280 likes | 669 Views
Civil Liberties. The Bill of Rights. Introduction. Civil liberties: negative restraints on government freedom v. order freedom of speech, press, religion Civil rights: what government must do rights guaranteed to individuals freedom v. equality. Civil liberties.
E N D
Civil Liberties The Bill of Rights
Introduction • Civil liberties: negative restraints on government • freedom v. order • freedom of speech, press, religion • Civil rights: what government must do • rights guaranteed to individuals • freedom v. equality
Civil liberties • most people agree that liberties can be restrained • issue becomes who puts limits on our liberties and how many limits are acceptable • how much freedom are YOU willing to give up?
Should government restrain... • a communist from teaching in college? in high school? • the distribution of a pamphlet to overthrow the government? • a KKK organization on campus? • Detention of “enemy combatants”?
how about... • burning the American flag? • prayer in schools? • Random security searches at airports? • yelling “fire” in the theater during the opening day of Harry Potter?
Freedom to believe what we want is absolute; freedom to act on those beliefs must be reconciled with social order • sand castles
Case write-ups • What issues involved in cases you researched?
Influences on civil liberties and rights • new social experiences or events (treason laws during times of war) • composition of the Supreme Court • change in public perspectives
Why is the 14th amendment important? • vehicle by which the Supreme Court has incorporated the Bill of Rights to state actions • incorporation has been by one phrase at a time • due process and equal protection clause
Palko v. CT (1937) • reinforced “selective incorporation” • Honor roll of rights: fundamental rights • today, most of the Bill of Rights applies to state actions
First amendment rights • Freedom of religion • Freedom of speech and of the press • Freedom of assembly
Freedom of speech and of the press • not absolute, but marketplace of ideas • advocacy of ideas must be linked to lawless action
Types of restrictions • inciteful speech • slander and libel • obscenity • prior restraint
Inciteful speech • Sandcastle: bad tendency to “clear and present danger” to direct incitement
Slander and libel • slander: untrue spoken statement that defames a person’s character • libel: (written) • requires proof of actual malice for public figure
Obscenity • work lacks any serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value • “reasonable person”/local standards
Prior Restraint • censorship: prohibiting something from being published
Freedom of religion • “wall of separation” between church and state • at the core of our personal being
The establishment clause prohibits • government sponsorship of religion • government financial support of religion • government’s active involvement in religious activity
Lemon v. Kurtzman (1971) • 1. secular purpose? • 2. neither inhibits nor advances religion? • 3. Avoids excessive entanglement in religion?
Free exercise clause • ability to practice religion freely • freedom v. order tensions
Due process and criminal justice • 4th, 5th, 6th and 8th amendments
Fourth amendment • unreasonable searches and seizures • without a warrant, police can search • person arrested • things in plain view of the accused • places/things in the person’s immediate control • anything if given permission
Mapp v. Ohio (1961) • exclusionary rule applied to states • prohibits use of improperly seized evidence at a trial
Fifth amendment • protection from self-incrimination • Miranda v. Arizona (1966) • Miranda rights
Sixth amendment • right to counsel • Gideon v. Wainwright (1963) • applied 6th amendment to state felony cases
Eighth amendment • cruel and unusual punishment • death penalty • Sandcastle: DNA tests; racial or income levels
Food for thought... • should we be concerned about the uneven use of the death penalty among states?