230 likes | 365 Views
The Sale of Great Lakes Strategies, LLC. A Case Study. Gary Gabel April 24, 2009. Overview of presentation. Positioning Your Firm with an Exit Strategy in Mind What are Buyers Willing to Pay For? Two Types of Buyers What Will Buyers Pay? Why Hire an Investment Bank? The Selling Process.
E N D
The Sale of Great Lakes Strategies, LLC A Case Study Gary Gabel April 24, 2009
Overview of presentation • Positioning Your Firm with an Exit Strategy in Mind • What are Buyers Willing to Pay For? • Two Types of Buyers • What Will Buyers Pay? • Why Hire an Investment Bank? • The Selling Process
Overview of Presentation • Overview of Great Lakes Strategies, LLC • Investment Company Proposals • The Presentation Made to Potential Partners • The Final Offers • Financial Buyer • Strategic Buyer • The Transaction • The Aftermath • Conclusion
Positioning Your Firm With an Exit Strategy in Mind • Revenues • Maximize annuity revenue • Extend client contracts as long as possible • Expenses • Eliminate extraneous expenses: • Excessive compensation • Company cars • Club memberships • Season tickets • Planes, boats
Positioning Your Firm With an Exit Strategy in Mind • People • Develop deep bench strength • Results/Relationships • Make sure quality of your service or product is exceptional • Develop close relationships with customers—make sure they’re not just yours
What Are Buyers Willing to Pay More For? • Eliminate competition • Entry into a complementary market • A book of attractive business • Annuity/recurring revenue • Companies with high earnings/sales • Strong talent
Two Types of Buyers • Strategic—They see you as a way to eliminate competition, enter a new market, buy a book of business, buy a talent base, gain new technology • Financial—They see a vehicle that can generate revenue and increase wealth—because they will buy it at the lowest price possible
What Will Buyers Pay? Most firms are sold for a multiple of EBITDA (Earnings before interest and taxes, depreciation and amortization)
Why Hire an Investment Bank or Business Broker? • They know the business of M&A • They know how to package what you have • You are too emotionally involved • They are experienced negotiators
Deal with your Emotional Expectations • In a strategic sale: • Don’t expect to stick around • Tenure of most entrepreneurs who sell their companies is less than 1 year • Don’t expect your people will be treated well • In a financial sale: • Expect to be hounded regularly to increase earnings
The Selling Process Analysis of Shareholder Objectives Pricing Analysis Selling Memorandum Buyer Log Due Diligence Bids (Letters of Intent) Buyer Contact Presentations to Prospective Buyers Definitive Agreement/ Closing Negotiations
Great Lakes Strategies • Provided outsourcing of benefits to clients ranging in size from 100 employees to 20,000 employees • At time of sale, sales exceeded $11 Million • 115 Employees
The Sale of Great Lakes Strategies Process Began: January 2002 Sale Consummated: December 2002
EBITDA for 2002 (in thousands) • Revenue $11,977 • Expenses $10,444 • Operating Income $1,533 (13%) • Dep and Amort 720 • EBITDA $2,253 (19%)
Offers Financial Buyer • Cash = $10 Million • Seller Note = $2 Million • Total = $12 Million • We retain 30% ownership for a “second payday” Strategic Buyer • $16.2 Million Cash • Earnout of $1.40 for each $1.00 of qualified revenue above $12.5 MM in 2003
Analysis of Financial Buyer Proposal • $10 MM Cash would come from: • $1 MM from Buyer • $5 MM Senior Debt (bank loan) to be paid back by GLS • $4 MM Preferred Stock (7%) • $2MM Seller Note—a note to be paid to us over 7 years at 7% interest
Cost of Financial Buyer Proposal Arrangement Cost to GLS $697,000/year $362,000/year $280,000/year Total = $1,339,000 per year vs. Operating Income of $1,533,000 • $5 Million Senior Debt, financed over 10 years at 7% • $2 Million Management Note for 7 years at 7% • $4 Million Preferred Stock with 7% Coupon
The Final Transaction • Received $15.7 Million Cash • $500,000 deposited in escrow, redeemed 6 months later • $1.4 Million Cash paid in 2003 based on earnout • Total = $17.6 Million
Payment as Multiple of EBITDA for 2002 (in thousands) • Revenue $11,977 • Expenses $10,444 • Operating Income $1,533 (13%) • Dep and Amort 720 • EBITDA $2,253 (19%) • Final Payment • Before Earnout 7.19 X EBITDA • Including Earnout ($1.4 MM) 7.82 X EBITDA
The Aftermath • My tenure in new company lasted 3 months • Employee headcount was reduced from 115 to 65 within one year of acquisition • Had to separate myself emotionally from events at company • Clients became disenchanted with new level of service • Client attrition increased • Site was closed July 2008 • Less than 10 employees remain with new company