660 likes | 954 Views
Design Process. Design process is a collection of procedures and habits that help teams design better products. The Process of Design. Designing is the process of making many decisions that converts a need into a hardware reality. Need. Product. 7-Step Design Process.
E N D
Design Process Design process is a collection of procedures and habits that help teams design better products
The Process of Design • Designing is the process of making many decisions that converts a need into a hardware reality. Need Product
7-Step Design Process • Product Design Specifications (PDS) • External Search (Research) • Internal Search (Brainstorming) • Concept Evaluation and Selection • Detail Design (Engineering) • Prototyping and Testing • Documentation
What Product?ToyTown Top Executives Water Balloon Rope Climber Can Crusher Better Mouse Trap Coin Sorter Nail Driver Rope Climber
Customer Input • Climbs fast • Affordable as a birthday present • Fully assembled • Uses batteries for power • No small parts – is safe • Looks good • Plays music as it climbs • Glows in the dark • Lasts a long time • Would not violate any patents
Graphical Representation of PDS START Patents Battery Life Slow Silent Expensive No Glow Unsafe Indoors Only
PDS CompromisesDesired versus Required Desired Boundary Retail < $45 Acceptable Boundary Retail < $50
PDS Compromises High Priority Plays Music Low Priority Glow in the dark
Customer Needs • Cannot be taken apart • Has no small parts or sharp edges • Only to be used indoors • It is light and compact • Does not use toxic materials • Fits into a small box for shipping • Has attractive packaging • Design and testing finished in 4 months • Quantity 1 Million
Engineering Specifications • Climbs at 1 ft/s or faster • Retail cost is to be less than $45 • Uses 2 AA batteries • Has 0 removable small parts • Music loudness between 20-30 db • Luminosity is to be more than 5 C • Works for minimum 3 hours on 2 AA
External Search • Level-I • Rope climbing toys / machines • Rope climbers (sports or circus) • Nature (spiders, bats, etc) • Level-II (friction wheels selected) • Hoists • Trolleys • Ski Lifts
Internal Search & Evaluation • Brainstorming • Generate many ideas • Evaluate against PDS • Evaluate risks • Select one to engineer
Detail Design (Engineering) MoreAbstract Engineering Less Abstract
Design Process • Applies to Top-level decisions • Applies to lower levels decisions • Define requirements • Search for existing ideas/technologies • Brainstorm for solutions • Pick a candidate • Determine the details
Product Development Process PDS Candidate Design Detail Design Concept Synthesis Prototyping Concept Evaluation Release for Production Candidate Design
Detail Design Candidate Design Components No Numbers System-Level Design Parameter Design Numbers Prototype Testing Release for Production
Complexities of Developing a PDS Document • Level-I: • Goal is clear, “Design a X to do Y” • specifications are known, • priorities are known, • no mass production concerns, • IP issues not important, • limited customer base • Example: one-of-a-kind equipment.
Complexities of Developing a PDS Document • Level-II: • Goal is specific “Design a X to do Y”, • Specifications are unknown, • Priorities are unknown, • Mass production concerns, • IP issues are important, • expanded customer base • Example: Most consumer products
Complexities of Developing a PDS Document • Level-III: • Goal is unclear, “Design ? To do ? • There is a general statement of need • Not easy to get to: “Design X to do Y” • Example: Oceans are rising
Customers • People who define the PDS • People who influence product success • People you cannot ignore Team Globe (External) Company (Internal)
What is a successful Product? • A successful product: • Sells well and makes a lot of profit • Would not violate any laws/regulations • What about: • Safer than law requires? • Solves some problems of humanity? • Is green (energy efficient, recycles, etc)? • Lasts more than warranty period? • Perform better than required? Only when they relate to 1) or 2)
Product Design Customers • Customers • The design team and its members are not customers • Every PDS statement must be associated with at least one customer • Internal customers are within the organization (management, marketing) • External customers are outside the organization(end users)
External Customers Company Buyers Retailer End Users Maintenance EXTERNAL Government & Standards Society (Marketing)
Internal Customers Manufacturing & Procurement Management Marketing Internal Shipping Packaging Legal
What Do They Want? • End users want • Performance & Functionality • Affordability • Ease of use including ergonomics • Reliability and Long life • Robustness • Versatility • Safety • Low maintenance and easy assembly • Esthetics
External Customers • Buying managers want • Low Cost/Performance • Safety • Ruggedness (abuse resistance) • Ergonomics • Long warrantees • Reliable with Low downtime • Low operating cost
External Customers • Retailers want • Small and attractive packaging • Long shelf life • Low cost high profit • Exciting features • Maintenance wants • Ease of maintenance • Low cost of maintenance
External Customers • Government wants • Conformance to laws and regulations • Standards want • Conformance to industry standards • Conformance to codes
Internal Customers • Management wants • Make $$$ • On time delivery • Low risk of financial failure • Proper Documentation • Process: Conformance to company product development process
Internal Customers • Marketing wants • Attractive features to target buyers • Low retail price • Esthetics • Attractive packaging • Ease of user assembly/maintenance • On time delivery • Long Warrantees
Internal Customers • Manufacturing / Purchasing want • Available materials • Manufacture-able at low cost. • Conformance to company documentation formats. • Use of products from preferred vendors.
Internal Customers • Legal wants • No patent infringements • Safety • All required safety warnings and labels • Protection against reasonable abuse • Safety manual • Conformance to laws and regulations
Internal Customers • Shipping and Packaging • Small (standard) package sizes • Ability of locking or fixing sensitive components • Resistance against damage due to dropping, vibrations, moisture, heat, and cold.
Product Design Specification • Is this a PDS item? • Is there a customer associated with it? • Does the information limit the design selections and choices? • Can the requirement be designed into the product? • High resale value • Win the Noble Prize
Product Design Specification • Elements of PDS • Performance (Primary customer: End User) • Speed, • Capacity, • Power, • Efficiency, • Accuracy, • Return on investment • etc.
Elements of PDS • Environment:(User) • Temperature range, rain, humidity, dust. • Life in service:(User) • 10 years, 5000 cycles, etc. • Maintenance:(User) • The market policy, what customers accept • Retail/Production cost:(User) • Consistent with comparable products • Rule of thumb 4:1
Elements of PDS • Shipping/packaging: • Package sizes + Weights • Damage resistance
Elements of PDS • Quantity(Marketing) • Determined by marketing • Manufacturing facility (Management) • Does the company policy dictate certain facilities?
Element of PDS • Size and shape (Marketing) • Weight (Marketing) • What is the desired weight? • Handles for lifting points? • Modular? • Aesthetics (Marketing) • Color, shape, form, texture, finish. • Market research.
Elements of PDS • Materials (Marketing, Codes, Regulations) • Left to designers unless company guidelines or regulations restrict certain materials (asbestos, lead). • Product life span (Marketing) • Designed life
Elements of PDS • Laws, Codes, and standards (Government) • Ergonomics (User + Marketing + buyers)
Elements of PDS • Quality and reliability (Marketing) • Company policy regarding warranties • Failure rate during warrantee period • Testing (Marketing) • Tests to perform to verify performance and other PDS requirements • Industry standard tests
Elements of PDS • Shelf life (storage) - Retail • Possibility of rust, decay, deterioration • Processes (Mangement) • Conformance to certain standards (GD&T or ISO 9000 for example) • Use of company procedures • Time-scales (deadlines) - Management • Whole design project, milestones
Elements of PDS • Safety (User, Government, Legal) • Safety requirements mandated by government • Professional society's codes and standards • Need for warning labels • Design against Acceptable degrees of abuse
Elements of PDS • Company constraints (Management) • Compatibility with other products • Documentation (Management – Legal) • Full documentation (Guard against possible litigation) • Safety, Operation, and Service documents.
Elements of PDS • Legal (Lawyers) • Product liability law suits associated with similar products and why. • Relevant patents
Element of PDS • Installation (Installers) • Connection geometry. • Various models to install • Disposal (Marketing) • Recyclable? • bio-degradable? • Green
Other Element of PDS • Other possible PDS items to include • Rugged • Easy to use • Reliable • Quiet • Portable • Source of energy
Before you Interview Sponsors • Prepare your questions (PDS) • Let them do most of the talking • Take notes • Ask for clarification • Do not be annoying (you can always ask more questions later if deemed important)