170 likes | 340 Views
Cascades, Islands and Streams. Indiana University Bloomington University of Wolverhampton University of Quebec at Montreal Presented by: Dr Kayvan Kousha (Wolverhampton). Project team. Indiana University Bloomington Cassidy Sugimoto (head) Ying Ding Staša Milojević
E N D
Cascades, Islands and Streams Indiana University Bloomington University of Wolverhampton University of Quebec at Montreal Presented by: Dr KayvanKousha (Wolverhampton)
Project team • Indiana University Bloomington • Cassidy Sugimoto (head) • Ying Ding • StašaMilojević • University of Wolverhampton • Mike Thelwall • KayvanKousha (presenting) • University of Quebec at Montreal • Vincent Larivière
http://mapofscience.com/nih.html Project idea • To correct the science bias in maps of science that rely upon journal citations
Our proposal • Integrate several datasets representing a broad range of scholarly activities (not just journal publishing) • Use method triangulation to explore the lifecycle of topics within and across a range of scholarly activities • Develop transparent tools and techniques to enable future predictive analyses
Explore topic emergence differences • Occurs consistently in one type of activity, then cascades in a linear fashion to other areas • OR • Emerges in one area then flows into other areas (streams) • OREmerges in different places and remains in separate islands
Research Questions • What is the nature of topic development in relation to core scholarly activities? • How does the type of activity in which a topic appears impact the lifecycle and duration of that topic?
Datasets • ProQuest Dissertation and Theses database • National Science Foundation grant database • Social Science and Humanities Research Council of Canada grant database • Web of Science (Century of Science database) • Internet discussions • Blogs • Twitter • Mendeley
Topics • Cognitive Science • Digital Humanities • History of Science • Social Network Analysis • We will analyse these four broad topic areas
Methods • Word analysis • Words used as proxies for topics to investigate topic flows over time • Topic modelling • Identifying topics by statistical analysis of word co-occurrences • Burst detection • Identifying sub-topic emergence by detecting significant increases in word frequencies
TEDTalks: Analysis of impact Example of findings:- Cassidy Sugimoto & Mike Thelwall Sugimoto, C.R. & Thelwall, M. (in press). Scholars on soap boxes: Science communication and dissemination via TED videos. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology.
Motivation • New popular genre • Public dissemination of science • Educational videos • Infotainment
Research Questions • In which communication forms do TEDTalks have the greatest impact? • Which disciplinary types of TEDTalks have the greatest impact? • Do different communication forms have similar types of impact?
Some Findings • There was a general consensus about the most popular videos as measured through views or comments on YouTube and the TED site. • Most videos were found in at least one online syllabus and videos in online syllabi tended to be more viewed, discussed and blogged. • Less liked videos generated more discussion. • Science and technology videos presented by academics were more liked than those by non‐academics • ->academics are not disadvantaged in TED
Next step • Integrating web, citation and dissertation data into one huge analysis