150 likes | 162 Views
This study explores the asymmetric dominance effect in consumer decision making, analyzing its robustness, theoretical implications, and practical applications in the marketplace. Lessons and open research questions are also discussed.
E N D
Asymmetric Dominance: Generalizations and Lessons Joel Huber-Duke University
What instigated the initial study? • Duncan Luce argued that only regularity had not been violated • Regularity specifies that you cannot increase the probability of choosing an item by adding an item to the set • John Payne, Chris Puto and I then designed a task that combined many known context effects to violate regularity • We did not know whether it would work; in hindsight, it was a low probability experiment
Example of Asymmetric Dominance Effect For a big dinner you are indifferent between these two restaurants Ambience + (Q=***, A=****) 50% Shr + (Q=****, A=***) 50% Shr Food Quality
Example of Asymmetric Dominance Effect What happens if we add a restaurant with great ambience but lower quality? Ambience + (Q=**, A=****) + (Q=***, A=****) 2% Shr 60% Shr + (Q=****, A=***) 38% Shr Food Quality
How robust is the effect? • Birds do it, bees do it • Consumers in markets choosing beans do it • Works with real gambles • Works with complex stimuli • Attributes do not have to be common, or even continuous, only ordered
What makes the asymmetric dominance effect stronger? • Accountability, need to justify • Less processing capacity or time pressure • Greater attribute knowledge • Presence of a no-choice option • Choices over ratings
What makes it go away? • Repeated choices within a category • Does not happen in choice based conjoint • Asymmetric dominance requires current construction of preferences • Lack of transparency in the dominance relationship • Preference ambiguity within attributes • Difficulty realizing one alternative is dominant
General theoretical approaches • Attribute importance (weight shift) • Market inference • Range-importance effect • Position of alternatives change (perceptual shift) • Anchoring on the dominated alternative • Range-frequency mechanism • Utility from dominance (value shift) • Conscious-articulate • Automatic-inarticulate
Example of Asymmetric Dominance Effect What happens if we add a restaurant with great ambience but lower quality? Ambience + (Q=**, A=****) + (Q=***, A=****) 2% Shr 60% Shr + (Q=****, A=***) 38% Shr Food Quality
General theoretical results • Most hypothesized effects matter, but differ in their magnitude and generality • Attribute weight effects are hardest to derive and prove (little carryover) • Perceptual effects matter, mostly when perceptual judgments (ratings) are evoked • For choice, direct short-term, automatic utility from dominance appears to be the most important process
Remaining theoretical questions • Impact differs by attribute used—high priced decoys are far more effective than low priced ones • Detailed processing account—what happens to search after discovering a dominance relationship • Unified response surface model--integrating dominated, compromise and phantom effects.
Asymmetric dominance–more than a quarter century old! • Asymmetric dominance has come of age as a classic context effect, like loss aversion and framing • Now assumed, used as a manipulation to bring about preference for an item • Schemer-schema: How much do people use ASD to affect other’s choices? What is their reaction to such manipulation?
Why asymmetric dominance spawned so much research • Effect is robust and general, but perplexing • Easy to conceptualize—two dimensions, decoy, target, competitor provide a good story • Easy to run, multiple categories, quick choices • Open-ended conceptually: Expands into different tasks, compromise and phantom alternatives • Open-ended theoretically. It can be used to validate many different theories
Final Lessons • Conduct research in areas where the surprise coefficient is large • Simple story, clear characters • Domain not explored • Relevant to markets • Do not try to resolve all the issues…leave room for other questions and researchers • Be alert for anomalies, public challenges, and emperors lacking clothes!