160 likes | 339 Views
Utilitarianism. Koreena Baublit Cyndi Mattson Holly Paulin Corey Dixon Tyler Teskey T / 5:30 Ethical Theories Presentation October 21, 2008. Utilitarianism “Greatest Happiness Principle” Provides most good
E N D
Utilitarianism KoreenaBaublit Cyndi Mattson Holly Paulin Corey Dixon Tyler Teskey T / 5:30 Ethical Theories Presentation October 21, 2008
Utilitarianism • “Greatest Happiness Principle” • Provides most good • Does the least harm • Greatest balance of good over harm (community, environment) • Ethical Warfare • Consequences that increase good and decrease harm
Origins of Utilitarianism traces as far back as the Greek Philosopher Epicurus
Jeremy Bentham • Credited for origination • Derived the rule of utility • Good brings greatest happiness to most people
"nature has placed mankind under the governance of two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure."
John Stuart Mill • Wrote Utilitarianism, famous short work • Cultural, intellectual, spiritual pleasures greater value than physical
Criticisms Distastefulness • 1st common • problems when sentiment involved • can’t dismiss emotions such as pity and compassion • Example: Would you kill a hundred citizens or save your mother?
Impossibility • 2nd common • Can’t be quantified or measured • Can’t compare happiness to suffering • Example: From a great amount of suffering sometimes comes great happiness
Too Much Change? • You're at a department store, a grocery store, a restaurant -- and the cashier gives you too much change. • Should you keep it? Is it the store's misfortune and your lucky day? • http://abcnews.go.com/Primetime/Story?id=2754830&page=1
Consider the overall good Keep the money • Gain money for self • Use towards family • Extra money for bills or goods
Consider the overall good Give back the money • Keep money in the economy • Pay for the workers • Sense of Righteousness
The Overall Good • Whole country relies on economy • People need jobs to provide for family and self • Based on these reasons, the answer would be to give back the money
"Primetime" set up hidden cameras in a New Jersey diner and gave the cashier a stack of extra $10 and $20 bills.
Over two days, 46 different people were given too much change. What would they do?
18 returned the money right away, but 26 people walked out. Are you surprised?
Questions • How can you use Utilitarianism to make better decisions in your family affairs? • Can you think of a situation where your idea of overall good differed from that of a friend or family member?