240 likes | 378 Views
Opportunities for biomass as fuel. Bernard Rice. Why biofuels now?. Increasing mineral fuel prices Need for new farm enterprises Need for secure fuel supply EU Directives/obligations Kyoto Protocol, Transport Biofuels Directive. Transport Biofuels Directive substitution targets (%).
E N D
Opportunities for biomass as fuel Bernard Rice
Why biofuels now? • Increasing mineral fuel prices • Need for new farm enterprises • Need for secure fuel supply • EU Directives/obligations • Kyoto Protocol, Transport Biofuels Directive
Transport Biofuels Directivesubstitution targets (%) 1% substitution needs 12-40,000 ha of biofuels
Transport Biofuels Directive • No sanctions or penalties • Member states obliged to: • Set substitution targets • (heeding Commission’s aims) • Take measures to achieve targets • Report progress annually • Review to be held mid-2006
First progress report • Proposes excise relief on: • 6 Million litres vegetable oil (5000 ha rape) • 1 Million litres biodiesel • 1 Million litres bio-ethanol (250 ha beet) • Equiv. to 0.1% substitution (EU target 2%) • Cost of excise foregone ~€3M • most would be recovered in vat, income tax etc
Limitations on biofuel development • Low price for renewable electricity • Limited excise remission for road biofuel For viability, either market support, low-cost feedstock or additional revenue source needed
Biofuel opportunities • LIQUID BIOFUELS • Veg oil/fats as biodiesel or in modified engines • Ethanol from cereals, beet • “Biofine” process,ethanol from straw/wood • SOLID BIOFUELS • Straw,wood residues • Short-rotation willow + effluent disposal • Other energy crops (e.g. miscanthus, hemp) • Biogas from food wastes, animal manure
In this presentation • Vegetable oil • Ethanol from wheat, beet • Straw • Short-rotation willow
Vegetable oil opportunities • Rape-seed oil in modified engines Projects in Wicklow, Wexford, Kilkenny (6000 t/year) Present MOTR scheme should ensure viability Biodiesel From rape-seed oil, waste veg. oil, tallow 3 proposals in planning (~90,000 t/year) Excise relief needed • Heating fuel Renderers already using 40,000 t/year of tallow But this is likely to be banned soon
BIO-ETHANOL • Current Irish options • Produce from wheat or beet • Add 5% as octane booster to petrol • Replacement for MTBE or lead • (no engine modifications needed)
Ethanol yields • From wheat • 350 litres per tonne • 3000 litres per ha • From sugar beet • 90 litres per tonne • 4500 litres per ha
Ethanol from wheat, beet For 2% substitution 30,000 ha beet or 40,000 ha wheat • Needs • Large scale • Excise relief • Investor/promoter interest
Straw and wood residues • Large quantities of both available • Wood use now developing Many companies active • Fewer options for straw More difficult fuel No market leaders
Wood/straw fuel markets (1) • Co-fired with peat in power stations • Wood more suitable • Electricity value €80/tonne • Not an option for straw • Combined heat-and-power plants • 3 in N.I., one in Cork sawmills • Use for heat essential • Little prospect for straw
Wood/straw fuel markets (2) • Boiler fuel • Medium size units 100-500 kW • Value of heat ~€100/t of straw • High-efficiency modern boilers • Straw delivered in bales • Several wood units installed
Biomass boiler (Oak Park) Very efficient, expensive, capital grants needed
Wood/straw fuel markets (3) • Stove/small boiler fuel • Fuel in pellet form • High-value market • (~€150/tonne) • Pellet plant in N.I.
Concerns about straw pellets • Immature technology • Lower quality? • higher ash content • binding problems • more corrosion • emissions? • More information needed
Energy crops and waste disposal • Willow used as boiler fuel • Sites used for • sewage sludge injection • Rapid progress in N.I. • Potential for 3000 ha • trickle irrigation of dilute effluents • Several projects under way • Promising results to date • Full potential not established
Energy crops and waste disposal • Research needed on • volume and composition of effluents • uptake by energy crops • drying and storage of wood-chips • Liaison needed with • local authorities, EPA • heat users • effluent producers • Establishment grants needed
Conclusions • Some biofuel opportunities emerging • More will follow • They need • Clear govt policy and supports • excise relief for biodiesel, bioethanol • grants for biomass boilers • establishment grants for energy crops • New supply chains • New partners • More R&D, short- and long-term