110 likes | 215 Views
Managing Early Antiretroviral Failure: Easy Answers for the Busy Clinician—Not!. Joseph J. Eron, Jr, MD. JJ Eron, JR, MD. Presented at IAS –USA /RWCA Clinical Conference, August 2004. The International AIDS Society–USA.
E N D
Managing Early Antiretroviral Failure: Easy Answers for the Busy Clinician—Not! Joseph J. Eron, Jr, MD JJ Eron, JR, MD.Presented at IAS–USA/RWCA Clinical Conference, August 2004. The International AIDS Society–USA
GS 903 Study: Week-144 Virologic Outcomes of Tenofovir DF vs Stavudine + 3TC/EFV Intent to Treat (Missing = Failure) 100 80 73% 69% 60 Patients with HIV-1 RNA < 50 copies/mL (%) 40 TDF + 3TC + EFV 20 d4T + 3TC + EFV 0 0 24 48 72 96 120 144 Weeks Gallant et al. Abstract TuPeB4538.
Duration of Initial Therapy The first regimen will be time-limited Chen et al 9th CROI
First Salvage: After 1st Rx • Most virologic failure is not clinical or immunologic failure • Frequently virologic failure is not regimen failure • Most regimen failure is not due to broad resistance
Virologic FailureDoes Not Equal Immune or Clinical DeclineFrench Cohort (N=2236): 100 95 IR+/VR+ IR+/VR- 90 IR-/VR+ Percent alive and AIDS-free 85 IR-/VR- 80 75 6 12 18 24 30 . Months since introduction of PI Grabar, et al, Ann Intern Med 2000
Patterns of Virologic Failure Limited response HIV RNA level Rebound Blip Sustained low level viremia Re-suppression Suppression Time
First Failure and Resistance • HIV-1 Resistance may be limited • 20-50% of patients may have HIV-1 with no evidence of resistance • If present, resistance usually arises to more potent components of the regimen with low genetic barrier • 3TC • NNRTI • Nelfinavir • Resistance to enhanced PI may be very limited
Initial Resistance NNRTI-based Regimens • NNRTI resistance mutations • 45 to 80% of early failures • 3TC resistance • 30-50% of early failures • Other resistance mutations (e.g. TAMs, K65R) • < 10%
PI Resistance • PI mutations uncommon in early virologic failure • Some primary PI mutations not associated with cross-resistance eg, D30N (NFV), I50L (ATV) • Others associated with cross-resistanceeg, 82, 84, 90 (LPV/RTV, IDV, SQV) • Accumulation of secondary mutations associated with increasing cross-resistance
Resistance Mutations with Boosted vs Unboosted Fosamprenavir * Excluding common natural polymorphisms observed in absence of other RT or PR mutations Macmanus S et al. 10th CROI, Boston, 2003, Abstract 598.
After 1st Rx • Summary • Most virologic failure is not clinical or immunologic failure • Most virologic failure is not regimen failure • Assess causes of virologic failure • Most regimen failure not due to broad resistance • Nucleoside resistance extremely important • Second line therapy should be more successful than observed in studies to date