1 / 18

Effective Governance of Public Safety Net Hospitals & Health Systems

Effective Governance of Public Safety Net Hospitals & Health Systems. Presentation of Larry Gage President, NAPH Partner, Powell Goldstein LLP Los Angeles Health Collaborative December 15,2005. Outline of Presentation. What is a “typical” public hospital?

tannar
Download Presentation

Effective Governance of Public Safety Net Hospitals & Health Systems

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Effective Governance of Public Safety Net Hospitals & Health Systems Presentation of Larry Gage President, NAPH Partner, Powell Goldstein LLP Los Angeles Health Collaborative December 15,2005

  2. Outline of Presentation • What is a “typical” public hospital? • The hallmarks of effective governance • Why do public hospitals restructure? • Advantages of public status • Potential models for reorganization

  3. What is a “Typical” Public Hospital? • Direct governance by elected/appointed officials • Advisory board or commission • Freestanding board with some autonomy • State University • Hospital District • Hospital Authority • Public benefit corporation • Private non-profit corporation • Public/private partnership

  4. What is the Responsibility of a “Typical” Hospital Trustee? • Strategic Orientation: To articulate the mission and establish long-term direction • Fiduciary: To preserve the fiscal viability of the organization • Public Accountability: To represent the needs of the public and be accountable to the public • Advocate: To represent the hospital’s needs before the executive and legislative branches and the public

  5. Why Do Public Hospitals Restructure? Issues & Challenges • Financial pressures • Demand for uncompensated care • Public need for money-losing services • Increased demand, reduced funds when economy slows • Disproportionate impact of Medicaid “reforms” • Aggressive competition for reimbursed services • Drain on local government resources • Lengthy budget & decision-making process • Limited control over revenues, expenditures • Personnel & procurement constraints • Under-funded medical education role • Access to capital • Ability to partner or compete

  6. Advantages of Public Status • Access to county tax revenues • Access to general obligation bonds • Ability to make Medicaid transfers and receive supplemental payments • OSHA, Social Security, labor, antitrust, tax and other federal and state exemptions • Availability of cross subsidies for prevention & public health • Sovereign immunity and eminent domain • Access to municipal support services – pension, benefits, self-insurance fund, etc.

  7. Restructured Public Hospitals: Potential Options • Hospital Taxing District • Independent Health Care Authority • Merger or Affiliation • Outright Sale • New Non-Profit Entity

  8. Reorganization Options: Taxing District • Most common form of public hospital in California • Counties may have more than one district • Governed by general hospital district statute • Subject to most open meeting and record laws • Need not conform to county boundaries (joint powers) • Powers of a hospital district include: • Entering management contract for hospital • Transferring all or majority of hospital assets to third party, subject to voter approval • Create subsidiary, participate in joint venture • Levying taxes, subject to voter approval

  9. Taxing District: Examples • Maricopa Medical Center • Dallas County Hospital District • North & South Broward Districts • North Sonoma County Hospital District

  10. Reorganization Options: Independent Authority • Special legislation authorizes transfer of significant county services & powers • County can adopt through resolution, ordinance • County can appoint board • Assets, personnel, programs, obligations can all be transferred to new entity • Contracts and agreements between county and authority govern services, funding

  11. Independent Authority: Examples • Denver Health & Hospitals Authority • Alameda County Health Care Authority • Hawaii Health Systems Corporation • New York City Health & Hospitals Corporation • Universities of Colorado, Kansas, Wisconsin • Nassau & Westchester Counties NY

  12. Reorganization Options: Merger or Affiliation • Can take a variety of forms, e.g. joint subsidiary, joint operating entity, management contract • Can be system-wide or for limited purpose • County’s involvement can be tailored to fit its needs – i.e. new governmental organization can be created to manage relationship • Responsibilities, as well as associated risks, may be transferred in varying degrees • County may negotiate desired level of control over funding priorities, physical renovations, service mix • Contract negotiation may be difficult -- affiliate entity typically requires limit on risk • May require public bids, hearings, special legislation, or voter approval • Short- to medium-term contract permits flexibility to respond to future needs and environment

  13. Merger or Affiliation: Examples • Boston Medical Center • UMass/Memorial Health System • University of New Mexico Hospital/Bernalillo County Medical Center • Harborview Medical Center/University of Washington • Wishard Memorial Hospital/Indiana University

  14. Reorganization Options: Outright Sale • Transfer of public hospital to existing provider • Unlike BMC merger – little remaining county role • Forms include merger, sale, long-term lease, etc. • Acquirer enters new market or gains market share • County can reduce financial risk, get out of healthcare provider business • May cover healthcare obligations by contract • Acquirer usually looks to limit risk

  15. Outright Sale: Examples • Fresno Valley Medical Center (Community HS) • Sonoma County Community Hospital (Sutter) • University of California -- Davis, Irvine, San Diego • Milwaukee County (Froedtert Memorial) • St. Paul-Ramsey County (HMO) • Memorial of Las Cruces (For-profit) • University of Minnesota Hospital (Fairview) • Brackenridge City Hospital (Seton Health System) • Cambridge Health Alliance

  16. Reorganization Options: New Non-profit Corporation • New corporation can be created by county or others • Releases hospital from “public entity” constraints • Insulates county from liabilities of corporation • County may retain substantial control, but excess control may result in treatment as public entity • County may contract for indigent care, other services • Public hearings, procurement requirements, voter approval, role of county employees may be issues • Medicaid payment methodologies favor public status

  17. New Non-profit Corporation: Examples • Detroit Medical Center • Truman Medical Center • Regional Medical Center at Memphis • Memorial Medical Center of Savannah • Universities of Maryland, Florida, Georgia, West Virginia, Massachusetts, etc.

  18. Reorganization: Issues to Be Considered • Remember: reorganization is a tool, not a panacea • System change requires will, ideas & execution (Tom Nolan) • Systematically identify key problems – and determine if a new structure can address them • Carefully define new structure: make sure it has the resources and power it needs • Lay out required process in detail before proceeding, e.g., authorizing legislation, referendum, board structure, services to be transferred, funding, personnel, procurement, information, accounting & financial systems, etc. • Educate & enlist all relevant stakeholders • Recruit an outstanding board – and let it function with sufficient autonomy to get the job done

More Related