1 / 21

FDI, GOVERNMENT POLICY AND INDUSTRIAL TRANSFORMATION IN MALAYSIA

FDI, GOVERNMENT POLICY AND INDUSTRIAL TRANSFORMATION IN MALAYSIA. Rajah Rasiah UNU-INTECH. 1 INTRODUCTION. Analytic framework Initial structure Industrial policy FDI-driven manufactured exports Domestic manufactured exports Policy Implications. 2 FRAMEWORK.

kiril
Download Presentation

FDI, GOVERNMENT POLICY AND INDUSTRIAL TRANSFORMATION IN MALAYSIA

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. FDI, GOVERNMENT POLICY AND INDUSTRIAL TRANSFORMATION IN MALAYSIA Rajah Rasiah UNU-INTECH

  2. 1 INTRODUCTION • Analytic framework • Initial structure • Industrial policy • FDI-driven manufactured exports • Domestic manufactured exports • Policy Implications

  3. 2 FRAMEWORK • Cumulative dimension of technical change: Learning and Innovation from TNCs • indirectly through licensing, reverse engineering, adaptation and eventually innovation • directly through foreign direct investment • Industrial policy focus - FDI-Local firms • Sequential changes in policy emphasis over transition • Ethnic restructuring

  4. 3 INITIAL STRUCTURE • Primary sector specialization under British rule • Rubber and tin exports • Sector and regional poverty and inequality, and ethnic identification problems • Education and other basic infrastructure concentrated in West Malaysia and in urban centers • Ethnic polarization and inter-ethnic tensions (May 13 1969 bloodshed)

  5. 4 INDUSTRIAL POLICY • IS I - 1958- Application of import tariffs on final consumer goods without any other significant interventions • MIDA formed in 1964 • New Economic Policy of 1971-90 and New Development Policy of 1991- • Poverty Alleviation and Restructuring along ethnic lines basis of development • Manufacturing identified as engine of growth • EOI I - 1972-80 - FDI with focus on investment, export and employment • Opening of FTZs and LMWs from 1972 • ICA - 1975 - ownership regulations on inward-oriented investment • 1981-85 - Emphasis on IS 2 • Focus on domestic investment in Heavy and Process Industries • Steel, automobiles, cement, processed palm oil • 1986-90 Resumption of EO1 Strategy (IMP1) • Technological Deepening Efforts • APITD - 1990; HRDF - 1992; MTDC/MIGHT - 1993; IMP2 - 1996; MSC/MDC - 1997 • 1998-2002 - Strategic focus on sequencing relaxed

  6. 4 FDI-DRIVEN MANUFACTURED EXPORTS • Political stability, good basic infrastructure, literate reserve labour and strong government incentives and support attracted FDI • TNC-driven electronics exports • External market penetration, foreign exchange, employment • Creation of experiential and tacit knowledge and the evolution of differentiation and division of labour in Penang. Truncated operations in KL, Selangor, N Sembilan, Melaka and Johor restricted differentiation and division of labour.

  7. 4 FDI-DRIVEN MANUFACTURED EXPORTS • Transition from importing to adaptation and process R&D. • High-tech deepening efforts from 1990 – APITD, HRDF, MTDC, MIGHT, IMP2 and MSC failed to take non-resource product firms to the paths achieved by Korea and Taiwan. Lack of human capital strategies constrained movement of firms to use higher R&D activities. R&D-intensity of firms much lower than in Korea and Taiwan (ethnic restructuring hampered human capital supply). • Regional market customization in some firms

  8. 5 DOMESTIC-DRIVEN MANUFACTURED EXPORTS • Palm oil • Against advice from foreign experts, government introduced subsidies and promoted PPO from CPO. • World’s largest exporter of PPO and firms operate at the technology frontier • Expansion into kernel oil • Extensive focus on diversification into oleo-chemicals • Model for other countries • Automobiles • Heavy reliance on foreign technology • Domestic technology especially since acquisition of Lotus. • Protection and domestic rents still prime source of profits • Bilateral trading arrangement prime focus of exports • Facing constraints of liberalization from TRIMs and AFTA process.

  9. 6 POLICY IMPLICATIONS • Successful FDI inflows and expansion in especially FDI-driven electronics, and domestic driven PPO. • Strategic FDI-targeting policy • Cumulative dimension of learning and innovation; FDI’s direct and indirect role in the processes • Dynamics of industrial policy: Initial structure and specific strategies tied to development policy objectives and options available - small domestic market drove FDI toward reliance on external markets; Export diversification to ensure sustainable financing of infrastructure build up.

  10. 6 POLICY IMPLICATIONS • Economic restructuring policies avoided collision with FDI strategies (except for 1980-85) and hence continued to keep strong FDI presence. • Weak human capital development policy constrained transition to R&D activities in non-resource based firms – partly constrained by ethnic restructuring policies. • While the ICA favourably exempted FDI, it constrained both direct support of independent non-Malay firms as well as the supply of human capital.

  11. SELECTED RELATED AUTHOR’S PAPERS • 1994 “Flexible Production Systems and Local Machine Tool Subcontracting: Electronics Component Transnationals", Cambridge Journal of Economics, 18(3): 79-98. • 1995 Foreign Capital and Industrialization in Malaysia, Basingstoke: Macmillan. • 1996 “Institutions and Innovations: Moving Towards the Technology Frontier in the Electronics Industry in Malaysia”, Journal ofIndustry Studies, 3(2): 79-102. • 1996 "Manufacturing as Engine of Growth and Industrialization in Malaysia", Managerial Finance, 22(6). • 1996 "Changing Organisation of Work in Malaysia's Electronics Industry", Asia Pacific Viewpoint, 37(1).

  12. SELECTED RELATED AUTHOR’S PAPERS • 1997, "Class. Ethnicity and Economic Development in Malaysia", Rodan G, Robison R. and Hewisen, K. (eds), Political Economy of Southeast Asia, Sydney: Oxford University Press . • 1999 "Malaysia's National Innovation System", Jomo K.S. and Felker G. (eds), Technology, Competitiveness and the State, London: Routledge. • 1999 (edited with Jomo K.S and Greg Felker). (eds), Industrial Technology Development in Malaysia: Firm and Industry Studies, London: Routledge • 2000 (with Osman R.H. and Rokiah Alavi) “Changing Dimensions of Malaysian Trade”, International Journal ofBusiness and Society, 1(1): 1-35. • 2001 “Labour and Work Organisation in Malaysia’s Proton”, Hutchison J. and Brown A. (eds), Organising Labour in Globalising Asia, London: Routledge.

  13. SELECTED RELATED AUTHOR’S PAPERS • 2001 (with Anita Doraisamy) “Incentives and Industrialisation in Malaysia, Jomo K.S. (ed), Southeast Asia and Industrialization, Basingstoke: Pelgrave. • 2001 “Southeast Asia’s Ersatz Miracle” Jomo K.S. (eds), Southeast Asia and Industrialization, Basingstoke: Pelgrave. • 2001 “Politics, Institutions and Flexibility: Microelectronics Transnationals and Machine Tool Linkages in Malaysia”, Deyo F.C, R.F. Doner and Hershberg E. (eds), Economic Governance and the Challenge of Flexibility in East Asia, Boston: Little and Rowland. • 2001 (with Ishak Shari) “Market, Government and Malaysia’s New Economic Policy”,Cambridge Journal of Economics, 25(1): 57-78. • 2002 “Government-Business Coordination and Small Enterprise Performance in the Machine Tools Sector in Malaysia”, Small Business Economics, 18(1-3): 177-195.

  14. SELECTED RELATED AUTHOR’S PAPERS • 2002 “Systemic Coordination and the Knowledge Economy: Human Capital Development in Malaysia’s MNC-driven Electronics Clusters”, Transnational Corporations, 11(3): 89-132. • 2003 “Industrial Technology Transition in Malaysia” Sanjaya Lall and Shujiro Urata (eds), Technology Development in East Asia, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. • 2003 (with Michael Best) Malaysian Electronics at the Crossroads, Technical working paper, Vienna: UNIDO. • 2004 Foreign Firms, Technological Capabilities and Economic Performance: Evidence from Africa, Asia and Latin America, London: Edward Elgar.

More Related