170 likes | 492 Views
ToK Essays. Writing about knowledge issues. What are knowledge Issues?. IB Definition: ‘Knowledge issues are questions that directly refer to our understanding of the world, ourselves and others, in connection with the acquisition, search for, production, shaping and acceptance of knowledge.’
E N D
ToK Essays Writing about knowledge issues
What are knowledge Issues? • IB Definition: • ‘Knowledge issues are questions that directly refer to our understanding of the world, ourselves and others, in connection with the acquisition, search for, production, shaping and acceptance of knowledge.’ • In simple terms, questions that: • Question what we believe, our reasons for believing it and whether these are good reasons
For example: • Of the four ways of knowing: Emotion, Language, Reason and Sense Perception, which do you think are more reliable and which are less reliable? Illustrate your answer with examples from at least two areas of knowledge.
Characteristics of a Good Knowledge Issue: • Open question • Asks explicitly about knowledge • Uses concepts from ToK (specific ways of knowing/areas of knowledge etc) • Is precise in terms of the relationship between the ToK concepts mentioned
Some More Examples • Questions not about what we know but how we know it TASK • For each knowledge issue, see if it meets the criteria mentioned on the previous page. • Try to develop your own knowledge issues and see if they meet these criteria.
Some fall-back knowledge issues • What role does ‘x’ play in ‘y’? • How does ‘x’ affect the certainty of ‘y’? • To what extent does ‘x’ apply to ‘y’? • What is the value of ‘x’ (to ‘y’)? • Is there a difference between ‘x’ and ‘y’?
Task: • In groups of 4 (ish) • Select one of the essay titles from the exam paper that no one in the group has done • Try to identify some of the knowledge issues that need to be addressed • These must be written down as this will help to clarify and shape them • Attempt another question if you finish early
Writing about knowledge issues • Stay focussed on answering the knowledge issue (do not let yourself get side tracked) • Describe the issue then explore it…this means talk about the implications, look at how it applies in different situations. • Apply the idea in relation to your experience as a learner • Bring in relevant examples, some from your own learning • Give (and justify) your own opinion
Key lessons from examiner’s report • Spend considerable time thinking about and unpacking the question • Bring in knowledge issues naturally – don’t just say ‘my knowledge issues are….’ • Focus discussing ways of knowing within the context of an area of knowledge • Choose concrete, real examples rather than complicated abstract ones • Make sure you answer the question • Avoid cliches…. ‘maths is totally based on reason’ etc • Avoid bald assertions (make qualified claims) • Use any definitions you give
Example: Knowledge is generated through the interaction of critical and creative thinking. Evaluate this statement in two areas of knowledge.
Structuring the Essay • Your essay must be structured in such as way as you make sure you answer the whole question • You should structure your essay in such a way as it helps you to analyse. • Use your knowledge issues to help provide some structure
For example: • In this case ‘X’ and ‘Y’ would be the two areas of knowledge I was looking at. It can be useful to choose ones that you think will clash in some way or provide interesting/instructive comparisons.
Task: • For whichever title(s) you chose previously • Draw out structure that would help you to answer it (doesn’t have to be a table, could be a mind-map etc – visual generally better) • Try to flesh-out some of the points you might try to make
How did you do? • Grade boundaries are as follows: