310 likes | 633 Views
Character/Personality Types/Disorder . Descriptions from ancient world eg body fluids and humourBody typePsychodynamic theoriesTrait theorySocial learning theory. . Current descriptions of Personality Disorder are not particularly helpful in planning clinical interventionsCircular causality Legal vs clinical descriptionsOverlap between disorders/clusters.
E N D
1. REFLECTIONS ON THE MANAGEMENT OF PERSONALITY DISORDER IN SECURE SETTINGS G Krishnan
Rampton Hospital
3. Current descriptions of Personality Disorder are not particularly helpful in planning clinical interventions
Circular causality
Legal vs clinical descriptions
Overlap between disorders/clusters
7. Treatability Who
When
By whom
8. Epidemiology - Community Surveys Personality Disorder
Antisocial
Borderline
Narcissistic
Histrionic
Paranoid
Schizoid
Schizotypal
Avoidant
Dependent
Compulsive
Any
%
2.0 - 3.0
1.7.-2.0
0.4
2.1
2.0
0.4-0.9
0.6-5.6
1.1-1.3
1.6-1.7
1.7-2.2
5.9-13.0
Reich & De Girolamo (1997) & Moran (1999)
9. Epidemiology - Prison Antisocial Personality Disorder
Male Remand - 63%
Male Sentenced - 49%
Female - 31%
Singleton et al (1998)
10. Epidemiology - Special Hospitals Borderline Personality Commonest Amongst Men And Women (55% & 91%)
Higher Prevalence Of Narcissistic PD
Higher Prevalence Of Hares Psychopathy
Sex Offenders, Arsonists Over Represented
Highly Selected Population
Coid (1992)
11. Comorbidity Dolan et al (1995) - Severity of Disorder ? Multiplicity Of Diagnosis
Hogue et al (1998) - Prevalence Of Axis I Pathology
Coid et al (1999) - Significant Axis I & II Comorbidity
- ASPD/BPD - Comorbid Substance Misuse in 60%
Sainsbury (in progress) - Range Of Psychopathy
13. Common Themes In PD Deprivation, Abuse, Family Breakdown
Lack Of Experience Of Success
Self Esteem
Emotional Under/Over Control
Maladaptive Coping
Interpersonal Relationship Difficulties
15. Treatment: What
When
By Whom
16. Treatment Models Attachment
Interpersonal
Trauma
Disability
Emotional Regulation
Cognitive Schema
17. Evidence Base Norton et al - Therapeutic Communities
Linehan -Dialectical Behaviour Therapy
Bateman, Fonagy - Pschoanlytically based partial hospitalisation in Borderline PD
Gendreau,, - Cognitive Behavioural, Offence Andrews Related Relapse Prevention Progs
18. Rampton ProgrammePD Service Development 42 Beds - 2 Consultants
Patients - All Male
Multidisciplinary Team
Incremental Development -
Assessment, Rehabilitation Wards
Added In A Staged Way
19. Comprehensive MultidisciplinaryAssessment Biopsychosocial, Includes Risk/Offending
ICD/DSM Diagnosis
Dynamic Formulation Psychometrics/Psychological Testing
Single Case Recording, Treatment Plan
20. Treatment Package Eclectic But Primarily Cognitive Behavioural
Individual - Nursing, Psychology
Group Work - Nursing, Psychology, Social Work, OT, Medics
Medication Management
Role Of Key Worker/Primary Therapist
21. Groups Community Meetings
Introductory, Motivation
Core Groups e.g. Thinking Skills, DBT
Specific Groups e.g. SOTP, VOTP
Range Of Educational,Vocational, ADL, Leisure
Maintenance, Relapse Prevention
22. Case Example - 1 24 year old white male
Mother of borderline/low IQ, promiscuous
Pakistani stepfather, several relationships with vulnerable women
Several step siblings
Extreme abuse
Education, vocation, relationships - disastrous
25. Case Example - 2 61 year old caucasian male
Mother died early, father remarried
Father - harsh discipline
Stepmother - detached, mocking
School - unremarkable
Difficulty sustaining relationship, number of acquaintances, no friends
Married - interest in teenage stepdaughter
28. Readiness For Treatment ? Treatability
DBT Hierarchy
Stages Of Change
29. Culture Multidisciplinary
Managing Defensive Reactions
Structure & Flexibility
Staff Support, Supervision
Communication
30. Does It Work Problems Of Research
Recidivism And/Or Institutional Behaviour
Measuring Change
- Pre/Post Intervention
- Individual Monitoring
Anecdotal Evidence Of Change
31. The Future Uncertainty But Guarded Optimism
Gradual Emergence Of Knowledge Base
Resources To Translate Knowledge Into Clinical Practice
Flexible Movement Between Health & Penal Settings
?? DSPD