1 / 28

Taxonomy and Knowledge Organization Taxonomy in Context

Taxonomy and Knowledge Organization Taxonomy in Context. Tom Reamy Chief Knowledge Architect KAPS Group Knowledge Architecture Professional Services http://www.kapsgroup.com. Agenda. Introduction: Time for Taxonomies Taxonomy Types: Strengths and Weaknesses Formal and Browse

gayora
Download Presentation

Taxonomy and Knowledge Organization Taxonomy in Context

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Taxonomy and Knowledge OrganizationTaxonomy in Context Tom ReamyChief Knowledge Architect KAPS Group Knowledge Architecture Professional Services http://www.kapsgroup.com

  2. Agenda • Introduction: Time for Taxonomies • Taxonomy Types: Strengths and Weaknesses • Formal and Browse • Taxonomy in the Organization: Intellectual Infrastructure • Content, People, Activities • Taxonomy Tips and Techniques • Development Stages • Issues and Ideas • Future Directions • Building on the Intellectual Infrastructure

  3. KAPS Group • Knowledge Architecture Professional Services (KAPS) • Consulting, strategy recommendations • Knowledge architecture audits • Partners – Convera and others • First Convera Certified Taxonomy Developers • Taxonomies: Enterprise, Marketing, Insurance, etc. • Taxonomy customization • Intellectual infrastructure for organizations • Knowledge organization, technology, people and processes • Search, content management, portals, collaboration, knowledge management, e-learning, etc.

  4. Time for Taxonomies • Taxonomy Time: Technology is not delivering • Professionals spend more time looking for information than using it • 50% of them spend > 2 hours a day looking • Search not enough – text strings vs. concepts • Relevance isn’t very relevant • Data mining misses 80% of significant content • Text mining needs more structure (taxonomies) • Surveys • 76% say taxonomies are important • 90% plan on a taxonomy strategy in 24 months

  5. Time for Taxonomies: Word of Caution • Taxonomy is not the answer • Is this a taxonomy? • Inventories, catalogs, classifications, categorization schemas, thesauri, controlled vocabularies • Taxonomy not enough – need other structures • Metadata, facets • Taxonomies have to be used to be useful • How to fail: • Taxonomy as a project • Taxonomy as a search engine project afterthought

  6. Two Types of Taxonomies: Browse and FormalBrowse Taxonomy– Yahoo

  7. Browse Taxonomies: Strengths and Weaknesses • Strengths: Browse is better than search • Context and discovery • Browse by task, type, etc. • Weaknesses: • Mix of organization • Catalogs, alphabetical listings, inventories • Subject matter, functional, publisher, document type • Vocabulary and nomenclature Issues • Problems with maintenance, new material • Poor granularity and little relationship between parts. • Web site unit of organization • No foundation for standards

  8. Formal Taxonomies: Strengths and Weaknesses • Strengths: • Fixed Resource – little or no maintenance • Communication Platform – share ideas, standards • Infrastructure Resource • Controlled vocabulary and keywords • More depth, finer granularity • Weaknesses: • Difficult to develop and customize • Don’t reflect users’ perspectives • Users have to adapt to language

  9. Dynamic Classification: Best of Both Worlds • Search and browse better than either alone • Categorized search – context • Browse as an advanced search • Dynamic search and browse is best • Can’t predict all the ways people think • Advanced cognitive differences • Panda, Monkey, Banana • Can’t predict all the questions and activities • Intersections of what users are looking for and what documents are often about • China and Biotech • Economics and Regulatory • Facet Taxonomies • Actors, events, functions, geography

  10. Taxonomy in Context: Intellectual Infrastructure • 3 infrastructures: technology, organizational, intellectual • Technology – systems and applications, servers and desktops, programmers and help desks, etc. • Organizational – business units and project groups, policies and procedures, administrators and facilitators • Intellectual – Information and knowledge, vocabularies and applications, authors and editors and librarians • Taxonomy at the nexus of the three infrastructures • Taxonomy enables communication among people, content, and technology

  11. Taxonomy in the Organization:Project Approach or Infrastructure Approach • Situation: Problem with access to information • Project Approach • Publish everything on the intranet • Buy a search engine • Do some keyword and usability tests • Buy a portal (or two) • Buy content management software • Try knowledge organization – taxonomy? • Infrastructure Approach • “The path up and down is one and the same.” (Heraclitus)

  12. Taxonomy in the Organization:Why an Infrastructure Approach? • Immanuel Kant • “Concepts without percepts are empty.” • “Percepts without concepts are blind.” • Knowledge Management (KM) / Information Projects • KM without applications is empty • Strategy only, management fad • Elegant taxonomies – unused • Applications without knowledge architecture (KA) are blind • IT based KM • Fragmented applications

  13. Taxonomy in the Organization: Structuring Content • All kinds of content • Structured and unstructured, Internet and desktop • Metadata standards – Dublin core+ • Keywords - poor performance • Need controlled vocabulary, taxonomies, semantic network • Document Type • Form, policy, how-to, etc. • Dynamic classification with subject matter taxonomies • Audience • Role, function, expertise, information behaviors • Consistent across subject matter and people • Best bets metadata

  14. Taxonomy in the Organization:Structuring People • Individual People • Tacit knowledge, information behaviors • Advanced personalization – category priority • Sales – forms ---- New Account Form • Accountant ---- New Accounts ---- Forms • Communities • Variety of types – map of formal and informal • Variety of subject matter – vaccines, research, scuba • Variety of communication channels and information behaviors • Community-specific vocabularies, need for inter-community communication (Cortical organization model)

  15. Taxonomy in the Organization:Structuring Processes and Technology • Technology: infrastructure and applications • Enterprise platforms: from creation to retrieval to application • Taxonomy as the computer network • Applications – integrated meaning, not just data • Creation – content management, innovation, communities of practice (CoPs) • When, who, how, and how much structure to add • Workflow with meaning, distributed subject matter experts (SMEs) and centralized teams • Retrieval – standalone and embedded in applications and business processes • Portals, collaboration, text mining, business intelligence, CRM

  16. Taxonomy in the Organization:The Integrating Infrastructure • Starting point: knowledge architecture audit, K-Map • Social network analysis, information behaviors • People – knowledge architecture team • Infrastructure activities – taxonomies, analytics, best bets • Facilitation – knowledge transfer, partner with SMEs • “Taxonomies” of content, people, and activities • Dynamic Dimension – complexity not chaos • Analytics based on concepts, information behaviors • Taxonomy is theanswer • In an Infrastructure Context

  17. Taxonomy Development: Tips and TechniquesStage One – How to Begin • Step One: Strategic Questions – why, what value from the taxonomy, how are you going to use it • Variety of taxonomies – important to know the differences, when to use what. • Step Two: Get a good taxonomist! (or learn) • Library Science+ Cognitive Science + Cognitive Anthropology • Step Three: Software Shopping • Automatic Software – Fun Diversion for a rainy day • Uneven hierarchy, strange node names, weird clusters • Taxonomy Management, Entity Extraction, Visualization • Step Four: Get a good taxonomy! • Glossary, Index, Pull from multiple sources • Get a good document collection

  18. Taxonomy Development: Tips and TechniquesStage Two: Development and/or Customization • Combination of top down and bottom up (and Essences) • Top: Design an ontology, facet selection • Bottom: Vocabulary extraction – documents, search logs, interview authors and users • Develop essential examples (Prototypes) • Most Intuitive Level – genus (oak, maple, rabbit) • Quintessential Chair – all the essential characteristics, no more • Work toward the prototype and out and up and down • Repeat until dizzy or done

  19. Taxonomy Development: Tips and TechniquesStage Three: Evaluate and Refine • Formal Evaluation • Quality of corpus – size, homogeneity, representative • Breadth of coverage – main ideas, outlier ideas (see next) • Structure – balance of depth and width • Kill the verbs • Evaluate speciation steps – understandable and systematic • Person – Unwelcome person – Unpleasant person - Selfish person • Avoid binary levels, duplication of contrasts • Primary and secondary education, public and private

  20. Taxonomy Development: Tips and TechniquesStage Three: Evaluate and Refine • Practical Evaluation • Test in real life application • Select representative users and documents • Test node labels with Subject Matter Experts • Balance of making sense and jargon • Test with representative key concepts • Test for un-representative strange little concepts that only mean something to a few people but the people and ideas are key and are normally impossible to find

  21. Taxonomy Development: Tips and TechniquesIssues and Ideas • Complex Topics – intersection of subject domains and facets • What documents are often about is the intersection • Example – China and Biotech • Standards and Customization • Balance of corporate communication and departmental specifics • At what level are differences represented? • Customize pre-defined taxonomy – additional structure, add synonyms and acronyms and vocabulary

  22. Taxonomy Development: Tips and TechniquesIssues and Ideas • Enterprise Taxonomy • No single subject matter taxonomy • Need an ontology of facets or domains • Enterprise Facet Model: • Actors, Events, Functions, Locations, Objects, Information Resources • Combine and map to subject domains

  23. Future Directions: Knowledge Organization • New analytic methods • Cognitive anthropology, history of ideas, ESNA • New metadata schemas • SCORM, RDF and semantic Web • Learning and knowledge objects • New people models • Bloom’s Taxonomy, Gardner’s 7 Intelligences • Advanced personalization • Community-based, cognitive-based • Adaptive, dynamic presentation variations

  24. Future Directions: Technology • Taxonomies within applications • Richer world knowledge and better learning • Entity extraction and fact extraction • Natural language processing (NLP) search – answers, not document lists • Integrated KM platform • Creation, structure, retrieval, application, measurement • Integrated KM/KA team • Contextualizing content: related content, best bets, expertise, communities

  25. Future Directions: Well-Articulated Organization • Learning takes place throughout the system • Smart applications – adapts to users’ and community’s activities • Just-in-time training and performance support • Combination of analytics and knowledge organization • Concept-level, not document-level • Taxonomy is the brain, analytics are the eyes • Self-knowledge – highest form of knowledge • “Unexamined life is not worth living.” (Plato) • Unexamined, inarticulate enterprise is not worth having

  26. Before you view: Agent keeps you up to date Your connections to content and communities, your preferences Your history and the history of other members of your communities When you add/change content Suggests categorization value, metadata values Routes to appropriate content and communities Prompt on unusual connections Pre-existing content Related content Regulatory issues Ask the question – route to experts? When you look for information Taxonomy-based dynamic browse Entities People, companies, wells Related content Regulatory, patents, BI-CI Geological data News stories Dictionaries, USGS data, databases Experts Ask questions, chat When you use information Communities Search, chat, email Performance aids, classes Stories The Contextual Desktop: Document, List of Documents, Applications Screen

  27. Sources • Books • Women, Fire, and Dangerous Things • What Categories Reveal about the Mind • Geroge Lakoff • The Geography of Thought • Richard E. Nisbett • Software • Convera Retrievalware • Inxight Smart Discovery – entity and fact extraction • Courses • Convera Taxonomy Certification

  28. Questions? Tom Reamytomr@kapsgroup.com KAPS Group Knowledge Architecture Professional Services http://www.kapsgroup.com

More Related