130 likes | 280 Views
Behavioural economics @ the CMA. Chris Walters* Director of Economics, Enforcement *The usual disclaimer applies. Overview. About the CMA Making markets work well Putting behavioural economics into practice at the CMA Enforcing consumer law Looking at markets Some future priorities
E N D
Behavioural economics @ the CMA Chris Walters*Director of Economics, Enforcement *The usual disclaimer applies
Overview • About the CMA • Making markets work well • Putting behavioural economics into practice at the CMA • Enforcing consumer law • Looking at markets • Some future priorities • The interaction of competition and behavioural economic effects, especially online • The behavioural economics of personal data as currency • The behavioural economics of businesses, not consumers
Behavioural economics @ the CMA About the cma
Tools for making markets work well Anti-competitive agreements Abuse of dominance Merger control Calls for information Market studies Super-complaints MIRs Unfair contract terms Unfair commercial practices Impact CONSUMER TOOLS COMPETITION TOOLS Strategic Significance Risk Resource Competition advocacy Business guidance Sector regulation SOFT TOOLS
When don’t markets work well? Demand side blockages Supply side blockages Accessing information Market concentration Assessing information Supplier behaviour Acting on information Barriers to entry
Behavioural economics @ the CMA Putting behavioural economics into practice
BE and demand-side blockages Bounded rationality Bounded self control Bounded self interest Accessing information Narrow choice sets Impulsive behaviour and procrast-ination Assessing information Anchors and heuristics Acting on information Habits and status quo Sacrifice and punishment
Business practices may exploit these • Making information difficult to find • Increasing search costs • Obfuscating (e.g. partitioned or dripped pricing) • Making choice difficult • Surprise charges, automatic renewals and default charges • Time limited offers (e.g. bait pricing) Accessing information Assessing information Acting on information
Some examples Pricing practices Other practices Gyms (2013) Lengthy minimum membership periods Penalties, not liquidated damages Debt collection • Since mid-2010, c.45 investigations, increasing focus on BE theories of harm • Drip pricing • Low cost airlines (2012) • Other pricing practices • Supermarkets (2012) • Furniture and carpet retailing (2014)
Behavioural economics @ the CMA Some future priorities
What next for BE @ CMA? • Online intermediation • Data as currency • BE of businesses
Thank you Chris WaltersDirector of Economics, Enforcement