管理一學門 財務領域國際期刊分級排序專案計畫 - 不動產期刊

1. 管理一學門財務領域國際期刊分級排序專案計畫-不動產期刊管理一學門財務領域國際期刊分級排序專案計畫-不動產期刊 盧秋玲 12/14/2006

2. Outline • Survey • Journal • Reviewer • Impact Factor • Literature • Result

3. Criteria for journal selection • Diaz, Julian, Roy Black, and Joseph Rabianski, 1996, A Note on Ranking Real Estate Research Journals • Evaluate 30 Journals • 22 of them are “Professional Group” • 8 of them are “Academic Group” • Dombrow, Jonathan and Geoffrey Turnbull, 2002, Individuals and Institutions Publishing Research in Real Estate – 1989-1998

4. Results 10 Journals are selected. • Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics • Real Estate Economics • Journal of Real Estate Research • Journal of Housing Economics • Journal of Regional Science • Journal of Urban Economics • Regional Science and Urban Economics • Urban Studies • Journal of Property Research • Journal of Property Investment and Finance (Land Economics was excluded. Because it doesn’t publish much on Real Estate)

5. Criteria for reviewer selection(1) Literature: Dombrow, Jonathan and Geoffrey Turnbull, 2002, Individuals and Institutions Publishing Research in Real Estate – 1989-1998

6. Criteria for reviewer selection(2) • Professors who were ranked in the top 20 of core, base, and broad journals • Finance or real estate professors • Editors of core journals • Professors from England area

7. Result • 14 Reviewers are selected • => 7 reviewers responded • Professors who were ranked in the top 30 of core, base, and broad journals and are in the editorial board of REE and JREFE. • 3 Reviewers were selected • => 3 reviewers responded

8. Adjustment Problem: 1. obvious bias 2. comments are not consistent with ranking result

9. 2. Impact Factor • 2000-2004

10. Ranking by Literature • Diaz, Julian, Roy Black, and Joseph Rabianski, 1996, A Note on Ranking Real Estate Research Journals • Ranking by 13 groups • Select 3 groups: tenured faculty, practitioners, and members of department with real estate title • Redmand, Arnold, Hermand Manakyan, and John Tanner, 1998, The ranking of real estate journals: a citation analysis approach • Rank without self citations • Rank with self citations

11. Result from 林炳輝 (2003) • 林丙輝，2003年，「管理一及管理二學門國際學術期刊及排序專案計畫」 • 受訪財金學者人數眾多，具代表性

12. 表一 國外學者問卷評分彙總資料

13. 表二 影響係數彙總資料

14. 表三 文獻排名彙總資料

15. 表四 財務相關不動產金融期刊排名

16. Reference • Diaz, Julian, Roy T. Black and Joseph Rabianski, 1996, A Note on Ranking Real Estate Research Journals, Real Estate Economics, 24:4, 551-563 • Dombrow, Jonathan and Geoffrey K. Turnbull, 2002, Individuals and Institutions Publishing Research in Real Estate—1989-1998, Journal of Real Estate Literature, 10:1, 45-92. • Dombrow, Jonathan and Geoffrey Turnbull, 2000, Individual and Institutional Contributors to the Journal of Real Estate and Economics: 1988-1999, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 21:2, 203-214. • Faircloth, Sheri and Steve Swidler, 1998, The Publishing of Real Estate Articles Within a Finance Department, Journal of Real Estate Literature, 6: 111-117 • Gibler, M. Karen and Alan J. Ziobrowski, 2002, Authors’ Perceptions and Preferences Among Real Estate Journals, Real Estate Economics, 30:1, 137-157. • Ong, Seow Eng, Joseph Ooi and Nyuk Hien Wong, 2001, Academic papers: Crossing the great divide? A survey of US and UK real estate journals, Journal of Property Investment & Finance, 19:6, 519-534. • Redman, Arnold L., Herman Manakyan and John R. Tanner, 1999, A Normalized Citation Analysis of Real Estate Journals, Real Estate Economics, 27:1, 169-182 • Redman, Arnold L., Herman Manakyan, and John R. Tanner, 1998, The Ranking of Real Estate Journals: A Citation Analysis Approach, Financial Practice and Education—Fall/Winter • 林丙輝，2003年，「管理一及管理二學門國際學術期刊及排序專案計畫」

17. 謝謝!!