250 likes | 384 Views
Optimal vaccination strategies against Bluetongue in Denmark. Kaare Græsbøll Technical University of Denmark (DTU) GEOVET - August 2013 Claes Enøe René Bødker Lasse Engbo Christiansen. Overview. Introduction: What is bluetongue? Model: Key aspects and the tested scenarios. Results:
E N D
Optimal vaccination strategies against Bluetongue in Denmark Kaare Græsbøll Technical University of Denmark (DTU) GEOVET - August 2013 Claes Enøe René Bødker Lasse Engbo Christiansen
Overview • Introduction: • What is bluetongue? • Model: • Key aspects and the tested scenarios. • Results: • Doses, herd visits, and a little economics. • Discussion: • Best strategy?
Bluetongue – a vector borne disease • Relies on a Culicoides (biting midge) vector Figure reproduced from Wilson, Darpel & Mellor (2008), PLoS Biology 6(8):e210; http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0060210. Reproduced under a Creative Commons Attribution License (CCAL2.5).
Bluetongue virus • 26 serotypes • Infects ruminants (cattle, sheep, goats, …) • Symptoms: fever, swollen head, blue tongue, decrease in milk production, drooling, lameness… • Prevention: Vaccination, Protection Zones, Movement restrictions • Costs: northern Europe 2006 – 2010: • > 1 billion € Fao.org Institute of Animal Health UK
Bluetongue virus: spatial extent Figure by: Tabachnick, W J (2010) Reproduced under an open access license. Taken from Journal of Experimental Biology
1 Exposed 1 2 2 …… …… death Exposed n-1 Infectious ñ-1 n ñ Recovered The infection model host - SEIR vector - SEI Susceptible Susceptible Infectious Adaptation from: A modeling framework to describe the transmission of Bluetongue virus within and between farms in Great Britain. Authors: C. Szmaragd, A.J. Wilson, S. Carpenter, J.L.N. Wood, P.S. Mellor, S. Gubbins
Pasture areas in Denmark • Four cattle distribution scenarios: • Stabled • Pasture • Pasture // Size • Pasture // Size // Dairy
Initialisation scenarios – cattle density Cattle / km2
Initialisation scenarios – cattle density Init M Init D Init L
Fraction of cattle to vaccinate to keep epidemic below 1000 affected cattle All farms Random farms Large farms first Small farms first Nearest Neighbour Pasture Southern Jutland Distance to border P: RH: L: S: NN: G: SJ: D2B:
Fraction of cattle to vaccinate to keep epidemic below 1000 affected cattle All farms Random farms Large farms first Small farms first Nearest Neighbour Pasture Southern Jutland Distance to border P: RH: L: S: NN: G: SJ: D2B:
Fraction of cattle to vaccinate All farms Random farms Large farms first Small farms first Nearest Neighbour Pasture Southern Jutland Distance to border P: RH: L: S: NN: G: SJ: D2B:
Fraction of farmsto vaccinate All farms Random farms Large farms first Small farms first Nearest Neighbour Pasture Southern Jutland Distance to border P: RH: L: S: NN: G: SJ: D2B:
Trends Smaller epidemic Smaller epidemic => more doses => L strategy is cheapest Larger epidemic => Fewer doses => G and S strategies are cheapest Regional strategies may be optimal Init D Init M Init L
Acknowledgements Partners: Knowledge Centre for Agriculture, Cattle Danish Agriculture and Food Council Danish Meteorological Institute Aarhus University Funding: Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries