1 / 15

Comparative economic systems

Comparative economic systems. Gabriel Söderberg, Uppsala University. Historical process: Feudalism  Capitalism  Debate / struggle over alternatives  alternatives shape each other Systems always undergoing change Theory vs. Reality , never any pure examples. Before we begin ….

tiara
Download Presentation

Comparative economic systems

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Comparativeeconomic systems Gabriel Söderberg, Uppsala University

  2. Historical process: Feudalism Capitalism  Debate/struggle over alternatives  alternatives shapeeachother • Systems alwaysundergoingchange • Theory vs. Reality, never any pure examples Before webegin…

  3. Decidewhat is to be produced • Organizeresources (human labor, energysources, tools, machinesbuildingetc) for the production • Allocate the productionresults • Decidehowtoreinvestmentsurplus (ifany!) • Providelegitimacy for the economic distribution What do economic systems do?

  4. Private ownershipofproductionresources (factories, machines, raw materials)  owners = ”capitalists” • Workersreceiveswages, • Capitalists ownproduction and sells it for money profit • Consumersdecide the product (consumersovereignty) • Capitalists decidehowtoreinvest profit  ackumulation • The capitalists organizeproduction, and the ”Invisible Hand” of the market ensures social efficiency Capitalism (in theory)

  5. After Industrial Revolution • Unprecedentedproductionincrease new richclass, ”capitalists/Bourgeoisie” • A new group: workers • Poverty, severeconditions in factories • Beginningofthoughts on howtochange the system Capitalism ca. 1840

  6. Systematized Socialism, provided a moreintellectuallycoherent program • Historyprogressesthrough a numberof different economic systems: Feudalism, Capitalism, Socialism • Technologicaldevelopment social tensions (classstruggle)  new system • Capitalismrevolutionizestechnology impoverishmentof the laborclass  revolution  socialism allowed by the technologycreated by capitalism Marxism

  7. Not muchto go on from Marx! • Plannedeconomy • Market socialism • Mixed economy (most/all capitalist systems) Socialism???

  8. World Wars plannedwareconomies  socialism possible? • Ludwig von Mises 1921: Needof market to set prices for calculation • Friedrich von Hayek 1945: Market necessarytochannel information to humans withlimitedunderstanding • Information is the crucial problem of socialism  socialism is impossible! ”The Socialist CalculationDebate”

  9. Markets not necessarily capitalist • Market mechanismbetterthan planning • Oskar Lange: • Consumersovereignty, central planning board experiments withprices, adjustsproductionafterconsumption • State ownsfactories, but managers acttominimizecosts as if on market • Interest in computation and statistics as guidance Market socialism

  10. Labor unions  higherwages  betterworkcondittions • Increasedrightstovote governmentsintroduceregulations, social securityetc • Split between social democracy and communistparties • Depression of the 1930s  bad reputation ofcapitalism • Mixed economies: large public sector, regulated markets, social securityetc 1900-1960 Socialism changescapitalism

  11. ”Temporary arrangement” on the wayto Socialism  technologicaldevelopmentimportant • First 5-year plan ca 1930 • State owns all productiveresources • Planners not consumersdecidewhattoproduce • Planners set prices and wages • After 1991 quick market reform (”shocktherapy”) 1917-1991 Sovietplannedeconomy

  12. After 1945: Extension ofSovietmodelto Eastern Europe • 1960s: reform attemptstoincrease market mechanism • Yugoslavia: work-managedproductionunits • Hungary, Poland: market reforms from 1968 • Less reform in othercountries: Albania, Romaniaetc • After 1991 quicktransitionto market economies 1960-1991 Eastern Europe

  13. Attack against ”socialist capitalism” • Deregulationsof markets • Business-friendly, anti-regulationpoliticianselected: Thatcher in UK, Reagan in USA • Fall of socialism  ”There is No Alternative” • ”Heroiccapitalism” • Market efficiencyemphasized, reforms toensure social efficiency 1980- Neoliberalism

  14. Deng Xiaoping • Markets reforms: ”Economic Special Zones”, decollectivizationofagriculture, introductionofprivately-ownedcompanies • ”Socialism withChinesecharacteristics” • Communist party still in control, cf. Russia/Eastern Europé • Future? 1979- China, Market reforms

  15. Financialmeltdown 2008  falsehoodof market efficiency? • Environmentalcrisis in a system based on constant ackumulation? • Technologies thatdissolves private property (file-sharing, 3d-printers etc)? • Completemechanizationofproduction  no workersneeded whowillbuyproducts? Wherearewe going?

More Related