60 likes | 366 Views
Resiko / bahaya perbandingan hukum ( The perils of comparative law ) dan Keuntungan / nilai lebih perbandingan hukum ( The virtues of comparative law ). R. Herlambang Perdana Wiratraman , SH., MA. Fakultas Hukum Universitas Airlangga E. herlambang@unair.ac.id P. +6281357819129.
E N D
Resiko/bahayaperbandinganhukum(The perils of comparative law) danKeuntungan/nilailebihperbandinganhukum(The virtues of comparative law) R. HerlambangPerdanaWiratraman, SH., MA. FakultasHukumUniversitasAirlangga E. herlambang@unair.ac.id P. +6281357819129
Menurutanda, apa yang membahayakandalamsuatukajianperbandinganhukum?
Resiko • Superficial (dangkal) • Getting the foreign law wrong (kelirumendapatsumberhukum) • Scarcely be systematic (jarang/kurangsistematis) • The system chosen for study may have no proper relationship, and the conclusion will be lacking in significance • Argue too easily from them to a similar situation in another system which has a relationship with it. Watson 1993: 10-15
Menurutanda, apakeuntunganketikamelakukansuatukajianperbandinganhukum?
Keuntungan • Understanding of nature of law and of legal development • Systematic study of foreign system • Unsystematic knowledge • The subject matter, historical relationship • Borrowing and transmissibility • Rules and their effects
Ketikamelakukanriset thesis misalnya, bagaimanaandabisamengelolaresikoperbandinganhukumtersebut? • Apaprasyarat yang diperlukanuntukmengurangiresiko?