140 likes | 238 Views
Innovation, Productivity and Welfare - Marcel Timmer Groningen Growth and Development Centre University of Groningen Presentation for t he 2008 World Congress on NAEP Measures for Nations. Motivation. Imagine a small open economy with two sectors:
E N D
Innovation, Productivity and Welfare - Marcel Timmer Groningen Growth and Development Centre University of Groningen Presentation for the 2008 World Congress on NAEP Measures for Nations
Motivation • Imagine a small open economy with two sectors: • Stagnant services sector (producing for domestic demand) • Dynamic Telecommunication equipment manufacturing (mainly for export) • Do workers gain in welfare when productivity growth is high in telecom? • Innovation can have two counteracting effects on welfare • Improve productivity • Declining terms-of-trade
This paper • Trace the contributions of individual sectors to overall real income growth • Productivity growth in a sector will contribute positively, but part of gains might spillover to foreigners. This will depend on share of exports and on terms-of-trade (price exports over price imports). • Use two approaches: • GDP function approach (Kohli, Diewert) • Production possibility approach (Gollop) • Empirical application to Finnish economy
Decomposing real GDP growth • GDP (net output) function : Kohli (1990); Diewert and Morrison (1986). Follow Kohli (2004) • Q (real income) is nominal GDP divided by price of domestic expenditure, while Y is nominal GDP with X and M deflated seperately (real production). • NB Prices of exports and imports relative to price dom exp
Sectoral contributions • Breakdown aggregates into sectoral contributions (in the spirit, but not equal to Diewert, 2008): • Define aggregate technical change (A) and Export prices as Tornqvist volume aggregation of sectors
Data • Need value added, labour, capital and MFP (technical change) by industry • EU KLEMS database (www.euklems.com) • Need export values and prices by industry • Not available. Use Input-output table to divide industry output into X and F (from Eurostat IO-database) • Assume price of industry output is the same for all uses.
Alternative approach • Net output approach ignores role of intermediate inputs. Technical change only affects K and L. • Following Gollop (1982), our model of an open economy is set up by defining sectoral production possibility frontiers for each sector j as follows:
Decomposition of growth in real expenditure F • Advantages above GDP approach: • More general definition of technology • Industry deliveries to real expenditure rather than to real income • Role of prices?
Concluding remarks • Advantages of production possibilities frontier approach above GDP approach: • More general definition of technology • Industry deliveries to real expenditure rather than to real income • Innovation gains can spill over internationally • Decomposition is silent on causality: Why do export and import prices change?