1 / 10

OLD AGE IN HUMANITARIAN PRACTICE The terms of the problem GENCap workshop, February 2012

OLD AGE IN HUMANITARIAN PRACTICE The terms of the problem GENCap workshop, February 2012. A matter of principle.

tatiana-stanley
Download Presentation

OLD AGE IN HUMANITARIAN PRACTICE The terms of the problem GENCap workshop, February 2012

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. OLD AGE IN HUMANITARIAN PRACTICE The terms of the problem GENCap workshop, February 2012

  2. A matter of principle Humanitarian operations, by and large, appear driven by “knee jerk” reflexes - almost automatic responses based on standard modalities, with little consideration for the actual needs. When looked at from the perspective of older people, in particular, humanitarian operations amount to a fundamental, massive breach of the principle of impartiality.

  3. One common misconception «Old age is an issue for developed countries»

  4. Second common misconception «Old people are taken care of by their families» • “Around the world, family support networks are in decline” UNFPA • Skiped-generationfamilies • Active discrimination

  5. Third common misconception «Old people’s needs are basically the same as for anybody else» • Example 1: HEALTH – Communicable vs. non-communicable diseases • Example 2: FOOD – The consumptiondylemma; dry rations • Example 3: SHELTER – Active exclusion • Example 4: MOBILITY – US and Uganda

  6. Fourth common misconception «Old people are taken care of as part of the overall humanitarian effort» • When assessment data are collected, they are generally not disaggregated by sex and age. (SADD Tufts University study) • In many cases, data about older people are simply not collected. (WHO example; Horn of Africa nutritional survey) • Older people are basically ignored in the planning and execution of humanitarian operations.

  7. “Ignored?” HelpAge International and Handicap International Humanitarian Financing Study 2012 This research study examined the UN Consolidated Appeals Process (CAP) for 14 countries and four Flash Appeals that took place in 2010 and 2011.2 All the projects submitted to these appeals were examined – a total of 6,003, the majority (5,330) under the CAP. In 2010 and 2011, 47 projects (0.78 per cent) included at least one activity targeting older people, and 18 of these were funded (0.3 per cent). In about half of these projects (21), the targeting of older people accounted for less than 25 per cent of total project activities.

  8. Influencing practice in the field • 11 deployments of ageingadvisors to Protection Clusters throughsecondmentfrom HAI to UNHCR • Recentreview: “There is no doubting the popularity and usefulness of the programme for those countries benefiting from a secondment. Nor is there any doubt that 1. it is appropriate, cost-effective and replicable in its implementation, and that 2. significant contributions have been made in each country to best practice in the protection and assistance of older people in emergencies”.

  9. But… • “demand” for the service being more created from the centre than generated from country programmes. • There have been a number of management weaknesses which have impinged on the effectiveness of some assignments. • Being one-off arrangements, there have been inevitable problems in measuring outputs or outcomes. • Continuing technical support, either close or remote, is an enduring issue. • Because they tend to be isolated country experiences, there are questions as to the transferability of good and best practice across and between country programmes

  10. Age and Gender advisors? • Strong rationale as described in the framework paper • Workload/portfolio • Placement • HelpAge ECHO proposal

More Related