1 / 15

Exploring Electrical Technology

Exploring Electrical Technology. The Electrifying Future From Chapter 8 of Nye’s Electrifying America. Nye’s Purpose. Suggests the sense Americans have had as a culture about our own history and specifically how electrification both fit and fashioned its views of the future

zivanka
Download Presentation

Exploring Electrical Technology

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Exploring Electrical Technology The Electrifying Future From Chapter 8 of Nye’s Electrifying America

  2. Nye’s Purpose • Suggests the sense Americans have had as a culture about our own history and specifically how electrification both fit and fashioned its views of the future • Assertion: “Americans have long tended to see the present as only a faint outline of the future…”

  3. Culture Sources of Optimism • Religious: Christian Eschatology • Economic: Capitalism • Psychological: frontier tradition epitomized in the phrase “building tomorrow out of a crude present”

  4. Culture Sources of Optimism • Scientific: theory of evolution “survival of the fitest” • Philosophical: utopian expectations-continued rise in material standards of living by virtue of technology

  5. Reasons for Utopian Hopes • Newness of the technology (still in 1930s) • Speed & scope of electrification in America (excluding rural areas) • Apparent progress even during the Depression

  6. Dysutopian Sources of Pessimism • National Electrical Light Association (NELA) hearing (1928-1934) • Controversy: exposed bad faith practices on the part of this interest group supporting private (vs. public) utilities preferentially and covertly • Result: hearing lasted 6 years and it politicized the electrification process

  7. Dysutopian Sources of Pessimism • “Chains of Lightning” • A popular novel by Mellet • Highlighted the unpopularity of utility presidents at the time • Trial of Insull • Former president of Chicago-based utility empire that collapsed during the Depression • Fled first successfully from arrest, later arrained and acquitted, but not in the public eye

  8. Dysutopian Sources of Pessimism • “Brave New World” • Science fiction novel by Huxley • Depicts a future society organized according to industrial principles including human reproduction

  9. Political Factor: Technocracy Movement • Origins • Created at Columbia U. School of Engineering • Advocated by Howard Scott & Walter Rautenstauch • Held an “energy theory of value” • Reasoned that it was the “sole scientific foundation for the monetary system…” • Wanted to give “energy certificates” to each citizen based on the total amount of power available for production • Result: groups emerged in CA, Denver, Chicago

  10. Technocracy View • Automation would continue to • Eliminate more jobs • Create an imbalance between production & consumption • Necessitate a correction to the capitalistic “price” system that only they could do

  11. Technocracy’s Demise? • Its leading proponent (Howard Scott) • Temperamental & overstated his academic credentials • Developed no political action plan • Without a strong leader, the movement fragmented • Ideas shared & carried on by many other intellectuals • Technology is not under proper control • Split existed between American culture & industrial civilization • Imbalances were arising between man & nature; production & consumption

  12. Fashionable Trends • Distinguish between Civilization & Culture • Civilization  technology, scientific achievement, institutions & organizations, power & material or financial success • Culture  traditions & values that pre-existed the modern world

  13. Fashionable Trends • Photography • “View of Morgantown” shows cross-bars of utility pole that cut across the harmony of the town & superimpose it on a technological grid • “Lines man at work” by Dorothy Lange shows two men precariously balanced on cross poles apparently impervious to nature

  14. Fashionable Trends in Artwork • “Light of the World” by Peter Blume (1932) • Nye’s description: • presents an enormous electric light that dominates the center of the canvass • Stands on a pedestal before the door of a house • 4 persons gaze at the light with expressions of awe • A Gothic Church looms in the background • Nye’s interpretation: Christ is not the light of this world; rather science and engineering have replaced religion as people turn their backs to the church & stare at the light

  15. Conclusion • If “Light of the World” suggests a split between culture & civilization or a growing ambivalence to technological change due to blanket acceptance of electrification and technology itself, it may be the basis for many Christians to take an Anti-technology position. Other Christians who disagree take a Pro- or “Responsible” position.

More Related