1 / 21

Enforcing Protective Orders Through Contempt Proceedings

Enforcing Protective Orders Through Contempt Proceedings. Alicia Aiken, LAF Neha Lall, Life Span. OP’s May be Enforced through Contempt Proceedings.

tad-deleon
Download Presentation

Enforcing Protective Orders Through Contempt Proceedings

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Enforcing Protective Orders Through Contempt Proceedings Alicia Aiken, LAF Neha Lall, Life Span

  2. OP’s May be Enforced through Contempt Proceedings “A violation of any valid Illinois order of protection, whether issued [in] a civil or criminal proceeding, may be enforced through civil or criminal contempt procedures, as appropriate, by any court with jurisdiction, regardless where the act or acts which violated the order of protection were committed.” 750 ILCS 60/223(b)

  3. Requirements for Enforcement • Actual knowledge of the contents of the order. 750 ILCS 60/223(d) • There need not be any physical manifestations of abuse on the person of the victim. 750 ILCS 60/223(f)

  4. Direct v. Indirect Contempt • Direct Contempt: violation occurs in the presence of the court • Indirect Contempt: violation occurs outside of the presence of court

  5. Civil v. Criminal Contempt Distinction lies in the purpose of Petition: • Civil Contempt: to compel future compliance with a court order • Criminal Contempt: to punish past violation of the order

  6. Civil v. Criminal Contempt

  7. Civil v. Criminal Contempt

  8. Indirect Criminal Contempt Proceedings

  9. LSC-Recipients Can Bring Indirect Criminal Contempt Petitions • “Criminal Proceeding” defined as an adversary process prosecuted by a public officer. • If “professional responsibility” requires criminal representation arising out of prior or current rep. • Prohibitions on assistance in criminal proceedings only apply to LSC funds. 45 C.F.R. Sec. 1613

  10. Filing Requirements • File Petition for Adjudication of Indirect Criminal Contempt • Issue new Summons • Unclear if new summons is required • Better practice is to do so, since this is technically a separate cause • Service of Petition

  11. Body Attachments • IDVA specifically allows for issuance of a body attachment in contempt proceedings if petition sets forth facts evidencing an immediate danger that the respondent will flee the jurisdiction, conceal a child, or inflict physical abuse on the petitioner or minor children. • Bond shall be set unless specifically denied in writing. 750 ILCS 60/223(b)(1)-(2)

  12. Procedural Requirements • 5th Amendment Rights Attach • Respondent need not file a Response • Burden may not be shifted to Respondent Rule to Show Cause NOT appropriate • Appointment of Counsel • Court must appoint counsel for Respondent if not already represented

  13. Minor v. Serious Criminal Contempt • Minor Contempt: • No Right to Jury Trial • Sanctions must be $500 or less and/or incarceration of less than 6 months • Serious Contempt: • Right to Jury Trial • Sanctions of more than $500 and/or incarceration of more than 6 months Cheff v. Schnackenberg, 384 U.S. 373 (1966).

  14. Hearing • Presumption of Innocence • Privilege against self-incrimination • Right to introduce evidence on own behalf • Right to present witness • Right to public trial • Right to be present at trial • Right to substitution of judge

  15. Requirements of Contempt Judgment Order • Must be written order signed by judge • Must recite jurisdiction • Must set forth facts on which the contempt is based • Must contain a clear and unambiguous finding of contempt • Must recite sanctions imposed • Certified orders should be served on Respondent along with a copy given to the warden of the institution along with commitment order

  16. Right to Appeal • Respondent should be advised of right to appeal pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 605(a) • May be appealed as any other criminal case if sanctions have been imposed

  17. Imposition of Sanctions Contemnor must be given an opportunity to make a statement in allocution prior to sanctions being imposed. Taylor v. Hayes, 418 U.S. 488 (1974)

  18. Penalties for Violation IDVA says the following sanctions are appropriate: • Incarceration • Payment of Restitution • Payment of Attorney’s Fees and Costs • Community Service 750 ILCS 60/223(g)

  19. Incarceration To the extent permitted by law, the court is encouraged to: • Increase penalties for subsequent violations • Impose a minimum penalty of 24 hours imprisonment for respondent’s first violation • Impose a minimum penalty of 48 hours imprisonment for respondent’s second or subsequent violation unless manifestly unjust 750 ILCS 60/223(g)(3)

  20. When is a Contempt Petition a Good Idea? • When the State’s Attorney will not prosecute a violation • Contempt proceeding will not further endanger victim • Respondent will likely not be incarcerated during proceedings • Not for high lethality cases!

  21. When is a Contempt Petition a Good Idea? • Non-violent violations • Phone calls/text messages • Emails/internet communications • Third Party Contact • Cases where Respondent will be deterred by a Contempt Finding

More Related