed to a carcinogen.

smelton
Download Presentation

Semiparametric Methods for Colonic Crypt Signaling

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Semiparametric Methods for Colonic Crypt Signaling Raymond J. Carroll Department of Statistics Faculty of Nutrition and Toxicology Texas A&M University http://stat.tamu.edu/~carroll

  2. Outline • Problem: Modeling correlations among functions and apply to a colon carcinogenesis experiment • Biological background • Semiparametric framework • Nonparametric Methods • Asymptotic summary • Analysis • Summary

  3. Biologist Who Did The Work Meeyoung Hong Postdoc in the lab of Joanne Lupton and Nancy Turner Data collection represents a year of work

  4. Basic Background • Apoptosis: Programmed cell death • Cell Proliferation: Effectively the opposite • p27: Differences in this marker are thought to stimulate and be predictive of apoptosis and cell proliferation • Our experiment: understand some of the structure of p27 in the colon when animals are exposed to a carcinogen

  5. Data Collection • Structure of Colon • Note the finger-like projections • These are colonic crypts • We measure expression of cells within colonic crypts

  6. Data Collection • p27 expression: Measured by staining techniques • Brighter intensity = higher expression • Done on a cell by cell basis within selected colonic crypts • Very time intensive

  7. Data Collection • Animals sacrificed at 4 times: 0 = control, 12hr, 24hr and 48hr after exposure • Rats: 12 at each time period • Crypts: 20 are selected • Cells: all cells collected, about 30 per crypt • p27: measured on each cell, with logarithmic transformation

  8. Nominal Cell Position • X = nominal cell position • Differentiated cells: at top, X = 1.0 • Proliferating cells: in middle, X=0.5 • Stem cells: at bottom, X=0

  9. Standard Model • Hierarchical structure: cells within crypts within rats within times

  10. Standard Model • Hierarchical structure: cell locations of cells within crypts within rats within times • In our experiment, the residuals from fits at the crypt level are essentially white noise • However, we also measured the location of the colonic crypts

  11. Crypt Locations at 24 Hours, Nominal zero Scale: 1000’s of microns Our interest: relationships at between 25-200 microns

  12. Standard Model • Hypothesis: it is biologically plausible that the nearer the crypts to one another, the greater the relationship of overall p27 expression. • Expectation: The effect of the carcinogen might well alter the relationship over time • Technically: Functional data where the functions are themselves correlated

  13. Basic Model • Two-Levels: Rat and crypt level functions • Rat-Level: Modeled either nonparametrically or semiparametrically • Semiparametrically: low-order regression spline • Nonparametrically: some version of a kernel fit

  14. Basic Model • Crypt-Level: A regression spline, with few knots, in a parametric mixed-model formulation Linear spline: In practice, we used a quadratic spline. The covariance matrix of the quadratic part used the Pourahmadi-Daniels construction

  15. Advertisement David Ruppert Matt Wand http://stat.tamu.edu/~carroll/semiregbook/ Please buy our book! Or steal it 

  16. Basic Model • Crypt-Level: We modeled the functions across crypts semiparametrically as regression splines • The covariance matrix of the parameters of the spline modeled as separable • Matern family used to model correlations

  17. Basic Model • Crypt-Level: regression spline, few knots • Separable covariance structure

  18. Theory for Parametric Version • The semiparametric approach we used fits formally into a new general theory • Recall that we fit the marginal function at the rat level “nonparametrically”. • At the crypt level, we used a parametric mixed-model representation of low-order regression splines Xihong Lin

  19. General Formulation • Yij = Response • Xij, Zij = cell and crypt locations • Likelihood (or criterion function) • The key is that the function is evaluated multiple times for each rat • This distinguishes it from standard semiparametric models • The goal is to estimate and efficiently

  20. General Formulation: Overview • Likelihood (or criterion function) • For iid versions of these problems, we have developed constructive kernel-based methods of estimation with • Asymptotic expansions and inference available • If the criterion function is a likelihood function, then the methods are semiparametric efficient. • Methods avoid solving integral equations

  21. General Formulation: Overview • We also show • The equivalence of profiling and backfitting • Pseudo-likelihood calculations • The results were submitted 7 months ago, and we confidently expect 1st reviews within the next year or two , depending on when the referees open their mail

  22. General Formulation: Overview • In the application, modifications necessary both for theoretical and practical purposes • Techniques described in the talk of Tanya Apanasovich can be used here as well to cut down on the computational burden due to the correlated functions.

  23. Nonparametric Fits • Equal Spacing: Assume cell locations are equally spaced • Define = covariance between crypt-level functions that are D apart, one at location x1 and the other at location x2 • Assume separable covariance structure

  24. Nonparametric Fits • Discrete Version: Pretend D, x1 and x2 take on a small discrete set of values (we actually use a kernel-version of this idea) • Form the sample covariance matrix per rat at D, x1 and x2 , then average across rats. • Call this estimate

  25. Nonparametric Fits • Separability: Now use the separability to get a rough estimate of the correlation surface.

  26. Nonparametric Fits • The estimate is not a proper correlation function • We fixed it up using a trick due to Peter Hall (1994, Annals), thus forming , a real correlation function • Basic idea is to do a Fourier transform, force it to be non-negative, then invert • Slower rates of convergence than the parametric fit, more variability, etc. • Asymptotics worked out (non-trivial)

  27. Semiparametric Method Details • In the example, a cubic polynomial actually suffices for the rat-level functions • Maximize in the covariance structure of the crypt-level splines, including Matern-order • The covariance structure includes • Matern order m (gridded) • Matern parameter a • Spline smoothing parameter • Quadratic part’s covariance matrix (Pourahmadi-Daniels) • AR(1) for residuals

  28. Results: Part I • Matern Order: Matern order of 0.5 is the classic autoregressive model • Our Finding: For all times, an order of about 0.15 was the maximizer • Simulations: Can distinguish from autocorrelation • Different Matern orders lead to different interpretations about the extent of the correlations

  29. Marginal over time Spline Fits Note • time effects • Location effects

  30. 24-Hour Fits: The Matern order matters

  31. Nonparametric and Semiparametric Fits at 24 Hours

  32. Comparison of Fits • The semiparametric and nonparametric fits are roughly similar • At 200 microns, quite far apart, the correlations in the functions are approximately 0.40 for both • Surprising degree of correlation

  33. Summary • We have studied the problem of crypt-signaling in colon carcinogenesis experiments • Technically, this is a problem of hierarchical functional data where the functions are not independent in the standard manner • We developed (efficient, constructive) semiparametric and nonparametric methods, with asymptotic theory • The correlations we see in the functions are surprisingly large.

  34. Statistical Collaborators Yehua Li Naisyin Wang

  35. Summary Insiration for this work: Water goanna, Kimberley Region, Australia

More Related