1 / 37

Withholding and Withdrawing in critical dialysis

Withholding and Withdrawing in critical dialysis. 2011-09-19 2012-03-26 蔡壁如. Outline. Case presentation: 現況 Paper review Data report Guideline 初稿. Case presentation. 59yrs male transferred from 雙和醫院

zenda
Download Presentation

Withholding and Withdrawing in critical dialysis

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Withholding and Withdrawing in critical dialysis 2011-09-19 2012-03-26 蔡壁如

  2. Outline Case presentation:現況 Paper review Data report Guideline 初稿

  3. Case presentation • 59yrs male transferred from 雙和醫院 • Bowel perforation, status post explore laparotomy , T-colostomy creation, primary closure of bowel perforation (three times: 5/26, 6/26 , 8/10) • Peri-anal abscess, status post debridement • Intra-abdominal abscess, status post CT-guided pigtail insertion drainage (three times: 7/22, 7/26, 8/15) • Tuberculosis of lung

  4. Case presentation ----SICU History • 2011-07-16 transferred from 雙和醫院 • Perianal abscess, bowel perforation, IAI ( GI bleeding) • Severe sepsis • 2011-8-10 • Op due to bowel perforation and intra-abdominal abscess • 2011-8-12轉回 9A • 2011-8-14 • CT guided : L’t abdominal wall abscess • 2011-8-18轉回9A • 2011-8-29 • Respiratory failure  intubation on 8/30 • Run sepsis check list  early goal  Xigirs use • 2011-9-1 03:00 Expired

  5. Case presentation----CVVH • 2011-8-30 12:40 ~ 2011-9-1 02:25 • Total duration : 36hr 45min

  6. Case presentation-5635578 診斷: Fever of unknown origin Shock status post ECMO implantation • 2010/10/20.羅東醫院轉診 • ED, ID was consulted first : SLE, HIV, infection, • Atypical pnuemonia or infection were considered. • Chest CT was performed on 10/20 • showed patches of consolidations in bilateral lungs and bilateral pleural effusion, pneumonia was suspected

  7. Case presentation-5635578 • emergent inbutaion and con’s loss. • Septic shock with inotropes used (IE: ?) • CV consulted for suspection of myocarditis. The bedside cardiac echo showed LVEF 11%. • ECMO insertion, EMB was performed. • 8/22 17:15 入4A2

  8. Case presentation-5635578 • IVIG was prescribed under the suspicion of acute myocarditis • CAVH on ECMO • DNR • Expired at 8/23 9:29 • ECMO duration:16.2hr • CAVH duration: 11hr

  9. 洗腎和ECMO • 無效醫療 • 醫生用來表達盡心盡力的工具 • 問題是它太昂貴 • ???

  10. Muscle man OHCA-4 5807892 • BH: 176 cm, BW:107.9 kg • Collapse Time:2012-02-25 17:35 • Call EMT:2012-02-25 17:38 • EMT arrived : 2012-02-25 17:40 • NTUH ER time:2012-02-25 18:00 • ER CPR time:2012-02-25 18:00 • ER rhythmic : VT • On ECMO time :02-25 18:45 • ROSC time:02-25 18:45 • HR:72, RR:22, BP:163/122, SpO2:100% • Total CPR time:65 min

  11. Muscle man OHCA-4 5807892

  12. OHCA-1 2302658 • 53yrs, Male, BH:168cm, BW:72.2Kg • 入院診斷 : OHCA, r/o AMI • Collapse time:2012-02-15 09:56 • Call EMT time：2012-02-15 09:57 • EMT arrived time：2012-02-15 09:59 • EMT到達醫院時間: 2012-02-15 10:08 • ER rhythmic : Vf • ECMO run time:2012-02-15 10:43 • Total CPR time:45 min

  13. WBC

  14. OHCA-1 2302658 • POBAS  LAD • Shock related with AKI  CAVH on ECMO • Con’s : E1M3VT • Removed ECMO: 2012-2-21 • Urine amount increased and con’s clear • Extubation and transport to general ward

  15. OHCA-2 王謝月嬌4258693 • 入院診斷 : OHCA, r/o AMI • Collapse time:2012-02-18 10:43 • Call EMT time：2012-02-18 10:46 • EMT arrived time：2012-02-18 10:51 • EMT到達醫院時間: 2012-02-18 11:10 • 急診到院時間:2012-02-18 11:10 • ER rhythmic : Vf • ECMO run time:2012-02-18 11:51 • ROSC time:2012-02-18 11:51 • HR:64, RR: , BP: , SpO2: • Total CPR time:41 min

  16. WBC

  17. 健身房OHCA-3 5806964 • Collapse Time:2012-02-22 21:00, BCLS by coworker • Call EMT time: 2012-02-22 21:05 • EMT arrived time:2012-02-22 21:08 • NTUH time:2012-02-22 21:25 • ER CPR time:2012-02-22 21:25 • ER rhythmic :Vf • On ECMO time :2012-02-22 21:56 • ROSC time:2012-02-22 21:56 • HR:80, RR:8, BP:104/46, SpO2: ? • Total CPR time:54 min

  18. OHCA-3 5806964 • Q10

  19. 恩主公OHCA-5 3099370 • Collapse Time: • Call EMT: • EMT arrived : • NTUH ER time: 2012-02-29 06:13 • ER CPR time: 2012-02-29 16:13 • ER rhythmic : Vf  PEA • On ECMO time : 2012-02-29 06:45 • ROSC time: • HR:72, RR:22, BP:163/122, SpO2:100% • Total CPR time: min

  20. Withholding and withdrawing in critical dialysis

  21. dialysis database data 其中ECMO + CAVH 2009: 2 2010: 5 2011 : 10

  22. ECMO data 黨中央不批准比率 ECMO meeting決議

  23. Mortality, DNR and length of stay in SICU DNR早講，配套措施？？？

  24. AND : Allow-nature-death • “Allow natural death” is not equivalent to “do notresuscitate” • DNR is too vague, whereas ‘‘Allow natural death’’ provides an order with clear intent. • “Allow natural death’’ that is part of a growing call for change.

  25. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 3: 587-593, 2008. doi: 10.2215/CJN.04040907

  26. Seminars in Dialysis—Vol 24, No 2 (March–April) 2011 pp. 208–214

  27. Withholding vs withdrawing Seminars in Dialysis—Vol 24, No 2 (March–April) 2011 pp. 208–214

  28. Evidence-based guideline of withholding or withdrawing dialysis : eight recommendations • shared decision making • informed consent or refusal • Estimating prognosis • conflict resolution • advance directives • special patient groups • Time-limited trials of dialysis • palliative care

  29. Dialysis Feasibility • Staring dialysis condition？ • Severe hypotension, difficulties vascular access, bleeding, hemorrhage diathesis, severe neurological impairment • Should offer to start and/or continue dialysis to everyone ? • involving prognosis and the ethical principles of beneficence • as well as the effect and interactions of others factors which are discussed. (social …..)

  30. The Frequency of Withdrawal from Acute Care Is Impacted by Severe Acute Renal Failure Conclusions: High severity ofillness and prolonged intensive care without improvement beyond 2 weeks presage decisionsto withdraw treatment and signal patients and caregivers that death is imminent and that furtheraggressive care should be reconsidered or limited. • Withdrawing, 48hr death more than 90% • 預期48小時死亡 aggressive care should be limited JOURNAL OF PALLIATIVE MEDICINE Volume 7, Number 5, 2004

  31. Time-limited trials of dialysisTrial of Therapy----Three elements to be evaluated • 1. Define goals of treatment. • 2. Endpoints have to be identified • Delineate criteria for evidence of improvement • Define a time point criteria will be evaluated • Define a magnitude of change accepted as evidence for improvement. • 3. The duration of dialysis trial should be established

  32. Cost Effectiveness of Acute Dialysis • SUPPORT trial • CRRT more expensive than IHD • Renal recovery vs Non-recovery (11.3 vs. 22.5 days, p < 0.001) • Renal recovery vs dependent dialysis (11,192 vs. 73,273 Canadian dollars, p < 0.001) over the year after hospital discharge

  33. Proposed algorithm to help in the decision-making process to withhold dialysis

  34. Proposed algorithm to help in the decision-making process to withdraw dialysis.

  35. Conclusions • Risk assessment prediction scores • 要那些 Scoring ? • Guideline • Data base statistics and analysis

More Related