E N D
1. Pleural Effusions Rob Mac Sweeney
Ulster Hospital
Intensive Care Training
June 22nd 2007
2. Aims Basics
Diagnosis
Presence of Effusion
Type of Effusion
How to Manage an Effusion
What the Various Tests Mean
Issues
3. Basics What is it?
4. Basics What is it?
Excess fluid in the
Pleural Space
5. Basics What sort of fluid?
6. Basics What sort of fluid?
Plasma - Effusion
7. Basics What sort of fluid?
Plasma - Effusion
Pus - Empyema
8. Basics What sort of fluid?
Plasma - Effusion
Pus - Empyema
Blood - Haemothorax
9. Basics What sort of fluid?
Plasma - Effusion
Pus - Empyema
Blood - Haemothorax
Lymph - Chylothorax
10. Basics What sort of fluid?
Plasma - Effusion
Pus - Empyema
Blood - Haemothorax
Lymph - Chylothorax
11. Basics What sort of fluid?
Plasma - Effusion
Pus - Empyema
Blood - Haemothorax
Lymph - Chylothorax
Cholesterol - Pseudochylothorax
12. Basics What sort of fluid?
Plasma - Effusion
Pus - Empyema
Blood - Haemothorax
Lymph - Chylothorax
Cholesterol - Pseudochylothorax
Urine - Urinothorax
13. Basics What sort of fluid is it usually?
14. Basics What sort of fluid is it usually?
Filtered Plasma
15. Basics How do we Classify Effusions?
16. Basics How do we Classify Effusions?
Transudate (<30g/L)
17. Basics How do we Classify Effusions?
Transudate (<30g/L)
Exudate (>30g/L)
18. Basics How is it Generated?
19. Basics How is it Generated?
Transudate: Altered Starlings Law
20. Basics How is it Generated?
Transudate: Altered Starlings Law
Exudate: Increased Permeability
21. Diagnosis How is the presence of
an effusion diagnosed?
22. Diagnosis How is the presence of
an effusion diagnosed?
Clinically
23. Diagnosis How is the presence of
an effusion diagnosed?
Clinically
Radiologically
24. Clinically
History
25. Clinically Clinical Diagnosis
History
PE:
Inspection
Palpation
Percussion
Auscultation
26. Radiology Imaging Diagnosis
CXR
Ultrasound
CT
MRI
PET
Pulmonary Angiogram
27. Radiology CXR
Supine Film: Haze
28. Radiology CXR
Supine Film: Haze
Erect Film: Meniscus
29. Radiology CXR
Supine Film: Haze
Erect Film: Meniscus
Volume Required:
Decubitus: 20mls
30. Radiology CXR
Supine Film: Haze
Erect Film: Meniscus
Volume Required:
Decubitus: 20mls
Lateral: 50mls
31. Radiology CXR
Supine Film: Haze
Erect Film: Meniscus
Volume Required:
Decubitus: 20mls
Lateral: 50mls
PA: 175mls
32. Radiology CXR
Supine Film: Haze
Erect Film: Meniscus
Volume Required:
Decubitus: 20mls
Lateral: 50mls
PA: 175mls
Supine: 175mls
33. Radiology CXR
Supine Film: Haze
Erect Film: Meniscus
Volume Required:
Decubitus: 20mls
Lateral: 50mls
PA: 175mls
Supine: 175mls
AP 500mls
34. Radiology CXR
Blackmore CC, Black WC, Dallas RV, Crow
Pleural fluid volume estimation: a chest radiograph prediction rule.
Acad Radiol. 1996 Feb;3(2):103-9.
500mls to obscure the hemidiaphragm500mls to obscure the hemidiaphragm
35. Radiology CXR
Blackmore CC, Black WC, Dallas RV, Crow
Pleural fluid volume estimation: a chest radiograph prediction rule.
Acad Radiol. 1996 Feb;3(2):103-9.
Lateral: 50mls
PA: 200mls
500mls
500mls to obscure the hemidiaphragm500mls to obscure the hemidiaphragm
36. Radiology Ultrasound
Confirm Presence
Estimate Size
Identify Septa
Identify Fluid
Other Pathology
Guide Drainage
37. Radiology Ultrasound
Confirm Presence
Estimate Size
Identify Septa
Identify Fluid
Other Pathology
Guide Drainage
38. Radiology Ultrasound
Confirm Presence
Estimate Size
Identify Septa
Identify Fluid
Other Pathology
Guide Drainage
39. Radiology CT
Confirm Presence
Estimate Size
Identify Septa
Identify Fluid
Other Pathology
Guide Drainage
40. Radiology CT
Confirm Presence
Estimate Size
Identify Septa
Identify Fluid
Other Pathology
Guide Drainage
41. Radiology CT
Confirm Presence
Estimate Size
Identify Septa
Identify Fluid
Other Pathology
Guide Drainage
42. Radiology MRI
As US and CT
Ix Pleural Disease
43. Radiology PET
Management NSC LC
Fluorodeoxyglucose
(FDG)
Technetium-99m methylene diphosphonate (MDP)
44. Causes
45. Causes
46. Causes
47. Suggested Approach for ICU
48. Suggested Approach for ICU
49. Suggested Approach for ICU
50. Suggested Approach for ICU
51. Suggested Approach for ICU
52. Suggested Approach for ICU
53. My Big Question
54. My Big Question Does thoracocentesis improve physiology?
55. Effects of Thoracocentesis Improve Oxygenation
Neff, T. A., and B. D. Buchanan.
Tension pleural effusion.
Am. Rev. Respir. Dis. 1975;111:543–548.
Brown, N. E., N. Zamel, and A. Aberman.
Changes in pulmonary mechanics and gas exchange
Following thoracocentesis.
Chest 1978;74:540–542.
Perpińá, M., E. Benlloch, V. Marco, F. Abad, and D.
Nauffal.
Effects of thoracocentesis on pulmonary gas exchange.
Thorax 1983;38:747–750.
56. Effects of Thoracocentesis No Change in Oxygenation
Karetzky, M. S., G. A. Kothari, J. A. Fourre,
and A. U. Khan. 1978.
Effects of thoracocentesis on arterial oxygen
tension.
Respiration 36:96–103.
57. Effects of Thoracocentesis Worsen Oxygenation
Trapnell, D. H., and J. G. B. Thurston. 1970.
Unilateral pulmonary oedema after pleural
aspiration.
Lancet 661:1367–1369.
Brandstetter, R. D., and R. P. Cohen. 1979.
Hypoxemia after thoracocentesis: a
predictable and treatable condition.
J.A.M.A. 242:1060–1061.
58. Effects of Thoracocentesis Does What to Oxygenation?
Peter Doelken, MD, FCCP; Ricardo Abreu, MD,
FCCP; Steven A. Sahn, MD, FCCP and Paul
H. Mayo, MD, FCCP
Effect of Thoracentesis on Respiratory
Mechanics and Gas Exchange in the
Patient Receiving Mechanical Ventilation
Chest. 2006;130:1354-1361 Background: This study reports the effect of thoracentesis on respiratory mechanics and gas exchange in patients receiving mechanical ventilation.
Study design: Prospective.
Setting: University hospital.
Patients: Eight patient receiving mechanical ventilation with unilateral (n = 7) or bilateral (n = 1) large pleural effusions.
Intervention: Therapeutic thoracentesis (n = 9).
Measurements: Resistances of the respiratory system measured with the constant inspiratory flow interrupter method measuring peak pressure and plateau pressure, effective static compliance of the respiratory system (Cst,rs), work performed by the ventilator (Wv), arterial blood gases, mixed exhaled PCO2, and pleural liquid pressure (Pliq).
Results: Thoracentesis resulted in a significant decrease in Wv and Pliq. Thoracentesis had no significant effect on dynamic compliance of the respiratory system; Cst,rs; effective interrupter resistance of the respiratory system, or its subcomponents, ohmic resistance of the respiratory system and additional (non-ohmic) resistance of the respiratory system; or intrinsic positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEPi). Indices of gas exchange were not significantly changed by thoracentesis.
Conclusions: Thoracentesis in patients receiving mechanical ventilatory support results in significant reductions of Pliq and Wv. These changes were not accompanied by significant changes of resistance or compliance or by significant changes in gas exchange immediately after thoracentesis. The reduction of Wv after thoracentesis in patients receiving mechanical ventilation is not accompanied by predictable changes in inspiratory resistance and static compliance measured with routine clinical methods. The benefit of thoracentesis may be most pronounced in patients with high levels of PEEPi. Background: This study reports the effect of thoracentesis on respiratory mechanics and gas exchange in patients receiving mechanical ventilation.
Study design: Prospective.
Setting: University hospital.
Patients: Eight patient receiving mechanical ventilation with unilateral (n = 7) or bilateral (n = 1) large pleural effusions.
Intervention: Therapeutic thoracentesis (n = 9).
Measurements: Resistances of the respiratory system measured with the constant inspiratory flow interrupter method measuring peak pressure and plateau pressure, effective static compliance of the respiratory system (Cst,rs), work performed by the ventilator (Wv), arterial blood gases, mixed exhaled PCO2, and pleural liquid pressure (Pliq).
Results: Thoracentesis resulted in a significant decrease in Wv and Pliq. Thoracentesis had no significant effect on dynamic compliance of the respiratory system; Cst,rs; effective interrupter resistance of the respiratory system, or its subcomponents, ohmic resistance of the respiratory system and additional (non-ohmic) resistance of the respiratory system; or intrinsic positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEPi). Indices of gas exchange were not significantly changed by thoracentesis.
Conclusions: Thoracentesis in patients receiving mechanical ventilatory support results in significant reductions of Pliq and Wv. These changes were not accompanied by significant changes of resistance or compliance or by significant changes in gas exchange immediately after thoracentesis. The reduction of Wv after thoracentesis in patients receiving mechanical ventilation is not accompanied by predictable changes in inspiratory resistance and static compliance measured with routine clinical methods. The benefit of thoracentesis may be most pronounced in patients with high levels of PEEPi.
59. Effects of Thoracocentesis
Gas exchange and hemodynamics in experimental pleural effusion
[Laboratory Investigations]
Nishida, Osamu MD; Arellano, Ramiro MD, FRCPC; Cheng, Davy C. H. MD, FRCPC; DeMajo, Wilfred MD, FRCPC; Kavanagh, Brian P. MB, FRCPC
Critical Care Medicine:Volume 27(3)March 1999pp 583-587
61. Effects of Thoracocentesis
Talmor M, Hydo L, Gershenwald JG, Barie
PS.
Beneficial effects of chest tube drainage
of pleural effusion in acute respiratory
failure refractory to positive end
expiratory pressure ventilation.
Surgery. 1998 Feb;123(2):137-43. BACKGROUND: As part of an ongoing prospective evaluation of the response of acute respiratory failure (ARF) to ventilation with titrated amounts of positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP), a subset of patients with a poor response to the initial application of PEEP and radiographic evidence of pleural effusion was identified. The effusion(s) were treated by tube thoracostomy (TT) to test the hypothesis that drainage would have a favorable effect on oxygenation and compliance in critically ill patients with substantial pulmonary dysfunction. METHODS: Consecutive patients with ARF underwent a titrated progressive application of PEEP if arterial oxygen saturation was less than 90% on fraction of inspired oxygen less than 0.5. One or two thoracostomy tubes (TT) were placed afterward in patients with radiologic evidence of effusion who had a poor response to PEEP therapy. The lung injury score (LIS), PaO2:FiO2 (P:F), peak airway pressure, dynamic compliance, and TT output were recorded. Changes over time were analyzed by one-way analysis of variance with repeated measures. RESULTS: Nineteen of 199 patients needed TT. LIS was 3.0 +/- 0.1. Maximum PEEP was 16.6 +/ 1.0 cm H2O. TT drainage was 863 +/- 164 ml in the first 8 hours. Mortality was 63% (12 of 19) but only 41% (74 of 180) in the patients who did not require TT (p = 0.11). TT improved oxygenation and compliance immediately after insertion in 17 of 19 patients, and P:F remained statistically higher (245 +/- 29 versus 151 +/- 13, p < 0.01) 24 hours after TT drainage. There was no correlation between the volume of fluid removed and P:F either immediately (R2, 0.16) or 24 hours after TT (R2, 0.07). CONCLUSIONS: Drainage of pleural fluid resulted in a significant improvement in oxygenation in ARF patients with pleural effusions who were refractory to treatment with mechanical ventilation and PEEP. TT represents a simple and safe alternative for aggressive management of selected patients, obviating the inherent risk of pneumothorax with thoracentesis and possibly avoiding the need for more complex forms of support in this critically ill patient population.BACKGROUND: As part of an ongoing prospective evaluation of the response of acute respiratory failure (ARF) to ventilation with titrated amounts of positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP), a subset of patients with a poor response to the initial application of PEEP and radiographic evidence of pleural effusion was identified. The effusion(s) were treated by tube thoracostomy (TT) to test the hypothesis that drainage would have a favorable effect on oxygenation and compliance in critically ill patients with substantial pulmonary dysfunction. METHODS: Consecutive patients with ARF underwent a titrated progressive application of PEEP if arterial oxygen saturation was less than 90% on fraction of inspired oxygen less than 0.5. One or two thoracostomy tubes (TT) were placed afterward in patients with radiologic evidence of effusion who had a poor response to PEEP therapy. The lung injury score (LIS), PaO2:FiO2 (P:F), peak airway pressure, dynamic compliance, and TT output were recorded. Changes over time were analyzed by one-way analysis of variance with repeated measures. RESULTS: Nineteen of 199 patients needed TT. LIS was 3.0 +/- 0.1. Maximum PEEP was 16.6 +/ 1.0 cm H2O. TT drainage was 863 +/- 164 ml in the first 8 hours. Mortality was 63% (12 of 19) but only 41% (74 of 180) in the patients who did not require TT (p = 0.11). TT improved oxygenation and compliance immediately after insertion in 17 of 19 patients, and P:F remained statistically higher (245 +/- 29 versus 151 +/- 13, p < 0.01) 24 hours after TT drainage. There was no correlation between the volume of fluid removed and P:F either immediately (R2, 0.16) or 24 hours after TT (R2, 0.07). CONCLUSIONS: Drainage of pleural fluid resulted in a significant improvement in oxygenation in ARF patients with pleural effusions who were refractory to treatment with mechanical ventilation and PEEP. TT represents a simple and safe alternative for aggressive management of selected patients, obviating the inherent risk of pneumothorax with thoracentesis and possibly avoiding the need for more complex forms of support in this critically ill patient population.
62. Effects of Thoracocentesis
63. Effects of Thoracocentesis
64. Effects of Thoracocentesis
65. Effects of Thoracocentesis
66. Should we Drain Pleural Effusions?
67. The (Unsatisfactory) Answer?
68. Suggested Approach for ICU
69. Suggested Approach for ICU
70. Drain if pH < 7.2 ?
71. Pleural Infection
72. Cause of Pleural Infection
73. Suggested Approach for ICU
74. Suggested Approach for ICU
75. Suggested Approach for ICU
76. Suggested Approach for ICU
77. Suggested Approach for ICU
78. The sensitivity for exudate is 98% and specificity 83% with the above
criteria. Twenty-five per cent of patients with transudative pleural effusions
are mistakenly identified as having exudative pleural effusions
by the above criteria.5 Additional testing is therefore needed if a
patient identified as having an exudative pleural effusion appears clinically
to have a condition likely to produce a transudative effusion.The sensitivity for exudate is 98% and specificity 83% with the above
criteria. Twenty-five per cent of patients with transudative pleural effusions
are mistakenly identified as having exudative pleural effusions
by the above criteria.5 Additional testing is therefore needed if a
patient identified as having an exudative pleural effusion appears clinically
to have a condition likely to produce a transudative effusion.
79. Light’s Criteria
80. Another Suggested Approach
89. But……..
90. ....Maybe do these tests…….. “Thoracocentesis should be performed for
protein, LDH, pH, Gram stain, AAFB stain,
cytology, and microbiological culture using
sterile vials and blood culture bottles to
increase microbiological yield”
Medford
91. Just When YouThought YouHad Enough..
92. Just When YouThought YouHad Enough.. BTS Guidelines2003 UnilateralPleural Effusion
93. BTS Guidelines2003 UnilateralPleural Effusion
94. Confused?
95. Order the Lot!
96. Investigations Additional Tests for Exudative Effusions
Total & Differential Cell Counts
Smear, Stain and Culture
Pleural Fluid Glucose Level
Pleural Fluid LDH Level
Pleural Fluid Tests for Cancer
Pleural Fluid Markers for TB
97. Investigations Other Specific Tests for Exudative Effusions
Pleural Fluid pH
Pleural Fluid Amylase Level
Immunological Tests
ANA / RF
Serum D-Dimer
Thoracoscopy / Pleural Biopsy
98. Investigations Additional Tests for Exudative Effusions
Total & Differential Cell Counts
Smear, Stain and Culture
Pleural Fluid Glucose Level
Pleural Fluid LDH Level
Pleural Fluid Tests for Cancer
Pleural Fluid Markers for TB
99. Total & Differential Cell Counts >50% Neutrophils = Acute Process
Lower counts in TB and Malignancy
Small Lymphocyte preponderance = TB or Cancer or post CABG
>10% Eosinophils = haemo/pneumo-thorax or unusual cases:
Drugs (dantrolene, bromocriptine, nitrofurantoin), asbestos exposure, paragonimiasis & Churg-Strauss Syndrome
100. Investigations Additional Tests for Exudative Effusions
Total & Differential Cell Counts
Smear, Stain and Culture
Pleural Fluid Glucose Level
Pleural Fluid LDH Level
Pleural Fluid Tests for Cancer
Pleural Fluid Markers for TB
101. Smears & Cultures Use Blood Culture Bottles
Smears may reveal fungi, rarely mycobacteria
102. Investigations Additional Tests for Exudative Effusions
Total & Differential Cell Counts
Smear, Stain and Culture
Pleural Fluid Glucose Level
Pleural Fluid LDH Level
Pleural Fluid Tests for Cancer
Pleural Fluid Markers for TB
103. Pleural Glucose Usually similar to plasma in transudates and most exudates
Low in:
RA
Tuberculosis
Empyema
Malignancies with extensive pleural involvement
Haemothorax / Lupus / Churg-Strauss / Paragonimiasis
104. Investigations Additional Tests for Exudative Effusions
Total & Differential Cell Counts
Smear, Stain and Culture
Pleural Fluid Glucose Level
Pleural Fluid LDH Level
Pleural Fluid Tests for Cancer
Pleural Fluid Markers for TB
105. Pleural LDH Correlates with degree pleural Inflammation
If increases with repeated sampling suggests increasing inflammation
Therefore more aggressive diagnostic approach required
106. Investigations Additional Tests for Exudative Effusions
Total & Differential Cell Counts
Smear, Stain and Culture
Pleural Fluid Glucose Level
Pleural Fluid LDH Level
Pleural Fluid Tests for Cancer
Pleural Fluid Markers for TB
107. Pleural Fluid Tests for Cancer Cytology – fast, efficient & minimally invasive
Yields:
Metastatic adenoCa – 70%
Lymphoma – 25-50%
Sarcoma – 25%
Squamous Cell Carcinoma – 20%
Mesothelioma – 10%
Thoracoscopy Next Investigation
108. Investigations Additional Tests for Exudative Effusions
Total & Differential Cell Counts
Smear, Stain and Culture
Pleural Fluid Glucose Level
Pleural Fluid LDH Level
Pleural Fluid Tests for Cancer
Pleural Fluid Markers for TB
109. Tests for TB in Pleural Fluid Untreated effusion resolves, but (extra) pulmonary disease develops in 50%
Adenosine Deaminase
Interferon gamma
PCR for Mycobacterial DNA
110. Investigations Other Specific Tests for Exudative Effusions
Pleural Fluid pH
Pleural Fluid Amylase Level
Immunological Tests
ANA / RF
Serum D-Dimer
Thoracoscopy / Pleural Biopsy
111. Pleural pH Normal 7.62 due to active transport of Bicorbonate
Low pH due to inflammatory / infiltrative conditions
Urinothorax only transudate with low pH
Parapneumonic effusion pH >7.2 has poor prognosis
pH<7.2 in cancer suggests life expectancy
less than 30 days
112. Investigations Other Specific Tests for Exudative Effusions
Pleural Fluid pH
Pleural Fluid Amylase Level
Immunological Tests
ANA / RF
Serum D-Dimer
Thoracoscopy / Pleural Biopsy
113. Pleural Amylase High level (>200 U /dl) occurs in:
Pancreatitis (acute & chronic)
Oesophageal rupture
114. Investigations Other Specific Tests for Exudative Effusions
Pleural Fluid pH
Pleural Fluid Amylase Level
Immunological Tests
ANA / RF
Serum D-Dimer
Thoracoscopy / Pleural Biopsy
115. Immunological Tests Add little
Check serum for immunological markers
116. Investigations Other Specific Tests for Exudative Effusions
Pleural Fluid pH
Pleural Fluid Amylase Level
Immunological Tests
ANA / RF
Serum D-Dimer
Thoracoscopy / Pleural Biopsy
117. Investigations Other Specific Tests for Exudative Effusions
Pleural Fluid pH
Pleural Fluid Amylase Level
Immunological Tests
ANA / RF
Serum D-Dimer
Thoracoscopy / Pleural Biopsy
118. Pleural Effusion of Unknown Cause About 15%
Try Thoracoscopy (high yield for TB)
Pleural Biopsy (closed/open)
119. Investigations
120. Post Thoracocentesis Post drainage will you order a CXR?
121. Post Thoracocentesis Post drainage will you order a CXR?
122. Issues I Have Left Out Drain or Tap
Image Guided Drainage
Tube size & type
Pleurodesis
Fibrinolysis
Surgery
“RAPID” Assessment
And others………..
123. Summary Basics
Diagnosis
Presence of Effusion
Type of Effusion
How to Manage an Effusion
What the Various Tests Mean
Issues
124. Thank You
125. Difficult Questions Will Evoke The Following Response