1 / 18

Standard Setting Political Issues

Standard Setting Political Issues. Class Announcements. Assignment #10 due March 31st; available on-line Research Paper Part #4 and bonus due April 3 rd

wylie-evans
Download Presentation

Standard Setting Political Issues

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Standard Setting Political Issues

  2. Class Announcements • Assignment #10 due March 31st; available on-line • Research Paper Part #4 and bonus due April 3rd • Business Banquet - April 2nd – 5:45-8pm, Catering - Gabrieau's Bistro; Keynote Speaker - Annette Verschuren, Past President of Home Depot for Canada and Asia • Final Exam 7:00pm April 19th, Main Gym, Oland Centre

  3. Class Objectives • Incentives for Production of Information • Regulation (e.g. setting standards) as a political process • Standard setting process in Canada • Theories of standard setting

  4. Standard Setting: Regulation • Standard setting is the regulation of firms external information production decisions by some central authority • Information asymmetry used to justify regulation • Accounting is a highly regulated area of economic activity • Regulation includes: minimum disclosure, GAAP, GAAS, audits

  5. Standard Setting: Incentives for Information Production • Contractual • Compensation contracts • IPO • Market-Based (non-contractual) • Securities markets (firm value) • Managerial labour markets (Reputation) • Takeover market (corporate control) • Other • Disclosure Principle • Signaling • Private information Search

  6. Standard Setting: Political • A demand for information production as a result of information symmetry creates the demand for regulation. • Because of the problem of unanimity, investors push for regulation causes standard setting to be a political process • Natural to expect that the various constituencies would appeal to the political process when conflicting views can not be resolved by contractual or market forces. • In standard setting, the interests of managers, small investors, large investors and other must be traded-off

  7. Standard Setting • What is the standard setting process? • In Canada http://www.frascanada.ca/accounting-standards-board/what-we-do/about-the-acsb/index.aspx • Internationally http://www.ifrs.org/How-we-develop-standards/Pages/How-we-develop-standards.aspx

  8. Standard Setting in Canada • CICA Handbook is the major source of accounting and auditing standards in Canada • Accounting Standards Boards (AcSB) establishes standards for Handbook • ASB: Structure • Voluntary board members; administrative staff and full time chair • Publishes standards on its own authority • Advised Private Enterprise Advisory Committee, its members and staff • 2/3rds of Board must be CICA members (broaden representation)

  9. Standard Setting in Canada (cont’d) • ASB: New standards • Requires 2/3rd approval of Board members (supermajority voting) • Exposure drafts enable reaction to standards by all interested parties • ASB: Timeliness • Due process requires time • Guidelines are interpretations of standards • See www.cica.ca

  10. Standard Setting in the US • FASB’s purpose is to establish and improve standards • Part of a three part organization • Independent of AICPA • Consists of 7 full time Board members • 5/7ths majority to pass a standard • Heavy emphasis on due process

  11. International Standard Setting • In 2001 IASB adopted a structure similar to FASB • Board of 14 members (12 full time) • Established to harmonize global economy • Compliance is not mandatory • Process: • Agenda is set by staff, Board, constituents • Solicits comment from constituent based on a decision paper both in writing and in public sessions • Publication of an exposure draft is a mandatory step in due process • After due process is completed, all outstanding issues are resolved and the IASB members have balloted in favor of publication, the IFRS is issued.

  12. International Standard Setting • Benefits: • Cost reduction • International comparability and consistency • Increase market efficiency • Delay: • IASC still in infancy and standards being developed • Strength and stringency issues • Getting US on board • No enforcing mechanism • Perspectives on role of standards • Language translations

  13. Standard Setting: Process Inclusions • 1) Conceptual Framework • 2) Sufficient independence and authority • 3) Accountability to public interest • 4) Thorough and published results • 5) Due process • 6) Decision rationale communicated • 7) Broad vs detailed standards • 8) Small vs. large companies

  14. Two Theories of Standard Setting • 1) Public Interest Theory • Public demand for correction of market failures • Best interest of society • Maximize social welfare • First best approach to standard setting • 2) Interest Group Theory • Presence of a number of interest groups • Various groups lobby to convince regulation • Regulatory maximizes its own welfare • Regulation viewed as a commodity

  15. Standard Setting and Theory • We do not know how to calculate the best tradeoff between conflicting uses of information by investors and managers • Current Standard Setting process is most consistent with Interest Group Theory • Existence of conflicting constituencies • Broad representation • Exposure drafts • Super-majority voting • Due process • Public hearings

  16. Criteria for Standard Setting • 1. Decision usefulness – investor reaction • 2. Costs – • Standard setting process • Management’s adherence to standard • Contract rigidities • Proprietary information • 3. Reduction of asymmetry – improves operation of markets • 4. Consensus – encouraged and necessary for adoption

  17. Standard Setting: Problems • 1) Questions concerning independence • 2) Need better opportunity for interested parties to be heard • 3) Inadequate research, monitoring, enforcement, and education • 4) Internationalization of standards • 5) Cost of process

  18. Class Objectives - Revisited • Incentives for Production of Information • Regulation (e.g. setting standards) as a political process • Standard setting process in Canada • Theories of standard setting

More Related