120 likes | 225 Views
Civil Liberties. Chapter 4: Protecting Individual Liberties. Freedom of Expression. The right of an individual to hold and communicate views of their choosing. EXCEPT: Endangers national security Wrongly damages the rep of others Deprives others of basic freedom. Schenck v. U.S. (1919).
E N D
Civil Liberties Chapter 4: Protecting Individual Liberties
Freedom of Expression • The right of an individual to hold and communicate views of their choosing. • EXCEPT: • Endangers national security • Wrongly damages the rep of others • Deprives others of basic freedom.
Schenck v. U.S. (1919) • 1917 Espionage Act Upheld. Schenck could not distribute antiwar leaflets. • Congress can restrict speech that was “of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger” to the nation’s security.
Does the government allow this? • Can you burn an American flag? • Can I fly the stars and bars? • Can the KKK march in public? • Content-neutral restrictions: Time, manner, place.
Imminent Lawless Action • When words cause others to engage in lawless action. • Before government can lawfully prevent a speech or rally, it must demonstrate that the event will cause harm and also must demonstrate the lack of alternative ways to prevent the harm from happening.
Libel and Slander • Libel: False info that greatly harms a person’s reputation is published. • Slander: If it is spoken
Obscenity • Roth v. United States (1957) • “Taken as a whole…” is there any “redeeming social value?” • This was to be judged by “the average person, applying contemporary community standards.” • Who is the “average person?” • What community? • Public v. Private
Religion • Establishment Clause: • Government may not favor one religion over another or support religion over no religion. • Engel v. Vitale (1962): Banned prayer in public schools. • Prayer at football games? • Ten commandments at Courthouse? • Statue installed half-century earlier • Paid by nonreligious group
Free-exercise clause • Americans are free to believe what they want. However, are not always free to act on their beliefs. • Child with life-threatening illness? Parent’s beliefs are to refuse medical attention.
Abortion • Roe v Wade (1973): gave women full freedom to choose abortion during the first three months of pregnancy. • Prohibit the use of government funds for abortion? • Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992): principle upheld that women have right to abortion. • State can impose regulations that do not place an “undue burden” on women seeking an abortion.
Surveillance of Suspected Terrorists • U.S. Patriot Act: • Wiretapping • Information from intelligence surveillance could be shared with criminal investigators; even without suspected terrorist connections. • Increased authority to examine medical, financial, and student records. • In specific situations, could secretly search homes and offices. • War-time Powers? Tapping phone lines for international calls?