1 / 69

Nodal Reliability Performance Measures Workshop Project No. 37052

Nodal Reliability Performance Measures Workshop Project No. 37052. Public Utility Commission of Texas June 12, 2009. Nodal Reliability and Regulatory Oversight. Goals for Go-live: Adequate PUCT oversight of market on first day Enforcement to consider new market limitations Reasonableness

sonora
Download Presentation

Nodal Reliability Performance Measures Workshop Project No. 37052

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Nodal Reliability Performance Measures WorkshopProject No. 37052 Public Utility Commission of Texas June 12, 2009

  2. Nodal Reliability and Regulatory Oversight • Goals for Go-live: • Adequate PUCT oversight of market on first day • Enforcement to consider new market limitations • Reasonableness • Metric adjustment and tuning process • Reliability and Compliance Training Plan • Monitoring reports are tested and useable • Longer term plan for additional metrics, if needed • Clear communication of regulatory oversight and risk

  3. Approach • PUCT, Texas RE, IMM and ERCOT ISO have taken a proactive approach • Define a minimum set of reliability metrics and criteria (NPRRs and NOGRRs) necessary to enable go live • Implement a gap analysis • Create NPRRs and NOGRRs to fill gaps • Work through Stakeholder process to enact in time for market trials with urgent status • Ensure proper reports are ready for monitoring and enforcement • Create regulatory training and roll out plan

  4. Other Issues • Plan to submit resulting NPRRs and NOGRRs to ERCOT process for approval using urgent status • Leverage NOGRR-025 work and integrate results into stakeholder process • Reliability metrics and criteria to be in place for market trials for testing • Minimized impact to Nodal Project (no code changes to core systems)

  5. Reliability Issues • 55 issues affecting reliability of the ERCOT grid were identified • Of these, 24 are deemed to be critical for Nodal go-live regulatory oversight • Of these 24, 12 will require protocol or operating guide changes • The remaining 12 issues are already addressed in existing protocols or operating guides • Many of the other 31 issues will be ready for go-live or should be addressed within a short time frame after nodal go-live

  6. Design Requirements • Criteria must be defined that detail what he expect behavior is and how it will be measured • Metrics must be defined that clearly identify what is passing and what is failing • The mechanism for monitoring performance, reporting potential failure and communicating this to Texas RE must be included

  7. Reporting • Reports will need to be developed to generate exception reports on a periodic basis (e.g. monthly) to identify failures of calculated metrics • Complaint process may be used to identify incident-oriented failures • Trending metrics may be defined that are intended to monitor an issue but that are not intended to be used for violations

  8. Not needed @ go-live Organization Critical for go-live, already covered Critical for go-live work needed

  9. Binding Documents • State Estimator • Telemetry Standards • Any other applicable binding documents

  10. Real-time > ISO > Frequency OG: NP: 8.2(2)(b)(vii) Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  11. Real-time > ISO > Event Recovery > DCS OG: NP: 8.2(b)(vii) Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  12. Real-time > ISO > Event Recovery > EEA-EILS OG: NP: 8.1.3.1, 8.1.3.4 Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  13. Real-time > ISO > Constraints > IROLs OG: 9.12.1(1), 9.12.4 NP: 8.2.(2)(d) Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  14. Real-time > ISO > Constraints > SOLs OG: 9.12.1(1), 9.12.4 NP: 8.2.(2)(d) Not needed for oversight at go-live. NPRR/NOGRR required to adopt criteria.

  15. Real-time > ISO > Constraints > Maintain proper bus voltage limits OG: 9.12.9, 2.7 NP: 3.15.1, and 6.5.7.7 Not needed for oversight at go-live. NPRR/NOGRR required to adopt criteria.

  16. Real-time > ISO > State Estimator > State Estimator Standards OG: 9.12.1(4)(a) NP: 8.2(2)(a)(iii) Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  17. Real-time > ISO > Operating/Ancillary Reserves > Regulation OG: NP: 6.5.7.5(1)(h) Not needed for oversight at go-live. No action required.

  18. Real-time > ISO > Operating/Ancillary Reserves > Non-spin OG: NP: 6.5.7.5(1)(d)-(g) Not needed for oversight at go-live. No action required.

  19. Real-time > ISO > Operating/Ancillary Reserves > Responsive Reserves OG: 9.12.2(2)(a) NP: 6.5.7.5(1)(a)-(c ),6.5.9.4.2 Not needed for oversight at go-live. No action required.

  20. Real-time > ISO > Operating/Ancillary Reserves > LaaRs OG: NP: 6.5.7.5(1)(b),(c ),and(e) Not needed for oversight at go-live. No action required.

  21. Real-time > ISO > Ancillary Service Energy Deployment > System Regulation Deployment OG: 9.12.2(1) NP: 8.2(2)(b)(ii) and 6.5.7.6.2.1 Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  22. Real-time > ISO > Ancillary Service Energy Deployment > Non-spin online measures OG: NP: 6.5.7.6.2.3 Not needed for oversight at go-live. No action required.

  23. Real-time > ISO > Ancillary Service Energy Deployment > Responsive requirements of units OG: 9.13.4 NP: 6.5.7.6.2.2, 8.2(b)(vii) Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  24. Real-time > QSE > Operating/Ancillary Reserves > Regulation OG: NP: 8.1.1.3.1 Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required to define compliance report/possible exemptions.

  25. Real-time > QSE > Operating/Ancillary Reserves > Non-Spin OG: NP: 8.1.1.3.3 Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required to define compliance report/possible exemptions.

  26. Real-time > QSE > Operating/Ancillary Reserves > Responsive Reserves OG: NP: 8.1.1.3.2 Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required to define compliance report/possible exemptions.

  27. Real-time > QSE > Operating/Ancillary Reserves > LaaRs OG: NP: 8.1.1.3.2(2) and 8.1.1.3.3(2) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required to define compliance report/possible exemptions.

  28. Real-time > QSE > Ancillary Services Energy Deployment > Non-spin online measures (1/3) OG: 9.13.6 NP: 8.1.1.4.3 and 8.1(3)(m) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required.

  29. Real-time > QSE > Ancillary Services Energy Deployment > Non-spin online measures (2/3) OG: 9.13.6 NP: 8.1.1.4.3 and 8.1(3)(m) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required.

  30. Real-time > QSE > Ancillary Services Energy Deployment > Non-spin online measures (3/3) OG: 9.13.6 NP: 8.1.1.4.3 and 8.1(3)(m) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required.

  31. Real-time > QSE > Ancillary Services Energy Deployment > Responsive requirements of units (1/3) OG: 9.13.4 NP: 8.1.1.4.2 and 8.1(3)(k) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required.

  32. Real-time > QSE > Ancillary Services Energy Deployment > Responsive requirements of units (2/3) OG: 9.13.4 NP: 8.1.1.4.2 and 8.1(3)(k) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required.

  33. Real-time > QSE > Ancillary Services Energy Deployment > Responsive requirements of units (3/3) OG: 9.13.4 NP: 8.1.1.4.2 and 8.1(3)(k) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required.

  34. Real-time > QSE > Telemetry Standards OG: 9.3(c)(ii) NP: 8.1(3)(c)(i) Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  35. Real-time > QSE > Event Recovery > Governor Response (1/3) OG: 2.2.7, 2.2.8 NP: 8.5.2, 8.5.1.1 and 8.5.1.2 Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  36. Real-time > QSE > Event Recovery > Governor Response (2/3) OG: 2.2.7, 2.2.8 NP: 8.5.2, 8.5.1.1 and 8.5.1.2 Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  37. Real-time > QSE > Event Recovery > Governor Response (3/3) OG: 2.2.7, 2.2.8 NP: 8.5.2, 8.5.1.1 and 8.5.1.2 Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  38. Real-time > QSE > Resource Outages OG: 9.6 NP: 8.1(3)(q) Not needed for oversight at go-live. No action required.

  39. Real-time > QSE > COP > Day-Ahead OG: 9.10(2),(3),(4),(6) NP: 8.1(3)(r ), 3.9.2, 3.16, 8.1.2 Critical for Nodal go-live. Changes recommended can wait until after go-live.

  40. Real-time > QSE > COP > Adjustment Periods OG: 9.10(1),(5),(6) NP: 8.1(3)(r ), 3.9.2, 3.16, 8.1.2 Critical for Nodal go-live. Changes recommended can wait until after go-live.

  41. Real-time > QSE > Energy > Adherence to dispatch orders OG: 9.4 NP: 8.1(3)(f) Critical for Nodal go-live. Already covered.

  42. Real-time > QSE > Energy > GREDP (1/3) OG: 9.4 NP: 8.1.1.4.1(2)-(5) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required to adopt criteria.

  43. Real-time > QSE > Energy > GREDP (2/3) OG: 9.4 NP: 8.1.1.4.1(2)-(5) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required to adopt criteria.

  44. Real-time > QSE > Energy > GREDP (3/3) OG: 9.4 NP: 8.1.1.4.1(2)-(5) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required to adopt criteria.

  45. Real-time > QSE > Energy > Voltage Control > Maintain voltage set point OG: 9.9, 2.7.4.1, 9.2 NP: 3.15.3, 8.1(3)(o), 6.5.5.1, 8.1(3)(b) Critical for Nodal go-live. NOGRR/NPRR required to define report.

  46. Real-time > TSP > Transmission Outages OG: 9.11.3 NP: 8.3(1)(c ) Not needed for oversight at go-live. No action required.

  47. Real-time > TSP > Telemetry Standards OG: 9.11.2 NP: 8.3(1)(b) Critical for Nodal go-live. No action required.

  48. Real-time > TSP > Voltage and Switching of Transmission Elements > Following TOP directives OG: 9.11.5, 2.7.4.1 NP: 3.15.2 Not needed for oversight at go-live. NOGRR25 may need more detail to explain the monthly report.

  49. Planning > ISO > Day-Ahead Market > DRUC OG: 9.12.1(3)(a)(i),9.12.2(3)(a),9.12.4(c) NP: 8.2(2)(l), 8.2(2)(d)(iii), 8.2(2)(b)(iv), 5.3 Not needed for oversight at go-live. No action required.

  50. Planning > ISO > Day-Ahead Market > HRUC OG: 9.12.1(3)(a)(i),9.12.2(3)(a),9.12.4(c) NP: 8.2(2)(l ),8.2(2)(d)(ii), 5.3, 8.2(2)(b)(iv) Not needed for oversight at go-live. No action required.

More Related