310 likes | 474 Views
Economics of Innovation Patents Manuel Trajtenberg 2005. What are patents all about?. A patent is a legal document that grants monopoly rights over a specific innovation for a specified period of time (~ 20 years).
E N D
What are patents all about? • A patent is a legal document that grants monopoly rights over a specific innovation for a specified period of time (~ 20 years). • Why? To provide incentives to innovate: if inventions could be copied, nobody will incur the fix costs of developing it. • So important that specified in the US Constitution. • Patents involve a deal: monopoly rights in exchange for disclosure – that further promotes innovation. • As R&D and innovation become more important in the industrialized world, patent protection gains in stature.
Patents as mechanism of appropriability • Innovation: creation of new Knowledge • Nice/nasty property of Knowledge: it leaks out easily! • Costs of copying knowledge usually very low • Hence need protection in order to reap benefits from innovation => • Need appropriability mechanisms
Other mechanisms of appropriability • Secrecy • Lead Times • Monopoly power in the field – barriers to entry Patents – important in pharmaceuticals and chemicals, less in other industries
Additional roles of patents • Tool for mutual deterrence • Tool for transfer/trade in technology, e.g. from Universities, from individual inventors/start ups.
Patent Policy • Scope of what’s patentable: business methods, gene sequences… • “Size” (breath) of patents • How/when to allow for opposition/ appeals? • Whether and when to disclose applications.
International Issues • Harmonization (e.g. first to file vs. first to invent) • Pharmaceutical patents in third world countries. • Enforcement.
Patents as depositories of wealth of information on innovation • Very detailed information, millions of patents • Can study countries, firms, inventors; • Can study links over time and across geography and institutions. • (see front page of patent)
Front page of patent (partial) United States Patent 6,539,988 Pressurized container adapter for charging automotive systems Inventors: Cowan; David M. (Brooklyn, NY); Schapers; Jochen (New York, NY); Trachtenberg; Saul (New York, NY); Nikolayev; Nikolay V. (Flushing, NY) Assignee: Interdynamics, Inc. (Brooklyn, NY) Filed: December 28, 2001 Current U.S. Class:141/67; 137/614.04; 141/351; 251/149.1 Intern'l Class: B65B Primary Examiner: Douglas; Steven O. Attorney, Agent or Firm: Levisohn, Lerner, Berger & Langsam LLP
Compaq 4/1995 TX Compaq 7/1995 TX Intel 11/1996 AZ IBM 3/1997 TX, FL Compaq 10/1998 CA Patent Citations: Spillovers, Importance spillovers “Self-citations” importance
Distribution of Patents by Technological Categories – Shares
Spillovers and geography QJE 1993