190 likes | 265 Views
Strategies for Improving the Primary and Secondary Bond Markets in Taiwan Paul Hsueh Professor of Finance National Chung Cheng University 11/20/2009. Presentation Outline. Session Topic Strategies for prospering the primary and secondary bond markets Focus of my presentation
E N D
Strategies for Improving the Primary and Secondary Bond Markets in TaiwanPaul HsuehProfessor of FinanceNational Chung Cheng University11/20/2009
Presentation Outline • Session Topic • Strategies for prospering the primary and secondary bond markets • Focus of my presentation • Taiwan bond market had the highest bond trading turnover in Asia (ex. Japan), but the trading activity has declined significantly in recent years • Highlight the problems in the market and provide suggestions for improving the current situation
Impact of Global Financial Crisis • Credit squeeze • Mortgages, junk bonds,…. • Fire sales of risky bonds and flocking to government bonds • flight to quality • Liquidity squeeze • Higher-grade corporate bonds, Structured notes, Auction-rate securities, …….. • flight to liquidity
US Treasury/Corp. Bond Yields Widening and narrowing credit spread through the crisis period 10-yr IG 10-yr Treasury
Taiwan Treasury/Corp. Bond Yields Relatively stable credit spread throughout the crisis
US Bond Market Issuance Volume in $US billions Corp. T-bond Significant increase in T-bond issuance following the crisis
Taiwan Bond Market Issuance Volume in $NT billions Relatively stable T-bond issuance T-bond Corp.
Daily Trading Volumein US Bond Market in $US billions T-bond Not significantly affected by the Crisis Corp.
Daily Trading Volumein Taiwan Bond Market in $NT billions T-bond Volume dropped long before the Crisis began Corp.
Problems Facing Taiwan Bond Market • Monopolistic T-bond investors • Disappearing bond mutual fund • Malfunctioning bond futures market
Holding Concentration of 5-year OTR T-bond in Taiwan Top 3 investors hold over 60% of on-the-run government bonds
Holding Concentration of 10-year OTR T-bond in Taiwan Top 3 investors hold over 80% of on-the-run government bonds
Monopolistic T-bond investors • Deterrent to other bond investors • Unreasonable special repo rate • Threat of short squeeze for bond futures sellers
Shrinking Bond Mutual Fund • Important institutional investor in the bond market • Major player in the early development of Taiwan bond market • Decreasing bond fund assets in recent years
Trends in Bond Fund Investing in the US in $US billions Money Market Funds Financial crisis attracts more money into bond funds Bond Funds
Trends in Bond Fund Investingin Taiwan in $NT billions Money Market/Bond Funds Separation of M.M. fund and Bond fund Trading volume < 1% are in bond funds Bond funds play a vital role in secondary market trading activity
Malfunctioning Bond Futures Market • Bond futures facilitates cash market trading and offers a vital hedging function • Taiwan’s T-bond futures started in 2004 but only with sluggish activities • Physical delivery is hampered by the illiquidity of deliverable bonds
Trading Volume and Open Interest of T-bond Futures in Taiwan No. of Contracts Dominated by far-month contracts and day trade Trading Volume Not used for hedging purpose
Conclusions • Taiwan bond market is facing serious problems and global financial crisis is not the cause • Position limits on OTR T-bond holdings • Tax incentives for bond mutual funds • Cash delivery of T-bond futures