190 likes | 318 Views
The European Union: An Introduction The Eurosceptic perspective <<Your Name>>. The EU today : 27 members, 501m citizens -The most recent members (Romania and Bulgaria) joined in January 2007. The EU – what’s the point?. Provide lasting peace and security
E N D
The European Union:An IntroductionThe Eurosceptic perspective<<Your Name>>
The EU today: 27 members, 501m citizens-The most recent members (Romania and Bulgaria) joined in January 2007
The EU – what’s the point? • Provide lasting peace and security • Build economic strength and development through a common market • Restore European influence in the wider world • Create ‘an ever closer union between the peoples of Europe’ ?
How does the EU work? European Council -Heads of State or Government from Member States -Meets twice every six months, to set EU ‘agenda’ European Commission -Appointed bureaucracy, headed by 27 Commissioners -Manages EU budget and common policies -Monopoly on proposing law Co-decision Council of the EU -Ministers from Member States -Votes, largely by QMV, to accept/reject Amendments European Parliament (EP) -736 directly elected members (MEPs) -Cannot propose legislation only Accept, reject or propose Amendments European Court of Justice (ECJ) -Oversees implementation of law
Law-making – The Ordinary Legislative Procedure • Commission proposes law • EP and Council debate and vote on adopting law (co-decision) • If adopted, Member States are obliged to implement law (through comitology) • ECJ can act against, and fine, Member States if they do not implement the law properly “The EU’s ways are complicated to the point of incomprehensibility” -Dr Helen Szamuely, Bruges Group
EU ‘competences’ • The European Commission has sole power to propose new EU laws. It is responsible for UK policy on: • Trade (e.g. WTO), commerce and industry • Social and labour issues • Agriculture (CAP), fishing (CFP) and the environment • Overseas development aid • Between 60 and 80% of our laws now originate in an unelected bureaucracy in Brussels!
EU policies: CAP • Under CAP, EU farmers are paid a Single Farm Payment (SFP) on top of what they receive from selling produce. • CAP also sets quotas on what farmers produce, to ensure higher prices, and imposes tariffs (tax) on agricultural imports. • CAP takes up 41% of the annual EU budget and costs the UK c.£10.3bn p.a. • “The way to build lasting economic growth in Africa…is for Europe to end the CAP.” -Sir Digby Jones, Former Chairman CBI
EU directives and regulation • EU legislation cost UK business £88.3bn between January 1998 and July 2010. • Some examples: • Working Time Directive • Services Directive • Child car seats for under-12s below 4’5”. • Permanent headlights
The €uro • The euro was launched in 1999. Notes and coins were introduced in 2002. • There are 17 Member States in the Eurozone. • It was intended to make it easier to do business across the EU. • ‘One size fits all’ interest rate in the Eurozone is fitting no-one. • 2010 Eurozone crisis - €273bn has been spent so far bailing out Greece, Ireland and Portugal. • Why risk entry?
The EU Constitution • The EU drafted a Constitutional Treaty in 2002, which was signed by representatives of the member states in 2004. • The Constitutional Treaty was supposed to combine existing Treaties to clarify what the EU’s responsibilities were. • But it actually increased the power of the EU: • National vetoes on 63 issues lost (to QMV) • Created an EU President and Foreign Minister • EU given ‘legal personality’ • No limits set on extension of EU power • It included things such as an EU ‘national’ anthem and the EU flag, yet ignored key issues such as reforming the CAP and liberalising Member State economies
The “reformed” EU Constitution • France and the Netherlands both rejected the EU Constitution in referendums in June 2005. • The response of the Constitution’s author : “Let’s be clear about this. The rejection of the Constitution was a mistake that will have to be corrected.” - Valery Giscard d’Estaing • The Constitutional project was resurrected under the guise of the Lisbon Treaty • It replaced the Constitution (but 96% of its content was the same as the Constitutional Treaty)
The Lisbon Treaty ‘We are united in our aim of placing the EU on a renewed common basis before EP elections in 2009’ - Berlin Declaration, March 2007 • The Lisbon Treaty was signed in December 2007. • However, Ireland rejected it in a referendum in June 2008 • Following controversial negotiations, Ireland voted ‘Yes’ in a second vote in October 2009. • The euro-sceptic Czech Republic President, Vaclav Klaus, campaigned against the Treaty, but eventually signed it. • The Treaty came into force in December 2009
Enlargement • On 1 May 2004, 10 new countries, mainly in Central and Eastern Europe, joined the EU. • Romania and Bulgaria joined in January 2007. • Yet the structure of the EU was built for 6, not 27, Member States. It needs reforming. • Average GDP per head in the 10 Member States that joined in 2004 was just 52.9% of the EU-15. • The ‘Copenhagen Criteria’ has been too loosely applied and was not met by Romania and Bulgaria prior to accession. Turkey is even further off. • Enlargement has raised many issues regarding immigration to the UK, the response to which has been chaotic.
What do the public think? • In 2010 only 29% of British people considered membership of the EU to be ‘a good thing’ • Just 49% of the entire population of the EU had the same response to the question. • By a margin of 60% to 30%, chief executives support moves to radically reduce the powers of the EU to a basic free trade area. QA7. Generally speaking, do you think that [your country’s] membership of the EU is…? Ans: A good thing. – Eurobarometer 2010
i. Why is the EU so unpopular? • Complex, undemocratic, and distant from its citizens. • Unaccountable and corrupt – the Court of Auditors has refused to sign off EU accounts for the last 16 years! "The creeping unification of Europe ... [has been] managed by the bureaucrats from Brussels behind the back of the citizens of individual member states." -Vaclav Klaus, Czech President
ii. Why is the EU so unpopular? • The trade rules of the EU disadvantage lesser developed countries around the world. • The EU has serious economic problems: high unemployment, low growth and a growing government pensions debt, not to mention the ongoing Eurozone crisis. • It is hamstrung by regulation and protectionism. • “There is a view that the more regulation you have, the more Europe you have." • -Gunter Verheugen, EU Commission Vice-President
Better off out? • The EU is expensive, costing each UK taxpayer approximately £300 last year. • The EU should stop the tide of regulation and focus on where it can make real changes: free trade and CAP reform. • The EU must return Member States’ power to revoke legislation. “The EU is making us poorer, less democratic and less free.” – Daniel Hannan MEP “Europe should do less, but do it better!” – Jacques Delors, 1992