1 / 21

Investor – State Arbitration

Investor – State Arbitration. Armand de Mestral. What is ISA?. Special form of international arbitration provided by bilateral investment treaties (BITs) to protect the interests of foreign investors and foreign investments 2700 total today Most BITs between developed and LDCs

Patman
Download Presentation

Investor – State Arbitration

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Investor – State Arbitration Armand de Mestral

  2. What is ISA? • Special form of international arbitration provided by bilateral investment treaties (BITs) to protect the interests of foreign investors and foreign investments • 2700 total today • Most BITs between developed and LDCs • Several hundreds between developed states (Canada – USA; EU Member States; • Promoted by regional trade associations ASEAN, MERCOSUR etc • Major LDCs also – China, India major negotiators

  3. Why is ISA significant? • Legally • Profesionally • Politically

  4. Legal Basis of ISA • BITs • FTAs • NAFTA Ch 11 • ICSID

  5. Where is ISA conducted? • ICSID • ICC Paris • LCIA London • Stockholm Chamber of Commerce • Dubai, HK, SPORE

  6. Rights usually granted to “foreign investors” and “foreign investments” under BITs • MFN • NT • Fair and equitable treatment • No performance requirements • No expropriation (direct or indirect) without compensation

  7. How does ISA operate? • Treaty promise to the foreign investor to arbitrate claims • No need to negotiate the establishment of an arbitration

  8. ISA Arbitrators • Who is chosen? • How are they chosen? • To whom are they responsible?

  9. Claims • Notice of arbitration • Statement of claim • Must be from a foreign investor in respect of a foreign investment • Must allege economic loss due to failure to respect standards required by the treaty • Claim seeks monetary compensation only

  10. Kinds of claims made • Asian Agricultural Products v Sri Lanka 1987 • Wena Hotels v Egypt 1998 • Argentine claims since 2002 (40) • Loewen v USA 2002 • Methanex v USA • UPS v Canada • Canadian Cattlemen V USA • Waste Management v Mexico 1998 • HFCS Cases v Mexico • Dow Chemical v Canada

  11. Procedure • Notice – Statement – Procedural orders • Challenge to Jurisdiction • Merits- presentation of evidence – written pleadings – oral pleading – deliberation – Award • Damages • Costs • Review - ICSID only • Time needed – 2 – 5 years

  12. Complex litigation • Teams of lawyers and other experts • Governments • Private practice • Canadian expertise

  13. How do arbitrators decide? • Duty to conduct a fair hearing • Equality of the parties • Independence of the arbitrators • Decision must be motivated and grounded in law

  14. Applicable law • Domestic law • BIT • International law • General principles of law • Delicacy of the process • Novel use of international law – determining the rights of private persons and companies

  15. The state as a party – consequences? • Compare with WTO or NAFTA ch 20 • Can the state still control the proceedings? • Does the state enjoy all the privileges of sovereignty? • Are parties really to be treated as equals? • Yes

  16. ISA public or private? • Is this just another form of international commercial arbitration? • No • Is it purely public? • No • Issues are mixed and arbitrators have to be aware of the public and private dimensions of issues before them

  17. Necessary balance • Sri Lanka – defence that there was a military operation which could not be second guessed • Argentine cases – plea of necessity by Argentina – need to protect public interest in a crisis • Waste Management – need to give the state room to regulate but sanction unfair and disproportionate means chosen

  18. Criticisms of ISA • Secret • Private disposition of public issues • Avoiding normal national courts • Promotion of an international corporate agenda • Blindness to the public interest • Special privilege given to foreigners • Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? • Unfair to LDCs • Inappropriate in a democracy

  19. How have governments responded to criticisms • Agree – try to get out – Venezuela, Bolivia, Ecuador • Accept - as the price of attracting investment – Mexico • Legislate to make enforcement harder - Grave political crisis – Argentina today • Canada and USA – decision to make all documents, pleadings and decisions and hearings public • ICSID attempt to follow

  20. Situation of ISA Today? • 2700 BITs • Many trade agrements have investment chapters • China has 110 BITs • Over 200 cases decided • Another 150 cases pending • Challenge to ISA or ICSID by Venezuela, Bolivia and Ecuador • Considerable concern in developed democracies – Canada, USA, Japan, EU Member states • Canada and USA changing model BITs to incorporate provisions on public interest and exceptions

  21. Why did Canada buy into this process? • NAFTA 1994 Ch 11 (Canada – USA FTA 1988) • Ethyl, S.D. Myers • Canadian BITs (FIPAs) – 30 in force • 15 more under negotiation • Possible inclusion in future Canada – EU trade agreement

More Related