1 / 11

Maternal Health: Implications of the ruling and the case

Maternal Health: Implications of the ruling and the case. KABANDA DAVID CENTER FOR HEALTH, HUMAN RIGHTS AND DEVELOPMENT (CEHURD). Maternal health.

uriel-wolfe
Download Presentation

Maternal Health: Implications of the ruling and the case

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Maternal Health: Implications of the ruling and the case KABANDA DAVID CENTER FOR HEALTH, HUMAN RIGHTS AND DEVELOPMENT (CEHURD)

  2. Maternal health • What is the right to health---The right to health can be construed as (1) a right to health care and (2) a right to conditions that promote good health. Article 12 of the ICESCR. • Maternal health is comprised in or from pregnancy, childbirth and in the postpartum period (up to the 42nd day after delivery

  3. Maternal mortality and its causes in Uganda • MMR in Uganda is high at 435/100,000 live births Causes • hemorrhage (26%), sepsis (22%), obstructed labour (13%), unsafe abortion (8%) and hypertensive disorders in pregnancy (6%). • Three delays – delay to seek care, delay to reach facilities and delay to receive care. (see the road map to accelerate reduction of MM)

  4. WHY LEGAL ACTION • 16 women die every day in Uganda due to avoidable maternal health related causes. • Government of Uganda phased out traditional birth attendants • Government of Uganda scrapped the user fees in Uganda. • Special rappotur on the right to health in 2001 highlighted that Uganda was not doing enough to realizing the right to health.

  5. contn • Art 33 of the constitution on the right of women as mothers • CEDAW made recommendations that you this un acceptable death of women in giving birth is discriminatory. • Women’s rights to life, health, non-discrimination entitle them to the services and care they need to go through pregnancy and childbirth safely. . • Uganda ratified all the international instruments on the right to health. • Art 45

  6. The petition and ruling • The main contention was/is that the avoidable maternal death is unconstitutional. • That the government has neglected and has failed to respect rights of women. The strategy? It was aimed at having every one involved and this resulted into a coalition of over 40 CSOs

  7. contn • At the hearing an objection was raised –political question doctrine and the court upheld the same ‘The acts and omissions complained of fall under the doctrine of “political question”.” Court further stated “Much as it may be true that government has not allocated enough resources to the health sector and in particular the maternal health care services, this court is, reluctant to determine the questions raised in this petition”

  8. Implications of the ruling/case on maternal health care • Negative Non vindicatation of the right tohealth/maternal health rights. Demoralisation of some maternal health activists Setting a bad precedent on the litigation of such issues and particularly maternal health in uganda

  9. contn • Positive • Even before the ruling we saw maternal audits in selected hospitals • Maternal kits have been and are continously being supplied in some hospitals • Strengthen coalition on maternal health in uganda • Individual cases/litigation of maternal mortality have started sprung up • Parliamentary activism—motion on maternal health and health budget influence. • Opportunity for a wider platform for interpretation in the supreme court and later at the international level--- • Improved maternal health services in general hospitals

  10. conclusion Why we do and should do this work on maternal health is • …….Not simply because these are women in the prime of their lives.... Not simply because a maternal death is one of the most terrible ways to die.... But above all because almost every maternal death is an event that could have been avoided, and should never have been allowed to happen.’

  11. MANY THANKS KABANDA DAVID Center for Health, Human rights and Development (CEHURD) Kabanda & Co.Advocates Plot 614 Tufnell Drive Kamwokya

More Related