100 likes | 235 Views
Development and Approval of Drugs and Devices EPI260 Lecture 12: Lessons from Drug Development June 3, 2010 Richard Chin, M.D. Overview. How regulations evolve Risks of drug development CAST FIAU University of Pennsylvania Vioxx Tysabri TeGenero. Regulations.
E N D
Development and Approval ofDrugs and DevicesEPI260 Lecture 12: Lessons from Drug DevelopmentJune 3, 2010Richard Chin, M.D.
Overview • How regulations evolve • Risks of drug development • CAST • FIAU • University of Pennsylvania • Vioxx • Tysabri • TeGenero
Regulations • Regulations tend to be reactive • Elixir of Sulfanilamide • Thalidomide • CAST • Risk management • New tools for FDA • Practice of medicine • Difference in other countries
Risks of Drugs and Drug Development • Drugs are poisonous • Clinical trials are dangerous by design • Testing limits • Testing new drugs and indications • Informed consent and IRBs • No direct relationship with patients • Social benefits outweigh risks
CAST • Post-MI patients are at risk for sudden death • Ectopy predictive of death • Antiarrhythmic drugs reduce ectopy
FIAU • Fialuridine was a Hep B drug candidate • 15 patients exposed • 5 died • 2 required liver transplantation • Study conducted at NIH – NIDDK • Investigations by IOM, FDA, NIH • Conclusion was that studies were justified, consents were obtained properly, the studies were adequately monitored for the most part
University of Pennsylvania Gene Therapy • Gene therapy study of ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency, an X-linked genetic disease of the liver • Jesse Gelsinger volunteered for the study, and died • Multiple failures in conduct of the study • Improper informed consent (key information missing) • Protocol violation in enrollment (Jesse has high ammonia levels) • Other failures • Significant financial conflict of interest
Tysabri • Alpha 4/Beta 7 inhibitor • Highly effective for MS • Approved on basis of reduction in relapses • PML found in several patients • Drug pulled from market • Now back on with closed distribution channel
TeGenero • TGN1412 – agonist antibody to CD28 (BAD idea!) • 6 patients enrolled rapidly into Phase I • All developed DIC and cytokine storm • All admitted into ICU, all survived • TeGenero out of business • New rules for Phase I studies